I think it was simon Clark who mentioned that even though we missed 1.5c (which most climate scientists knew was going to happen) we have also prevented the worst case scenario which was something...
I think it was simon Clark who mentioned that even though we missed 1.5c (which most climate scientists knew was going to happen) we have also prevented the worst case scenario which was something like 4c. So we are narrowing the scope of heating.
Its not great but as i told an environmental scientist friend recently. There's always eco terrorism to fall back on if we want to get shit done.
edit: here is a link to a climate obstruction book that is free to download. Iv not read the whole thing yet but the parts I have read are really good.
Aside from the morality, the sources are too diffuse and global for terroristic activity to have any real impact on emissions. Not to mention that the backlash would play right into the hands of...
Aside from the morality, the sources are too diffuse and global for terroristic activity to have any real impact on emissions. Not to mention that the backlash would play right into the hands of fossil fuel industry-sponsored fascists.
You might put the fear into executives of a corporation, but entire nation-states that profit from fossil fuel extraction are a different ballgame. And they're not changing their behavior even when their activities are making their countries uninhabitable.
China really took the only course of action available - making fossil fuel use so uncompetitive and uneconomical that only propagandized fools continue to pursue it as the primary energy source.
Edit: If you really want to see change, get corrupt money out of politics. It's not that no one knows what to do, it's that our leaders are thoroughly bought and paid for.
Honestly, it's so hard to not feel hopeless and defeated when looking at the prospects of not only ending the corruption that controls our politics, but also overcoming the widespread propaganda...
Honestly, it's so hard to not feel hopeless and defeated when looking at the prospects of not only ending the corruption that controls our politics, but also overcoming the widespread propaganda that dominates the discourse in this country. Even the most popular and progressive politicians tend to stay away from the Green New Deal. Isn't that crazy? We've had three presidential elections in the last 10 years and I can probably count on one hand the number of times that the environment/climate change was brought up in the debates. And of those handful of times that it was brought up, the only time a question like that gained any traction in the media was because it was asked by Ken fucking Bone, and his question - which was ignored in the media coverage in favor of his jolly little brand of pervertry - was framed by asking how they would protect his jerb in the fossil fuel industry! We live in an insane society.
Meanwhile, what's the earliest we could see major campaign finance reform? Three years? And that's assuming you get both Congress and the president to expand and stuff the supreme court. Then you still have the business of replacing those in office who are subservient to the fossil fuel industry (which would take years) and hope they haven't developed a clever workaround to make use of the millions of dollars that currently buy elections and politicians, and convince people to care about it in a media environment that, at best, will ignore or downplay the severity of the issue.
Really the only way I see us doing what we need to by the time it needs to be done is if we get an unbelievably popular, talented, and bulletproof politician (like Obama + Mamdani + Tom Hanks x10000, aka Mechazobama) to come in during a time of crisis and do a little Trump-like authoritarianism/strong-arming to force the regulations, infrastructure, and global coordination that we need. Either that or we get about a dozen Katrina-level environmental catastrophies in a single year that are so horrifying and devastating that it's like 9/11 and the Lisbon Earthquake rolled into one.
FWIW, Biden actually got the ball rolling with the biggest "Green New Deal" the US has ever enacted ... he just called it an intrastructure & jobs act. There's a lesson to be learned there. If the...
FWIW, Biden actually got the ball rolling with the biggest "Green New Deal" the US has ever enacted ... he just called it an intrastructure & jobs act. There's a lesson to be learned there. If the Dems had won in 2024, the US would be well on track right now.
What does it really mean for politicians to stray away from the Green New Deal? From what I remember of it I honestly was not impressed and thought it was kind of nothing.
What does it really mean for politicians to stray away from the Green New Deal? From what I remember of it I honestly was not impressed and thought it was kind of nothing.
I'm saying that tackling the environmental crisis is mostly an afterthought, even among the politicians who supposedly support taking aggressive measures to do so. The climate investment that was...
I'm saying that tackling the environmental crisis is mostly an afterthought, even among the politicians who supposedly support taking aggressive measures to do so. The climate investment that was in the IRA was great, but not nearly enough, and the only thing floating around right now that matches the scope of the issue is the GND. It's less about the GND specifically and more about the absence of any real effort to address the issue or bring it into the conversation.
The lack of attention on climate change is not doing us any favors. Because while Democrats have shifted their entire focus towards affordability issues and - for the progressive wing - our relationship with Israel, Republicans and Donald Trump have been filling that void by hyping up fossil fuels. As a result, there has been a 20-point swing towards support for prioritizing fossil fuels over renewables. That's probably going to make the next attempt to reduce emissions that much harder. I can already hear Kristen Welker asking the poor sucker who tries to make climate a major issue, "Many Americans - roughly half - believe that lowering gas and energy prices is more important than reducing greenhouse emissions. Are you sure that this is the right policy and the right message for your campaign, and can you guarantee that gas prices won't go up next year?"
Ok, I see what youre saying. I disagree though, I think it would be a liability for them because putting climate change as a center stage issue would reveal how empty their platform really is on...
Ok, I see what youre saying. I disagree though, I think it would be a liability for them because putting climate change as a center stage issue would reveal how empty their platform really is on the subject.
The reason I asked about the Green New Deal is because that bill doesnt propose doing anything about climate change. It is a bill that directs congress to write a bill that would do something about climate change. Its two congresspeople asking the rest of congress to come up with a plan for them. The reason congress never followed up on that is that none of them have a good plan ready.
The last time someone had a good idea about what to do was back in the Obama era when the US and Germany and China all made a big push to kickstart the solar industry, and honestly that worked out great. But we already did that one, and you cant just keep rehashing that idea for 15 years.
Theres other stuff we could be doing, but all the big swing ideas are divisive. I think investments in clean hydrogen or nuclear technology or a carbon tax could all be useful, but all those ideas have their detractors, and youd be fracturing your base on what is already kind of a wedge issue.
But if you dont want to do any if that stuff for fear of alienating people, youre just left with a bunch of smaller incremental efforts, like Biden's IRA. And you already explained how people respond to that: "great, but not nearly enough". Nothing short of refactoring the entire economy will impress people, and I just dont think most politicians are actually capable of planning something like that.
Now on the other hand, its not necessarily a dealbreaker if you make promises you cant keep. Republicans ran on repealing and replacing Obamacare for like 8 years, and they didnt have a plan for what they were going to do either, and it still worked. I just think thats a bad example to follow.
Gotcha. I get what you're saying about the Green New Deal, and I think it's a fair criticism when you look at it like that. There's two different ways to interpret the/a Green New Deal. There's...
