-
8 votes
-
Turkey warns Russia an attack on Idlib will turn it into ‘lake of blood’
8 votes -
Aggrieved Kurdish fighters quietly join Syrian regime side in battle for Idlib
7 votes -
I survived the Warsaw ghetto. Here are the lessons I’d like to pass on
10 votes -
Fox News violates Poland's holocaust law with reference to "Polish death camp"
14 votes -
Axes of evil. Four days, two murders, and one poplar tree that almost ignited World War III.
4 votes -
Eritrea has slashed conscription. Will it stem the flow of refugees?
2 votes -
Tillerson's war: The invasion of Qatar
7 votes -
Number of children killed in Saudi-American strike on schoolbus grows to twenty-nine
10 votes -
Saudi forces attack Yemeni schoolbus, at least twelve shildren have died
12 votes -
Dozens dead in Yemen as bus carrying children hit by airstrike
6 votes -
Russia is quietly seizing territory in Georgia as it warns of a ‘horrible conflict’ if the Eurasian country joins NATO
21 votes -
South Sudan government and rebels sign peace deal to end five years of civil war
6 votes -
Axes of evil - Four days, two murders, and one poplar tree that almost ignited World War III
8 votes -
Water scarcity and conflict
5 votes -
At last, a law that could have stopped Tony Blair and George W Bush invading. The Hague’s new crime of aggression might give belligerent heads of states a reason to pause.
10 votes -
What, if anything, makes a morally good war?
I've been consuming the darkness that is wartime histories from the past three or four centuries and I feel like I've encountered a lot of people who had what they believed to be justifiable...
I've been consuming the darkness that is wartime histories from the past three or four centuries and I feel like I've encountered a lot of people who had what they believed to be justifiable reasons to launch wars against other powers. There are people who thought they had divine right to a particular position of power and so would launch a war to assert that god-given right. There are people who believed in a citizen's right to have some (any) say in how their tax money gets used in government and so would fight wars over that. People would fight wars to, as John Cleese once said, "Keep China British." Many wars are started to save the honor of a country/nation. Some are started in what is claimed to be self-defense and later turns out to have been a political play instigated to end what has been a political thorn in their sides.
In all this time, I've struggled to really justify many of these wars, but some of that comes with the knowledge of what other wars have cost in terms of human carnage and suffering. For some societies in some periods, the military is one of the few vehicles to social mobility (and I think tend to think social mobility is grease that keeps a society functioning). Often these conflicts come down to one man's penis and the inability to swallow their pride to find a workable solution unless at the end of a bayonet. These conflicts also come with the winning powers taking the opportunity to rid themselves of political threats and exacting new harms on the defeated powers (which comes back around again the next time people see each other in a conflict).
So help keep me from embracing a totally pacifistic approach to war. When is a war justifiable? When it is not only morally acceptable but a moral imperative to go to war? Please point to examples throughout history where these situations have happened, if you can (though if you're prepared to admit that there has been no justifiable war that you're aware of, I suppose that's fine if bitter).
20 votes -
The Seige and Recapture of easter Ghouta, Syria
4 votes -
A day in the life of a Kabul emergency room
13 votes -
Hiroshima - a 1946 piece exploring how six survivors experienced the atomic bombing and its aftermath
9 votes -
Australian SAS soldiers committed alleged war crimes in Afghanistan: official report
5 votes -
A warning to those visiting Auschwitz
8 votes -
Big Tech firms march to the beat of Pentagon, CIA despite dissension
4 votes -
Russian pilot found after three decades missing in Afghanistan
6 votes -
Battle for rebel-held Yemen port may trigger humanitarian disaster. Saudi-led forces are eight miles from Hodeidah, where 80% of aid supplies are handled.
4 votes -
China steps up pace in new nuclear arms race with US and Russia as experts warn of rising risk of conflict
7 votes -
The Battle of Ilerda (49 B.C.E.)
4 votes