-
8 votes
-
Trump Pardons Conservative Says Lifestyle Maven Stewart May Be Next
3 votes -
Rosanne Barr and now Samantha Bee, does the punishment fit the crime?
You may have heard that Roseanne Barr made a horrible comment/joke on her Twitter account - this lead to the cancelation of her show, Rosanne. Then, Samantha Bee made a horrible comment/joke on...
You may have heard that Roseanne Barr made a horrible comment/joke on her Twitter account - this lead to the cancelation of her show, Rosanne.
Then, Samantha Bee made a horrible comment/joke on her show about Ivanka Trump that has prompted an apology, and an advertiser exit (so far).
If Samantha Bee is canceled too, does the punishment fit? Did Rosanne deserve to see her show canceled? Is there (or should there be) a limit to what comedians can say on TV or online?
Note: Typed this out on mobile, so may need corrections later. Edit: Added links, corrections. Edit again, update Bee's details.
13 votes -
Donald Trump hits Canada, Mexico, EU with steel and aluminum tariffs
19 votes -
US President Donald Trump signs 'Right to Try Act' aimed at helping terminally ill patients seek drug treatments
12 votes -
President Trump violated the First Amendment by blocking users @realdonaldtrump
20 votes -
China slams US President Donald Trump's ‘flip-flop’ on tariffs as trade spat worsens
12 votes -
Trump's Memorial Day Message Slammed as 'Grossest, Most Inappropriate' in History
9 votes -
Trumps' Twitter is a public forum, rules federal judge: Good!
8 votes -
Is the United States on its way to losing its hegemonic status?
On the heels of President Trump pulling out of talks with North Korea over nuclear disarmament in the Korean peninsula, the United States' pending withdrawal from the Paris agreement (coming soon!...
On the heels of President Trump pulling out of talks with North Korea over nuclear disarmament in the Korean peninsula, the United States' pending withdrawal from the Paris agreement (coming soon! ... the day after the next presidential election), and the United States' unilateral withdrawal from the Iran nuclear agreement, combined with ongoing Russian and Iranian leadership in resolving the Syrian civil war and Chinese leadership in talks with North Korea, we seem to be heading toward an ambiguous point in international geopolitics.
So this question is simple and nasty: Is the United States on its way to losing its status as the unquestioned dominant world power in the international order?
If it is on its way off the top of the food chain, who will challenge it? Are we returning to a cold war-style era or are the lines shifting and different? If the United States is not on its way to losing its dominant status, how might it maintain its footing in a world that seems increasingly disillusioned with it?
13 votes -
Trump Ignores Court Ruling That He Can't Block Twitter Critics: 'President Thinks He's Above The Law'
15 votes -
US President Donald Trump calls off meeting with North Korea's Kim Jong Un
21 votes -
US court bars Donald Trump from blocking users on Twitter
9 votes -
We're starting to see a lot of repeat questions, so let me make an introduction to Tildes post for everyone just arriving
It's been an interesting couple of weeks while we all decompress post-reddit and think about the future of democratic online forums. Most of the relevant topics have already been discussed in...
It's been an interesting couple of weeks while we all decompress post-reddit and think about the future of democratic online forums. Most of the relevant topics have already been discussed in multiple threads, and rather than having repeats, I'd like to invite everyone to comment on these threads themselves - and to read the comments that are already there. You'll find most of the solutions we've been thinking about explained in some detail, and we do want your feedback on these ideas to help make them better.
I suggest you bookmark this page. This thread is getting a bit lost in the shuffle, and it's really the best nexus of information about tildes we have at the moment. It'll take you quite a while to read all of this, so since we don't have 'save posts' here yet, a bookmark will have to do. We're also updating the links here as new discussions form. If you think a discussion should be added here, please reply to this thread with the link and I'll take care of editing it into the main post. When you see new users asking repeat questions, please link them to this post. Thanks for your patience while we work through all of this. :)
Let's get started.
-
A group is its own worst enemy. This will help you think better about online community management. Also, if you haven't yet, play The Game Of Trust.
-
Community Moderators? How do we moderate effectively, and fairly? Do we moderate at all? (everyone should read this monster) Also, see round two.
-
How do we handle communities that get too big? It's a doozy, the inverse of reddit.
-
Do we allow Fluff content? Just how do we select for quality instead of popularity, or even define quality, anyway?
-
Do we allow for political content? How do we handle one of the most heated categories of discussion? Also see the followup.
-
What do we do about "Fake News?" And you thought politics was hard? :D
-
Can we create new ~groups? Will users be able to create them? Yes, eventually... but it's not that simple.
-
How do we stop bots from wrecking the place? What about the bots that are useful?
-
Why exactly is my comment box at the bottom, rather than the top? We have reasons. ;)
-
Anonymous posting? You betcha. Privacy is not just a buzzword.
-
Can we think of a better name than votes? Not really, not yet. Got any ideas?
-
Funding - how do we pay for all of this? Nothing is free, after all. No ads, no pay to play, but what else could we do?
-
Tildes Gold? No, something much better - the exemplary upvote, because you need a limited use vote to highlight the things you think are top quality. If we all use them together, it just might work.
-
What changes need to be made to the comment tags before they are re-enabled? It's a tough problem.
-
Should we make the site publicly visible? For users without accounts to read.
-
Moving the vote count to the vote button. It's the little things.
And, of course, our first ban. In fact we're up to two now.
It's not all serious, though!
- Drop by and introduce yourself. Also see round two and round one.
- Where are you from? Quite the diversity in countries already!