Gotcha. I get what you're saying about the Green New Deal, and I think it's a fair criticism when you look at it like that.
There's two different ways to interpret the/a Green New Deal. There's the 2019 resolution, which if you compare it to an actual bill like the IRA, it's basically piss in the wind. Then there's the slogan, which isn't necessarily tied to a specific bill like the IRA or OBBB, but is more like a mission statement or guiding principles that would feature a series of bills and executive orders, like the original New Deal(s), or even Make America Great Again (I guess).
Personally, I'm a big slogan guy. Hope and Change was a great one, and we've twice elected the dumbest, sloppiest, most corrupt and embarrassing moron to ever hold public office, thanks in part to a decent slogan.
As far as ideas go, it seems like we're passing the dinking and dunking phase and heading straight towards the "oh fuck, time for WW2-level mobilization" phase. I think if you're going to embark on a mission to completely change how we fuel our civilization in under three decades, you gotta come with a good elevator pitch and a nice tag line, right? Sadly, I think the best we can get right now is a couple of lines about investing in renewables, which is basically the "two state solution" or "immigration reform" of climate policy.
Unless covid was actually an eco-terrorist attack, hmm Man that would be movie level evil though wouldn’t it, killing millions to provide a few more years for the human race to prepare for the...
Unless covid was actually an eco-terrorist attack, hmm
Man that would be movie level evil though wouldn’t it, killing millions to provide a few more years for the human race to prepare for the changing climate.
It would be a next level irony if it turned out that the conspiracy theories of it being a bioweapon turned out to not only be true but also to be something to try to save the world as a “lesser...
It would be a next level irony if it turned out that the conspiracy theories of it being a bioweapon turned out to not only be true but also to be something to try to save the world as a “lesser of two evils” kind of bad choice thing.
Right? Someone should make a movie It would only be a good movie if it turns out it was worth it, though, I guess, and from my perspective that's sorta hard to see.
Right? Someone should make a movie
It would only be a good movie if it turns out it was worth it, though, I guess, and from my perspective that's sorta hard to see.
Pretty sure the movie is called “Twelve Monkeys” (That’s kind of a joke as I mostly forget the reason the virus was released but my mind wants it to be eco terrorism)
Pretty sure the movie is called “Twelve Monkeys”
(That’s kind of a joke as I mostly forget the reason the virus was released but my mind wants it to be eco terrorism)
To be honest I'm surprised we're not seeing more eco-terrorism these days, considering the stakes. Maybe the consequences are still too abstract to get people truly angry.
To be honest I'm surprised we're not seeing more eco-terrorism these days, considering the stakes. Maybe the consequences are still too abstract to get people truly angry.
I think it's awareness that pissing off broader society only gets you so far and is often counter-productive combined with the heavy handed response from even liberal democracies to anyone that...
I think it's awareness that pissing off broader society only gets you so far and is often counter-productive combined with the heavy handed response from even liberal democracies to anyone that gets even vaguely near heading in the direction of direct action.
I think it all links back to what another commenter has said. The sources are way too diverse and complicated to dismantle. This also means that it is hard to find a single cause to rally behind....
I think it all links back to what another commenter has said. The sources are way too diverse and complicated to dismantle.
This also means that it is hard to find a single cause to rally behind. Like you can shout "just stop oil", but if you start mumbling stuff the moment someone asks "how?" or start reading a 600 page PhD thesis, the message is not nearly as powerful.
At the same time, there is no clear target. Who is to blame for climate change? Government are, companies are, consumers are, pretty much everything and everyone. Getting radical action going is probably a lot easier if there is a clear bad actor we can blame.
There have been some large climate protests near where I live. The ones that stayed with me are the ones with a clear message, e.g. against tax benefits for air travel. More generic ones are mostly just disruptive and annoying, which probably hurts the cause more than it helps.
Agreed except consumers. The problem is systems and industries, if action (such as regulation, protests, boycotts) is taken against those, the science says it should be enough. Or possibly would...
At the same time, there is no clear target. Who is to blame for climate change? Government are, companies are, consumers are, pretty much everything and everyone
Agreed except consumers. The problem is systems and industries, if action (such as regulation, protests, boycotts) is taken against those, the science says it should be enough. Or possibly would have been enough... it doesn't really matter, it's a clear target and inaction doesn't seem to be an sane option.
If you want an even clearer target: The heavily intertwined global energy and military industries. They've been funding pushback againt climate action for decades, they've run massive and successful propaganda campaigns to water down public support and seed doubt. They invented and funded the concepts of "carbon footprint" and plastics recycling to warp public perception. Those being examples in a mind blowingly widely scoped and long running plan of persistent strategic messaging, bad science funding, media influence and political manipulation. It's resulted in people doubting the science, burying their heads in the sand or thinking it's their own, and their neighbors, fault. The only reason you're wondering who to blame is that they're really good at what they do.
Politicians are scared shitless of the political power of these organizations. Media too, that's why they don't cover the issue honestly, or enough.
The target is right there under the neon sign pointing at the industries that profit the most, both directly and indirectly, from continued fossil fuel dependence and energy related conflict.
The world, and especially the US, is years, maybe decades, more behind on the response to the climate crises almost solely because that's what big industries are paying for.
I don't think eco-terrorism is the answer. Awareness is part of the answer though, if the public decides the fossil fuel industry is the problem, it will make a difference no matter what the media says, or carefully doesn't say. Not just where oil is concerned, across a variety of industries that depend on fossil fuels.
It's a bit more complicated than that, though. Consumers are part of the systems and industries in question. Take Amazon as an example - on the one hand, a lot of their success is due to their...
Agreed except consumers. The problem is systems and industries, if action (such as regulation, protests, boycotts) is taken against those, the science says it should be enough.
It's a bit more complicated than that, though. Consumers are part of the systems and industries in question. Take Amazon as an example - on the one hand, a lot of their success is due to their size and ability to overpower smaller competitors. On the other hand, they also make buying things really convenient, and consumers like that. I have friends who buy almost everything on Amazon because it has it all in one place and it comes quickly. That's consumer preference.
When it comes to climate change, it's a similar situation. Most people agree that climate change is bad, but they like meat being relatively cheap, and being able to afford private transport, and long-distance travel being relatively quick and convenient. And therefore companies offer those services, even though it's terrible for the environment (and then greenwash the whole thing to try and get the best of both worlds).
It's a bit too simplistic to say it's all consumer-driven - there's also plenty of lobbying and advertising going on to push consumers in certain directions - but I think it's a mistake to take consumers out of the equation entirely.
Sure consumers matter, but people are always broadly going to choose based on cost and convenience. Many people don't have the luxury of changing their carbon footprint in a meaningful way. Public...
