Explain Linux controversies to me

kfwyre
2025-06-17T11:37:15Z

I'm one of those mythical Linux users who has been using it for years but has little to no idea what's going on behind the scenes or under the hood.

In my time using it, I've sort of passively gleaned that certain things are controversial, but I don't necessarily know why. It's also hard for me to know if these are just general intra-community drama/bikeshedding, or if these are actually big, meaningful issues.

If you're someone who's in the know, here's your chance to lay out a Linux controversy in a way that's understandable by someone like me, who can't tell you why people always make "GNU/Linux" jokes for some reason whenever people mention "Linux."

Here are some things that have pinged for me as controversial in my time using Linux:

Unity

Canonical

Deepin

systemd

Arch

GNOME

Manjaro

Kali

Rust in the kernel

elementaryOS

Linus Torvalds

Snaps

Wayland

Something about a university being banned from contributing to Linux

NVIDIA drivers

Package managers vs. Snaps/Flatpaks

There are certainly more -- these are just the ones I can remember off the top of my head.

Replies don't have to be limited to the above topics. I'm interested in getting the lay of the land about any Linux controversy.

IMPORTANT

This topic is intended for learning, not bickering.

Please try to explain a controversy as fairly as you can.

Please try to not re-ignite a flame war about a specific controversy.

It's fine to discuss these in good faith, but I do not want this topic to become yet another Linux battleground online. There are plenty of those already!

Comments URL: https://tildes.net/~tech/1omw/explain_linux_controversies_to_me

Votes: 89

Comments: 78