- Our first Trump thread. Went better than expected.
- What about cultural exchanges? Great idea there.
- First impressions? Once you've slogged through all this, tell us what you think about the site. ;)
- Some simple user scripts. It's not RES, but it's a start.
Please do take some time to browse through everything in ~tildes. It's a cross between theoryofreddit, ideasfortheadmins, and announcements. That's where we talk turkey. There's a new discussion there every day.
I also want to make one important contrast about what this site intends to be.
Reddit and Voat: Democratic republic based on popularity. 'Free speech' forums.
Tidles: Democratic meritocracy based on quality. 'Civil speech' forum.Enjoy yourselves, post some content, make some new friends. This sweet honeymoon phase won't last forever, and it's one of the best parts of a new site. Remember, as long as you're civil here, you are never going to have any problems.
60 votes -
-
Donald Trump lawyer 'paid by Ukraine' to arrange White House talks
5 votes -
NFL clubs to be fined if players kneel during anthem
19 votes -
Michael Cohen’s business partner agrees to cooperate as part of plea deal
7 votes -
Less than a month to Trump-Kim summit, White House Communications Agency (WHCA) releases its “trip coin.”
@peteralexander: Less than a month to Trump-Kim summit, White House Communications Agency (WHCA) releases its "trip coin." This is #74 of 250 made.
4 votes -
The princes, the president and the fortune seekers
3 votes -
So far this site has been mostly politics-averse, but I am curious if I am alone as an MAGA/Trump voter/supporter in a sea of reddit mods
I've seen a few remarks here and there that have implied sort of matter-of-factly that places like /r/The_Donald have no redeeming value, the community members are awful (and undesirable to have...
I've seen a few remarks here and there that have implied sort of matter-of-factly that places like /r/The_Donald have no redeeming value, the community members are awful (and undesirable to have here), their ideas are all reprehensible, etc. I assume that this is mostly just due to the demographic coming primarily from popular reddit mod teams where being anti-Trump is sort of an unspoken requirement - but I don't really know for certain.
It reminds me a little of this woman in a class i had once, who spoke to me about atheists, assumed I was christian just as a matter of course. It's kind of an awkward situation to find yourself in. I don't identify as an atheist, but if someone is mildly insulting atheists, it's uncomfortable. You have to be a covert conservative (or covert center-right, or even left-leaning Trump voter) or else you risk being blasted/flamed/mocked/etc. in places like reddit.
Part of what attracted me to Tildes was the sales pitch that it is to be a community for civil conversation, no hate-speech/bigotry. I think that's a perfect environment for political discussion - far more than shit-flinging and nuclear downvoting on /r/politics. So even if I'm the only MAGA person here, maybe there's a chance we can actually have civil conversations on topics we might initially disagree on...?
Edit: wow! Really happy to have these conversations with folks. Sad that i haven't encountered any fellow (public) Trump voters/supporters yet but very pleased that things have been civil as advertised. ;) Apologies for slow responses, trying to give proper thought and consideration to all the comments!
Edit2: gotta head to bed. sorry to anyone i haven't responded to questions from. feeling a bit like a novelty "And here's our token Trump voter. ha ha, he sure is a quirky one, isn't he, that crazy dictator-enabler!" xP. I'll try to answer any questions I've missed tomorrow. Sleep well, all (well, all who are going to sleep before I get back).
Edit3: Thanks for the open engagement, all you people who live in a different reality!
Still a bit bummed there aren't any MAGA friends here yet, but I've been blown away by how cordial most of you have been (i hope we can retain this culture into the future of the site). For those who are just coming in and don't want to read everything, I'd say a tl;dr of the conversations I've had below is:
- most people here want to engage with others on important topics without the shit flinging,
- some people express disbelief that someone can not be a bigot or racist and vote for Donald Trump,
- I've been repeating in various conversations the Laurel and Yanny thing is a great metaphor for the polarized camps experiencing different realities, seeing different movies on the same screen.
I'm continuing to try to reply to questions, and in the spirit of not provoking heated emotions I have been trying not to argue any of my political beliefs except that both sides are seeing different realities.
90 votes -
Trump Jr. and Other Aides Met With Gulf Emissary Offering Help to Win Election
6 votes -
Bill Gates: Trump twice asked me the difference between HIV and HPV
18 votes -
How Mueller’s first year compares to Watergate, Iran-Contra and Whitewater
5 votes -
Missing files in the Treasury Department's FINCEN database motivated a law-enforcement official to leak Michael Cohen's financial records
4 votes -
US President Donald Trump reports apparent payment through his personal attorney to adult-film star Stormy Daniels in a new financial disclosure
5 votes -
Democrats Flip a Pennsylvania Seat, Making 41 Since Trump’s Inauguration
4 votes -
A judge just denied Paul Manafort's motion to dismiss the indictment against him in DC
6 votes -
John Kelly's interview with NPR comes with an editor's note warning that it contains offensive language
6 votes -
John Bolton pushing to eliminate White House cyber job
5 votes -
Abuse of power: US President Donald Trump just signed an executive order stating that he is allowed to get inside John McCain’s coffin with him
9 votes -
Feds tapped US President Donald Trump lawyer Michael Cohen's phones
6 votes -
Rudy Giuliani: US President Donald Trump reimbursed Michael Cohen for $130,000 Stormy Daniels payment
5 votes -
Trump to add Clinton impeachment lawyer Emmet Flood to replace Ty Cobb
4 votes -
Robert Mueller has dozens of inquiries for US President Donald Trump in broad quest on Russia ties and obstruction
7 votes