Sure consumers matter, but people are always broadly going to choose based on cost and convenience. Many people don't have the luxury of changing their carbon footprint in a meaningful way.
Public sentiment matters a lot more than consumption IMO. Not only does it impact consumption, it impacts political and commercial decision making.
If you take consumers out of the equation (not that we should), the majority of the problem still exists. Whereas if you take regulation, government spending, economic incentives and giant industries out of the equation, the problem is unsolvable.
Which is to say that if everyone improved their personal carbon footprint some realistic amount based on what they could afford, it wouldn't be enough to head off climate disaster. They still should, but that part of the conversation is mostly a distraction from the real problems.
However if everyone started loudly and persistently demanding action against the real problems, that would make a huge difference.
I guess I don't really see the difference between consumer demand and public sentiment. The biggest difference is how you vote: at the polls or with your wallet. Either way, things are unlikely to...
I guess I don't really see the difference between consumer demand and public sentiment. The biggest difference is how you vote: at the polls or with your wallet. Either way, things are unlikely to change unless a majority of people are willing to accept that the luxuries they are used to are supplied largely by industries that burn the planet. And not in the sense that those industries are run by malevolent villains who want to do bad things, but rather in the sense that the luxuries themselves rely on massive waste and consumption of resources.
Therefore, the people that ultimately need to enact these changes are us, the voters and consumers. Corporations aren't going to change by themselves, they're responding to the market (i.e. us, again, the voters and consumers). And politicians do (in most democracies at least) what they're told to by us, the voters and consumers.
The problem as I see it is that the voters and consumers aren't really convinced by the need for these changes. Like, we (mostly) agree that climate change is bad, but the price we're willing to pay to fix it is far lower than what's actually needed. I think that's slowly starting to change as more younger people become able to vote and as the more disastrous effects are being felt, but it's taken a long time to get this far.
I think there are plenty of clear targets: oil pipelines, data centers, petrol stations, they could just start smashing every non-electric car they see in the street. I don't expect my eco...
I think there are plenty of clear targets: oil pipelines, data centers, petrol stations, they could just start smashing every non-electric car they see in the street. I don't expect my eco terrorists to be super nuanced.
Has eco-terrorism ever got anything done? I thought it didn't do anything for systemic change and only made people see all eco-activusts as crazy lunatics. Kinda like how PETA does more harm than...
Has eco-terrorism ever got anything done? I thought it didn't do anything for systemic change and only made people see all eco-activusts as crazy lunatics. Kinda like how PETA does more harm than good for the animal rights movement.
in the case of my friend she works in australia and while they love to protect their natural environment they also love to mine and develop land without actually paying attention to the...
in the case of my friend she works in australia and while they love to protect their natural environment they also love to mine and develop land without actually paying attention to the environmental reports that she writes for businesses so in this case I was implying sabotaging construction equipment.
I should also mention it was only partially in jest. Also maybe eco terrorism is the wrong term and maybe I should say eco defense because when people think of the former they think of XR and Just Stop Oil which aren't everyones favourite. I think ZAD is a better example.
Not sure what counts as eco-terrorism. But some kids chained and glued themselves during the Keystone XL protests. It's hard to tell in hindsight what's effective or not, but that tar sand...
Not sure what counts as eco-terrorism. But some kids chained and glued themselves during the Keystone XL protests. It's hard to tell in hindsight what's effective or not, but that tar sand pipeline wasn't built.
Kinda like how PETA does more harm than good for the animal rights movement.
... does it? The only way I can think of is that it serves as a lightning rod for, I guess, the "animals should not have rights" movement. Otherwise they just do outreach (besides operating kill shelters).
Looks like they're still building the pipeline, just calling it a different name https://www.nrdc.org/press-releases/keystone-light-tar-sands-pipeline-same-problems-different-name
Looks like they're still building the pipeline, just calling it a different name
Mmhm, Keystone XL is definitely dead, and the dream of building a pipeline to ship more products to America from Canada is likely politically non-viable in 2026 (the federal conservatives lost an...
Mmhm, Keystone XL is definitely dead, and the dream of building a pipeline to ship more products to America from Canada is likely politically non-viable in 2026 (the federal conservatives lost an election over this, and a couple seats in a recent byelection). Trump can sign whatever paper he'd like, but the only pipelines which Canada is building at the moment are being done with tremendous amounts of public money, which are unlikely to be allocated to this project.
There is a conspiracy that PETA is funded by the meat industry to make the protesters look bad and similarly Just Stop Oil by the fossil fuel industry. Not that I want to lend any credibility to...
There is a conspiracy that PETA is funded by the meat industry to make the protesters look bad and similarly Just Stop Oil by the fossil fuel industry.
Not that I want to lend any credibility to these types of conspiracy theories, but the fact that this sounds vaguely plausible shows that their reputation is far from stellar indeed
One quick thought ... methane. Methane is 80 times more potent than CO2, and it degrades out of the atmosphere in <30 years. And half the methane we put into the atmosphere comes from (relatively)...
Exemplary
One quick thought ... methane.
Methane is 80 times more potent than CO2, and it degrades out of the atmosphere in <30 years.
And half the methane we put into the atmosphere comes from (relatively) cheap-and-easy-to-fix leaks in fossil fuel production.
If we fixed those, global warming would almost flatline for 30 years, as the atmospheric methane breaks down almost as fast as the CO2 we keep emitting adds to the problem.
Bonus ... If y'all could just quit eating cows, that's where the other half of our methane comes from.
It's not a solution, but it is an easy quick-fix to buy us a couple more decades.
According to the article, some of the leaks have been easy fixes yet there are states not even responding to alerts :(
According to the article, some of the leaks have been easy fixes yet there are states not even responding to alerts :(
The UN Methane Alert and Response System (Mars) sent 192 alerts of methane plumes to Turkmenistan in the last year. The country had three of the six worst leaks detected in the world by Mars in last six months, and nine of the top 50.
Turkmenistan responded to about 20% of the alerts with on-the-ground information about the leaks and potential plans to fix them. In contrast, the US was sent the second highest number of alerts – 138 – but responded to none and had fixed no leaks in the last year. Other nations that failed to respond to any alerts were Iran, Russia and China.
And yet we have ever increasing resources allocated to data centers/ai and never decreasing resources allocated for destined to trash products. Right to repair never materialized how it would need...
And yet we have ever increasing resources allocated to data centers/ai and never decreasing resources allocated for destined to trash products. Right to repair never materialized how it would need to and finding products that will last is either impossible, dependent on second hand market or marked up several dozen times where they are still being made. Then there is the meat industry of course.
