-
5 votes
-
In my opinion, censorship is a bad way to combat hate speech.
(Let me make this clear before you continue reading, I don't know any good solutions) Recently, all over the internet, I feel like I am seeing more and more companies filtering out content that...
(Let me make this clear before you continue reading, I don't know any good solutions)
Recently, all over the internet, I feel like I am seeing more and more companies filtering out content that are considered hate speech. I personally do not like this for two reasons.
- I think it is a band-aid solution. People who have their voice taken away from themselves are not suddenly going to change their mind.
- In a way, it is a form of removing freedom of speech. Now, I understand that a lot of the companies that are censoring hate speech are doing it primarily for the sake of sponsors, but I mean this in a more broad scope.
- It is effectively hiding societal problems.
I think one argument for the increased censorship is: even if it doesn't combat hate speech, it stops the spreading of hate speech. By spreading, I mean more people believing that hate speech. Though at first this could be a good idea, I think it is the wrong way to go about it. I really don't know what exactly is the right way to deal with this issue. Maybe more inclusion of different communities? Maybe education? Learn how to think critically?
Here are a couple other things I have been thinking about, but I am not too sure about. I do not know if they are true or not, but if any of you could provide more insight, I would like to know more:
- Hate speech is actually lower than ever. The reason why some people feel like it is higher is because the hate speech is entering to people's bubbles through the internet. Before the internet, there was still that kind of talk, it was just in a different medium.
- Though not hate speech, but in a way related, with Anti-vax, the people who are most susceptible to converting to an anti-vaxxer, are parents. A lot of times these are the people who didn't grow up with the internet, the way they view the internet is not exactly how younger people view the internet. There is more doubt in what we see online between younger people than older.
And I have had people say I must be a white upper class person to have these kinds of opinions. No. I am not white. Not upper class. I have dealt with racism in one way or another for all of my childhood, less so as an adult.
28 votes -
By censoring Arthur’s same-sex wedding, Alabama Public Television betrayed Mr. Rogers’ legacy
7 votes -
EFF launches "TOSsed Out", a new project to highlight ways that Terms of Service and other rules are unevenly and unthinkingly applied to people by online services
12 votes -
2600 denied access to UK stores due to fear of "negative publicity"
6 votes -
Russian court fines Internet user hundreds of dollars for calling Vladimir Putin an ‘unbelievable fuckwit’
20 votes -
When a country bans social media - Sri Lanka’s ban on social media forces a question nobody wants to ask: what if a global media network is impossible?
5 votes -
State Duma passes law ‘isolating’ Russian Internet
7 votes -
'We need to keep our language alive': Inside a Uyghur bookshop in Istanbul
10 votes -
Welcome to the prude internet: No more sex talk allowed
32 votes -
What are your thoughts on the New Zealand government censoring the possession and distribution of the Christchurch shooter's manifesto?
Personally, free speech to me means that while platforms like Facebook and YouTube are not required to host it, if they so choose to host it they should be able to do so. Speech should not be...
Personally, free speech to me means that while platforms like Facebook and YouTube are not required to host it, if they so choose to host it they should be able to do so. Speech should not be restricted because it is offensive or because it is viewed as immoral. This applies doubly so to political speech, which terrorism is the most extreme form.
30 votes -
Christchurch mosque shootings: 'Manifesto' deemed objectionable
16 votes -
“The big error was that she was caught”: The untold story behind the mysterious disappearance of Fan Bingbing, the world’s biggest movie star
12 votes -
Putin has signed into law Russia's ‘fake news’ and ‘Internet insults’ bans
8 votes -
The Simpsons pulled an episode featuring Michael Jackson. That was a mistake
20 votes -
Taxed, throttled or thrown in jail: Africa's new internet paradigm
7 votes -
The internet, but not as we know it: Life online in China, Cuba, India and Russia
13 votes -
Why the UK's porn block is one of the worst ideas ever
30 votes -
Google takes down Artstation android app for explicit content
11 votes -
Google’s secret China project “effectively ended” after internal confrontation
12 votes -
Google shut out privacy and security teams from secret China project
22 votes -
Reddit silently introduces an option to report content as violating the German NetzDG law
27 votes -
The news is bad in Hungary: "Viktor Orban didn’t like what the press was reporting, so he took it over."
11 votes -
In Iran, state sanctioned messaging apps are the new hallmark of internet nationalisation
4 votes -
China blocks website that revealed spyware and "re-education" camp monitoring
9 votes -
Nadine Gordimer wrote furiously, in every sense. The Nobel Prize-winning South African writer cared very much how people think, and not at all what people thought of her.
7 votes -
Why are African governments criminalising online speech? Because they fear it.
8 votes -
Stop press: has a journalist revolt at Forbes Russia saved the magazine’s independence?
7 votes -
Newly discovered letter by Galileo shows that he lightly edited his original words to appease the Catholic Church
10 votes -
Text of u/DivestTrump's post about T_D and Russia propaganda that was deleted
51 votes -
Twitch vanishes in China weeks after spike in popularity
21 votes -
Google China prototype links searches to phone numbers
10 votes -
Google employees are reportedly resigning over China search efforts
30 votes -
Signs of life: Does a music festival in a desert offer hope for cultural reform in Uzbekistan?
3 votes -
Is This The Beginning Of The End For Facebook?
18 votes -
The other political correctness: America's elite universities are censoring themselves on China
11 votes -
Github Joins the fight against the Mandatory Webfilters on the EU Copyright Reform
7 votes -
Google employees protest secret work on censored search engine for China
11 votes -
Google has kicked Ahoy! the anti-censorship app from the Chrome store
22 votes -
What are your thoughts on Wikileaks?
I'm curious to see what the public consensus towards the site is nowadays. They have been controversial since their inception, but no matter what you think of them, there is no denying that the...
I'm curious to see what the public consensus towards the site is nowadays. They have been controversial since their inception, but no matter what you think of them, there is no denying that the information they've released has sparked massive debate around the world.
13 votes -
China's rebel generation and the rise of 'hot words'
8 votes -
Social Media Bans Actually Work
13 votes -
Russians are facing criminal prosecution for sharing memes online, thanks to anti-extremism laws
10 votes -
Engineers say 'no thanks' to Silicon Valley recruiters, citing ethical concerns
29 votes -
Censorship 2.0: Shadowy forces controlling online conversations
9 votes -
A generation grows up in China without Facebook, Google, or Twitter
7 votes -
Killing speech softly: How the world’s biggest tech companies are quietly censoring critical expression in the Middle East
6 votes -
US Lawmakers pressure Google over "deeply troubling" China censorship project
9 votes -
Google struggles to contain employee backlash over China censorship plans
26 votes -
Bangladesh students attacked during Dhaka protest for road safety
18 votes