There has to be some political will to end global warming and some public will to make sacrifices, mainly to the dreaded convenience. Otherwise it does not matter what targets are set. The nature of the problem is such that when it is impossible to ignore there will be nearly nothing to be done.
Despite advancements in wind and solar power, countries have continued to burn oil, gas and coal, releasing carbon dioxide into the atmosphere where it traps the sun’s heat and has raised average global temperatures by about 1.4 degrees Celsius
Based on current climate policies among nations and trends, the planet is expected to warm 2.6 degrees Celsius, or 4.7 degrees Fahrenheit, by the end of the century.
in order for temperatures to be brought back to the 1.5 degree mark this century, global warming at its peak would have to be limited to 1.8 Celsius (3.2 Fahrenheit), compared with preindustrial times. Most scientists describe that as unlikely. [...] Even under the most optimistic scenarios, a single decade of warming could take about 50 years to reverse.
The U.N. report predicted the rise in average global temperatures would eclipse 1.5 degrees Celsius in “the next few years.” At that level of warming, “there are no good outcomes,” said Inger Andersen, the executive director of the U.N. Environment Program.
I'm not gonna sit here and lie to you and say 'planting forests will be enough'. But I will say that a jobs program dedicated to ripping up useless decorative grass fields and getting proper...
I'm not gonna sit here and lie to you and say 'planting forests will be enough'.
But I will say that a jobs program dedicated to ripping up useless decorative grass fields and getting proper forests and meadows re-established will pay huge dividends. Especially once you dive into the rabbithole of how rebuilding these things also mitigate droughts and floods.
And as a betting man, I'd say that the money invested into building up that program will do much better per dollar than any carbon-sequestration factory.
An American sycamore will grow by approximately 6ft in height and 1in in diameter each year in its first 10 years. About 720 cuft of wood. That tree is approximately 34 lb/cuft dry, and tree wood is approximately 50% carbon by weight. That one tree that just sprouted in my backyard will sequester a minimum of 6 tons of carbon. Not counting its root structure, which is probably another 6.
Now here is the kicker: The ground underneath it's 40ft+ reach will then be 20F+ lower than the ground in the direct sunlight in the summer.
The best possible thing we could do to mitigate suburbia is to get it back under the trees. But I'm seeing a hundred cut for every new one being planted. Lots of the times a tree cut out of the sidewalk just becomes more concrete.
Universal rooftop solar sounds nice, but that collective money would best be spent building gigantic utility-scale facilities and making sure all the homes are properly shaded in the summer and in the sun in the winter.
My first job after getting my B.S. in ecology was lab and field work on some forestry-related climate change studies (similar to/associated with the Duke Forest FACE experiment) recording tree...
My first job after getting my B.S. in ecology was
lab and field work on some forestry-related climate change studies (similar to/associated with the Duke Forest FACE experiment) recording tree growth and calculating biomass.
What's especially frustrating about the wasted space we could be devoting to trees is that a maximally carbon-sequestering forest can still be highly economically valuable to humans. This can be a win-win.
On a per-hectare basis, a young forest captures carbon faster than an old forest — which favors tree farms, where you harvest the trees relatively young and immediately replant. And you can arrest all that carbon in the timber by making permanent products out of it, such as houses and furniture/cabinetry (specifically higher-quality products that don't just end up in a dump).
Locking up tree-farm-grown wood by building houses is so effective that, on average, building a timber-framed house removes more carbon from the atmosphere than it adds, despite the heavily polluting techniques widely used across the construction industry (heavy fossil fuel vehicles, cement foundations, long distance transport of materials, etc.). This ratio could be improved even further with minimal disruption — but more importantly, we should simply be building more wood houses even if we don't improve our construction techniques.
In every region of the world where a forestry industry is viable, governments should be subsidizing them heavily, particularly tree farms destined for the construction and carpentry industries. Let's make wood cheap again!
I'm glad that you're interested in this stuff too! It's good that people are actually imagining a way out of this, instead of surrendering to the doom and gloom, or leaping to destructive actions....
I'm glad that you're interested in this stuff too! It's good that people are actually imagining a way out of this, instead of surrendering to the doom and gloom, or leaping to destructive actions.
It might be worth prodding some local organizations to see what sort of interventions they think are useful for your region? E.g. rooftop solar can be extremely valuable since it's otherwise flat, ecologically dead space -- but building performance improvement initiatives (e.g. replacing windows, insulating walls, air sealing homes, ripping out natural gas heaters, etc.) can get crazy good bang for the buck by comparison. It kinda depends on whether you're in a heating climate, what solar gains are like in your area, etc.
As my boss put it "We shouldn't look at putting panels on homes until there is an array on every commercial/industrial box and EV chargers in every parking lot." My point is that a roof being...
As my boss put it "We shouldn't look at putting panels on homes until there is an array on every commercial/industrial box and EV chargers in every parking lot."
My point is that a roof being covered by a tree >>>> solar panels on that roof. And the tree will do most of the hard work for you after about 2 years.
Parking lots are an excellent target for that effort though, considering that you can practically boil water on unshielded asphalt.
Fair enough! Afaik, the main issue with building in a parking lot is that you require a bunch of steel/concrete structures to get the panels off the ground (plus the maintenance costs), whereas a...
Fair enough! Afaik, the main issue with building in a parking lot is that you require a bunch of steel/concrete structures to get the panels off the ground (plus the maintenance costs), whereas a roof is already sitting there. And I don't think there's strong evidence that a tree is universally >>>> solar panels on a roof, but hopefully whenever these initiatives are funded, the people who look into them will perform adequate research for whatever is appropriate in your region.
Generally I'd propose the opposite to what you're noting -- prioritize trees in parking lots, and solar panels on roofs -- since the trees can largely take care of themselves (given adequate planning, and a good watering schedule up front). But whatever the data supports is best.
Agree in the abstract, but solar panels on roofs always struck me as an 'Murika Individualism Bootstraps' answer. Never really a practical one. Speaking as someone who had a 15kw system on his...
Agree in the abstract, but solar panels on roofs always struck me as an 'Murika Individualism Bootstraps' answer. Never really a practical one. Speaking as someone who had a 15kw system on his roof before moving.
Asphalt and concrete don't really provide a lot of opportunties for root growth that would be required for trees that could blanket it. But it's pretty trivial to install steel beams and run wires.
Additionally, shading a parking lot helps keep some cars cool, but shading buildings directly reduces peak energy demands.
But almost every tiny back lot in American city backyards could host a gigantic tree or two.
Looking at approximate costs, to get 10,000 households to cover 80% of their electric needs with solar, that's approximately $200,000,000 for about 70MW of power. Distributed in a hot mess across 10,000 housholds. That will need to be disrupted for roof repairs, requires 10,000 people to manage the logistics of yet another finicky appliance every time a squurrel decides to nibble the wires, etc.
Estimates for a 100MW solar farm run something like 10-30% cheaper than that, probably due to a simpler installation process per kwh. It's now easily monitored and maintained by 1 entity.
And then when you plant trees to cover the houses, you also get a greater reduction in the electrical demand for those 10,000 households.
I get this is doing a lot of arbitrary handwaving, as this is an internet post and not a detailed 20 year plan. My point being that centralizing the complex technology while decentralizing the finicky nature (that a lot of people love having around them anyway), has a lot more benefits than the reverse.
Not to say this is an either/or situation. But if you have the option to throw some solar panels on a carport over your driveway instead of your roof and you plant a tree to cover your roof, it's gonna be a net win.
Fair enough! Disagreed with the characterization, but I get that tone is difficult to convey on the internet. For personal context, I'm looking into a solar array for a property that will see...
Agree in the abstract, but solar panels on roofs always struck me as an 'Murika Individualism Bootstraps' answer. Never really a practical one. Speaking as someone who had a 15kw system on his roof before moving.
Fair enough! Disagreed with the characterization, but I get that tone is difficult to convey on the internet. For personal context, I'm looking into a solar array for a property that will see frequent power outages, and although the rooftop will be technically capable of mounting solar panels, I'll likely be setting them up solar pergolas and/or greenhouses as some site restrictions limit the utility of rooftop solar.
As you note, we're just having an internet chat, so I won't go crazy with citations. But I suppose to broadly counterpoint, there are a bunch of examples of people tearing up parking lot sidewalks in parking lots to install green islands. And hard surfaces are less problematic for root development when deployed with silvacells or permeable asphalt. Overall, I dislike status quo biases, especially towards unjustified centralization (e.g. the IMF dislikes solar microgrids because they don't work like a regular grid, without providing evidence for their stance), hence my general disagreement on the uncited, strongly worded, broad claim that centralized solar farms are unequivocally better than rooftop solar without direct head-to-head systems level studies comparing approaches. Really resisting the urge to whip out the napkin and soapbox, here ...
Not to say this is an either/or situation.
Agreed. Again, as noted above, I'm hoping that the folks who research policy for a living will produce an analysis indicating which approaches make the most sense given the current state of the world. Internet jousting aside, any progress is still progress, but it'd be great not to blow a tonne of money on less effective solutions (or which leave a bunch of trash to remediate later). My main experience with solar panels in parking lots are experimental sun tracking systems which rust out in a couple of years, then overcharge compared to standard grid tied chargers down the street. Anecdotes aren't data, in other words.
Planting trees over roads and parking lots, instead of over houses, is also safer from a wildfire standpoint, which is a pretty major concern in a lot of places (particularly those with dry, hot...
Planting trees over roads and parking lots, instead of over houses, is also safer from a wildfire standpoint, which is a pretty major concern in a lot of places (particularly those with dry, hot summers), and it's only going to get worse as droughts become more frequent and more intense.
Where I live (rural Australia), large trees have to be planted at a pretty significant setback from buildings, which means lots and lots of roofs exposed to lots and lots of sun — perfect conditions for solar panels.
People here make up for the lack of trees next to homes by planting shady avenues all over the place. These trees can still catch fire, but the road accessibility ensures firefighters can reach them quickly, making it dramatically easier to get fires under control before they reach buildings.
Edit:
I'd also like to mention that planting trees (specifically native trees) along roads has other environmental benefits. One of the biggest is that tree-lined roads function as wildlife corridors and go a long way toward mitigating the effects of habitat fragmentation. Tree-lined roads mean you can have lots of smaller parks instead of just a few really big parks. Small parks are more affordable/achievable for local governments, more human-friendly (who doesn't like having a park nearby?), and allow a greater variety of habitats to be preserved.
Another big one is that trees along roads are generally left in a more natural state than trees around people's homes. For example, if a tree dies next to a house, it needs to be removed before it damages the house. But along roads, dead trees can often be left standing (depending on how close they are to the road and how busy the road is). Dead trees are important for a lot of wildlife, especially birds and mammals that nest in hollows. In my region, the loss of dead trees is by far the biggest factor in bird decline, and they are protected more carefully than living trees (e.g., if the council needs to choose between cutting down a live tree and a dead tree to build an access road, they will preserve the dead tree if it has hollows).
110%!! And I heard that eucalyptus trees explode during wildfires out there, which is extra terrifying?! In my region (the Canadian west coast), an entire village burned down a few years back due...
[...] safer from a wildfire standpoint [...]
110%!! And I heard that eucalyptus trees explode during wildfires out there, which is extra terrifying?! In my region (the Canadian west coast), an entire village burned down a few years back due to a wildfire, with a primary cited reason for the devastation being an absence of defensible space within 30m of the buildings. Trees are beautiful, and I absolutely understand people wanting to preserve them everywhere, but permanent structures are definitionally generational investments, and due care is necessary when planning them out.
(also, relatedly, frequently having leaves on one's roof makes safe rainwater harvesting more difficult ...)
Dead trees are important for a lot of wildlife, especially birds and mammals that nest in hollows.
Huh! That's fascinating; I hadn't considered that before, but it makes sense.
This reminds me that about a month ago there was an article posted about how carbon capture is a scam and can never possibly work. So if you take that piece at face value I guess we're all boned....
This reminds me that about a month ago there was an article posted about how carbon capture is a scam and can never possibly work.
So if you take that piece at face value I guess we're all boned.
I cant see the actual text of this article though, so who knows.
TBH, that sounds about right. The solution we actually need now mostly exists in the form of charlatans selling snake oil funded by the people causing the problem in the first place. Mostly...
TBH, that sounds about right. The solution we actually need now mostly exists in the form of charlatans selling snake oil funded by the people causing the problem in the first place.
Mostly because the people causing the problem spent more than 50 years hiding and lying about it. Sowing misinformation and actively campaigning against things that would have rendered that solution pointless.
I do think that pretty much any "capture and sequester carbon" scheme involving technological solutions is dooming us to WALL-E levels of self-destruction via hubris. We need to acknowledge that...
I do think that pretty much any "capture and sequester carbon" scheme involving technological solutions is dooming us to WALL-E levels of self-destruction via hubris.
We need to acknowledge that this is an extinction-level crisis we have inflicted upon ourselves, and requires that level of serious, humble, and somber approach to the solution.
What's that solution going to look like without massive loss of life? A worldwide planned economy with WWII levels of mobilization of resources and the complete destruction of wealth inequality.
To that end, we need to strip billionaires of their fortunes. Money is power, and we need to eliminate the ability for any given individual to exert their will upon the world.
We need to level off energy use. 100% freeze on added capacity until 100% off fossil fuels (natural gas inclusive). Yup, that means pretty much a freeze on all technological development not explicitly targeted at sustainability.
Thus, growth needs to be explicitly targetted at bringing up standards of living for those at the bottom, paired with sunsetting standards of living at the top. We kind of need to put a halt to pushing performance boundries on computing and focus on improved efficiency and long term durability. Goods need to reflect their actual environmenral costs from extraction until burial. Wages need to be standardized globally so that efficienies come from proximity to resources and not which country has the cheapest labor. We need to actively shrink the economy that does not bring people up out of poverty. Sharing luxuries needs to be the norm. Even the wealthiest should not be able to afford whatever they want without sacrifice. Having a car should require sacrifices elsewhere in life, even for the wealthiest. The richest among us should still only just barely be able to afford a business class flight or two, let alone private chartered jets.
We need to pay people handsomely to rebuild public transit infrastructure. To re-integrate with nature instead of paving it over. We need to de-industrialize farming (and thus have more farmers) to reduce reliance on mass poisoning of the ground. We need to undo a century of approaching stormwater management like a waste product to be disposed of and treat it like the precious resource for reducing wildfires and mitigating droughts that it is.
I do not forsee this happening until it is much too late. Because it is exponentially harder than dealing with slightly worse hairspray like the CFC phase out was.
I do not think half of this would have been necessary if we neutered wealth inequality in the 90s. Or if we began seriously addressing the problem in the 1980s.
Realistically for things to change significantly it would require developed nations to subsidize clean industrial development for developing countries (ironically, you can argue that Trump has...
Realistically for things to change significantly it would require developed nations to subsidize clean industrial development for developing countries (ironically, you can argue that Trump has been a great force in global decarbonization).
If you’re a developing country, rationally it just makes no sense for you to care about emissions while industrializing. The benefits of economic development far outweigh the harms. Today’s developed countries had their environmental disasters already (see: the famous smog of London), so why wouldn’t you get your turn?
So as a developed country, with hypothetically more to lose, you can either take over these countries militarily and force them to deindustrialize, or fork over lots and lots of money, with the only string attached being that the developing countries must use it on clean energy.
Of course, there’s no way that’s happening. Voters balk at the slightest increase in inflation - spending tax money to help “others” get rich?
Kinda is what it is. We’ll get the global warming we deserve, not the global warming we need. Not everyone will die but a lot of people will, and even more displaced. It do be like that sometimes.
I think it was simon Clark who mentioned that even though we missed 1.5c (which most climate scientists knew was going to happen) we have also prevented the worst case scenario which was something like 4c. So we are narrowing the scope of heating.
Its not great but as i told an environmental scientist friend recently. There's always eco terrorism to fall back on if we want to get shit done.
edit: here is a link to a climate obstruction book that is free to download. Iv not read the whole thing yet but the parts I have read are really good.
https://academic.oup.com/book/61469?login=false
Aside from the morality, the sources are too diffuse and global for terroristic activity to have any real impact on emissions. Not to mention that the backlash would play right into the hands of fossil fuel industry-sponsored fascists.
You might put the fear into executives of a corporation, but entire nation-states that profit from fossil fuel extraction are a different ballgame. And they're not changing their behavior even when their activities are making their countries uninhabitable.
China really took the only course of action available - making fossil fuel use so uncompetitive and uneconomical that only propagandized fools continue to pursue it as the primary energy source.
Edit: If you really want to see change, get corrupt money out of politics. It's not that no one knows what to do, it's that our leaders are thoroughly bought and paid for.
Honestly, it's so hard to not feel hopeless and defeated when looking at the prospects of not only ending the corruption that controls our politics, but also overcoming the widespread propaganda that dominates the discourse in this country. Even the most popular and progressive politicians tend to stay away from the Green New Deal. Isn't that crazy? We've had three presidential elections in the last 10 years and I can probably count on one hand the number of times that the environment/climate change was brought up in the debates. And of those handful of times that it was brought up, the only time a question like that gained any traction in the media was because it was asked by Ken fucking Bone, and his question - which was ignored in the media coverage in favor of his jolly little brand of pervertry - was framed by asking how they would protect his jerb in the fossil fuel industry! We live in an insane society.
Meanwhile, what's the earliest we could see major campaign finance reform? Three years? And that's assuming you get both Congress and the president to expand and stuff the supreme court. Then you still have the business of replacing those in office who are subservient to the fossil fuel industry (which would take years) and hope they haven't developed a clever workaround to make use of the millions of dollars that currently buy elections and politicians, and convince people to care about it in a media environment that, at best, will ignore or downplay the severity of the issue.
Really the only way I see us doing what we need to by the time it needs to be done is if we get an unbelievably popular, talented, and bulletproof politician (like Obama + Mamdani + Tom Hanks x10000, aka Mechazobama) to come in during a time of crisis and do a little Trump-like authoritarianism/strong-arming to force the regulations, infrastructure, and global coordination that we need. Either that or we get about a dozen Katrina-level environmental catastrophies in a single year that are so horrifying and devastating that it's like 9/11 and the Lisbon Earthquake rolled into one.
FWIW, Biden actually got the ball rolling with the biggest "Green New Deal" the US has ever enacted ... he just called it an intrastructure & jobs act. There's a lesson to be learned there. If the Dems had won in 2024, the US would be well on track right now.
What does it really mean for politicians to stray away from the Green New Deal? From what I remember of it I honestly was not impressed and thought it was kind of nothing.
I'm saying that tackling the environmental crisis is mostly an afterthought, even among the politicians who supposedly support taking aggressive measures to do so. The climate investment that was in the IRA was great, but not nearly enough, and the only thing floating around right now that matches the scope of the issue is the GND. It's less about the GND specifically and more about the absence of any real effort to address the issue or bring it into the conversation.
The lack of attention on climate change is not doing us any favors. Because while Democrats have shifted their entire focus towards affordability issues and - for the progressive wing - our relationship with Israel, Republicans and Donald Trump have been filling that void by hyping up fossil fuels. As a result, there has been a 20-point swing towards support for prioritizing fossil fuels over renewables. That's probably going to make the next attempt to reduce emissions that much harder. I can already hear Kristen Welker asking the poor sucker who tries to make climate a major issue, "Many Americans - roughly half - believe that lowering gas and energy prices is more important than reducing greenhouse emissions. Are you sure that this is the right policy and the right message for your campaign, and can you guarantee that gas prices won't go up next year?"
Ok, I see what youre saying. I disagree though, I think it would be a liability for them because putting climate change as a center stage issue would reveal how empty their platform really is on the subject.
The reason I asked about the Green New Deal is because that bill doesnt propose doing anything about climate change. It is a bill that directs congress to write a bill that would do something about climate change. Its two congresspeople asking the rest of congress to come up with a plan for them. The reason congress never followed up on that is that none of them have a good plan ready.
The last time someone had a good idea about what to do was back in the Obama era when the US and Germany and China all made a big push to kickstart the solar industry, and honestly that worked out great. But we already did that one, and you cant just keep rehashing that idea for 15 years.
Theres other stuff we could be doing, but all the big swing ideas are divisive. I think investments in clean hydrogen or nuclear technology or a carbon tax could all be useful, but all those ideas have their detractors, and youd be fracturing your base on what is already kind of a wedge issue.
But if you dont want to do any if that stuff for fear of alienating people, youre just left with a bunch of smaller incremental efforts, like Biden's IRA. And you already explained how people respond to that: "great, but not nearly enough". Nothing short of refactoring the entire economy will impress people, and I just dont think most politicians are actually capable of planning something like that.
Now on the other hand, its not necessarily a dealbreaker if you make promises you cant keep. Republicans ran on repealing and replacing Obamacare for like 8 years, and they didnt have a plan for what they were going to do either, and it still worked. I just think thats a bad example to follow.
Gotcha. I get what you're saying about the Green New Deal, and I think it's a fair criticism when you look at it like that.
There's two different ways to interpret the/a Green New Deal. There's the 2019 resolution, which if you compare it to an actual bill like the IRA, it's basically piss in the wind. Then there's the slogan, which isn't necessarily tied to a specific bill like the IRA or OBBB, but is more like a mission statement or guiding principles that would feature a series of bills and executive orders, like the original New Deal(s), or even Make America Great Again (I guess).
Personally, I'm a big slogan guy. Hope and Change was a great one, and we've twice elected the dumbest, sloppiest, most corrupt and embarrassing moron to ever hold public office, thanks in part to a decent slogan.
As far as ideas go, it seems like we're passing the dinking and dunking phase and heading straight towards the "oh fuck, time for WW2-level mobilization" phase. I think if you're going to embark on a mission to completely change how we fuel our civilization in under three decades, you gotta come with a good elevator pitch and a nice tag line, right? Sadly, I think the best we can get right now is a couple of lines about investing in renewables, which is basically the "two state solution" or "immigration reform" of climate policy.
Unless covid was actually an eco-terrorist attack, hmm
Man that would be movie level evil though wouldn’t it, killing millions to provide a few more years for the human race to prepare for the changing climate.
It would be a next level irony if it turned out that the conspiracy theories of it being a bioweapon turned out to not only be true but also to be something to try to save the world as a “lesser of two evils” kind of bad choice thing.
Right? Someone should make a movie
It would only be a good movie if it turns out it was worth it, though, I guess, and from my perspective that's sorta hard to see.
Pretty sure the movie is called “Twelve Monkeys”
(That’s kind of a joke as I mostly forget the reason the virus was released but my mind wants it to be eco terrorism)
It's also the plot of Rainbow Six
Thanos?
Nope, I'm betting on the Fash team to get rid of "useless eaters" once they've automated all the things.
To be honest I'm surprised we're not seeing more eco-terrorism these days, considering the stakes. Maybe the consequences are still too abstract to get people truly angry.
I think it's awareness that pissing off broader society only gets you so far and is often counter-productive combined with the heavy handed response from even liberal democracies to anyone that gets even vaguely near heading in the direction of direct action.
I think it all links back to what another commenter has said. The sources are way too diverse and complicated to dismantle.
This also means that it is hard to find a single cause to rally behind. Like you can shout "just stop oil", but if you start mumbling stuff the moment someone asks "how?" or start reading a 600 page PhD thesis, the message is not nearly as powerful.
At the same time, there is no clear target. Who is to blame for climate change? Government are, companies are, consumers are, pretty much everything and everyone. Getting radical action going is probably a lot easier if there is a clear bad actor we can blame.
There have been some large climate protests near where I live. The ones that stayed with me are the ones with a clear message, e.g. against tax benefits for air travel. More generic ones are mostly just disruptive and annoying, which probably hurts the cause more than it helps.
Agreed except consumers. The problem is systems and industries, if action (such as regulation, protests, boycotts) is taken against those, the science says it should be enough. Or possibly would have been enough... it doesn't really matter, it's a clear target and inaction doesn't seem to be an sane option.
If you want an even clearer target: The heavily intertwined global energy and military industries. They've been funding pushback againt climate action for decades, they've run massive and successful propaganda campaigns to water down public support and seed doubt. They invented and funded the concepts of "carbon footprint" and plastics recycling to warp public perception. Those being examples in a mind blowingly widely scoped and long running plan of persistent strategic messaging, bad science funding, media influence and political manipulation. It's resulted in people doubting the science, burying their heads in the sand or thinking it's their own, and their neighbors, fault. The only reason you're wondering who to blame is that they're really good at what they do.
Politicians are scared shitless of the political power of these organizations. Media too, that's why they don't cover the issue honestly, or enough.
The target is right there under the neon sign pointing at the industries that profit the most, both directly and indirectly, from continued fossil fuel dependence and energy related conflict.
The world, and especially the US, is years, maybe decades, more behind on the response to the climate crises almost solely because that's what big industries are paying for.
I don't think eco-terrorism is the answer. Awareness is part of the answer though, if the public decides the fossil fuel industry is the problem, it will make a difference no matter what the media says, or carefully doesn't say. Not just where oil is concerned, across a variety of industries that depend on fossil fuels.
It's a bit more complicated than that, though. Consumers are part of the systems and industries in question. Take Amazon as an example - on the one hand, a lot of their success is due to their size and ability to overpower smaller competitors. On the other hand, they also make buying things really convenient, and consumers like that. I have friends who buy almost everything on Amazon because it has it all in one place and it comes quickly. That's consumer preference.
When it comes to climate change, it's a similar situation. Most people agree that climate change is bad, but they like meat being relatively cheap, and being able to afford private transport, and long-distance travel being relatively quick and convenient. And therefore companies offer those services, even though it's terrible for the environment (and then greenwash the whole thing to try and get the best of both worlds).
It's a bit too simplistic to say it's all consumer-driven - there's also plenty of lobbying and advertising going on to push consumers in certain directions - but I think it's a mistake to take consumers out of the equation entirely.
Sure consumers matter, but people are always broadly going to choose based on cost and convenience. Many people don't have the luxury of changing their carbon footprint in a meaningful way.
Public sentiment matters a lot more than consumption IMO. Not only does it impact consumption, it impacts political and commercial decision making.
If you take consumers out of the equation (not that we should), the majority of the problem still exists. Whereas if you take regulation, government spending, economic incentives and giant industries out of the equation, the problem is unsolvable.
Which is to say that if everyone improved their personal carbon footprint some realistic amount based on what they could afford, it wouldn't be enough to head off climate disaster. They still should, but that part of the conversation is mostly a distraction from the real problems.
However if everyone started loudly and persistently demanding action against the real problems, that would make a huge difference.
I guess I don't really see the difference between consumer demand and public sentiment. The biggest difference is how you vote: at the polls or with your wallet. Either way, things are unlikely to change unless a majority of people are willing to accept that the luxuries they are used to are supplied largely by industries that burn the planet. And not in the sense that those industries are run by malevolent villains who want to do bad things, but rather in the sense that the luxuries themselves rely on massive waste and consumption of resources.
Therefore, the people that ultimately need to enact these changes are us, the voters and consumers. Corporations aren't going to change by themselves, they're responding to the market (i.e. us, again, the voters and consumers). And politicians do (in most democracies at least) what they're told to by us, the voters and consumers.
The problem as I see it is that the voters and consumers aren't really convinced by the need for these changes. Like, we (mostly) agree that climate change is bad, but the price we're willing to pay to fix it is far lower than what's actually needed. I think that's slowly starting to change as more younger people become able to vote and as the more disastrous effects are being felt, but it's taken a long time to get this far.
I think there are plenty of clear targets: oil pipelines, data centers, petrol stations, they could just start smashing every non-electric car they see in the street. I don't expect my eco terrorists to be super nuanced.
"Just stop oil" is kicking back into gear, so watch this space I guess?
I remember reading about an eco-activist from the 70s who sabotaged pipelines etc...
Has eco-terrorism ever got anything done? I thought it didn't do anything for systemic change and only made people see all eco-activusts as crazy lunatics. Kinda like how PETA does more harm than good for the animal rights movement.
in the case of my friend she works in australia and while they love to protect their natural environment they also love to mine and develop land without actually paying attention to the environmental reports that she writes for businesses so in this case I was implying sabotaging construction equipment.
I should also mention it was only partially in jest. Also maybe eco terrorism is the wrong term and maybe I should say eco defense because when people think of the former they think of XR and Just Stop Oil which aren't everyones favourite. I think ZAD is a better example.
Not sure what counts as eco-terrorism. But some kids chained and glued themselves during the Keystone XL protests. It's hard to tell in hindsight what's effective or not, but that tar sand pipeline wasn't built.
... does it? The only way I can think of is that it serves as a lightning rod for, I guess, the "animals should not have rights" movement. Otherwise they just do outreach (besides operating kill shelters).
Maybe you're thinking of Greenpeace?
Looks like they're still building the pipeline, just calling it a different name
https://www.nrdc.org/press-releases/keystone-light-tar-sands-pipeline-same-problems-different-name
Mmhm, Keystone XL is definitely dead, and the dream of building a pipeline to ship more products to America from Canada is likely politically non-viable in 2026 (the federal conservatives lost an election over this, and a couple seats in a recent byelection). Trump can sign whatever paper he'd like, but the only pipelines which Canada is building at the moment are being done with tremendous amounts of public money, which are unlikely to be allocated to this project.
There is a conspiracy that PETA is funded by the meat industry to make the protesters look bad and similarly Just Stop Oil by the fossil fuel industry.
Not that I want to lend any credibility to these types of conspiracy theories, but the fact that this sounds vaguely plausible shows that their reputation is far from stellar indeed
Maybe this doesn't mean much because we import many of our goods in the US, but our CO2 emissions peaked 20 years ago.
Also, they've peaked - per capita - very high indeed. Even now 3 times the global average and vastly higher than most peer nations.
One quick thought ... methane.
Methane is 80 times more potent than CO2, and it degrades out of the atmosphere in <30 years.
And half the methane we put into the atmosphere comes from (relatively) cheap-and-easy-to-fix leaks in fossil fuel production.
If we fixed those, global warming would almost flatline for 30 years, as the atmospheric methane breaks down almost as fast as the CO2 we keep emitting adds to the problem.
Bonus ... If y'all could just quit eating cows, that's where the other half of our methane comes from.
It's not a solution, but it is an easy quick-fix to buy us a couple more decades.
E.g. ‘Breakthrough’ as Turkmenistan starts fixing ‘mindboggling’ methane mega-leaks
According to the article, some of the leaks have been easy fixes yet there are states not even responding to alerts :(
And yet we have ever increasing resources allocated to data centers/ai and never decreasing resources allocated for destined to trash products. Right to repair never materialized how it would need to and finding products that will last is either impossible, dependent on second hand market or marked up several dozen times where they are still being made. Then there is the meat industry of course.
There has to be some political will to end global warming and some public will to make sacrifices, mainly to the dreaded convenience. Otherwise it does not matter what targets are set. The nature of the problem is such that when it is impossible to ignore there will be nearly nothing to be done.
archive
UN's report
I'm not gonna sit here and lie to you and say 'planting forests will be enough'.
But I will say that a jobs program dedicated to ripping up useless decorative grass fields and getting proper forests and meadows re-established will pay huge dividends. Especially once you dive into the rabbithole of how rebuilding these things also mitigate droughts and floods.
And as a betting man, I'd say that the money invested into building up that program will do much better per dollar than any carbon-sequestration factory.
An American sycamore will grow by approximately 6ft in height and 1in in diameter each year in its first 10 years. About 720 cuft of wood. That tree is approximately 34 lb/cuft dry, and tree wood is approximately 50% carbon by weight. That one tree that just sprouted in my backyard will sequester a minimum of 6 tons of carbon. Not counting its root structure, which is probably another 6.
Now here is the kicker: The ground underneath it's 40ft+ reach will then be 20F+ lower than the ground in the direct sunlight in the summer.
The best possible thing we could do to mitigate suburbia is to get it back under the trees. But I'm seeing a hundred cut for every new one being planted. Lots of the times a tree cut out of the sidewalk just becomes more concrete.
Universal rooftop solar sounds nice, but that collective money would best be spent building gigantic utility-scale facilities and making sure all the homes are properly shaded in the summer and in the sun in the winter.
My first job after getting my B.S. in ecology was
lab and field work on some forestry-related climate change studies (similar to/associated with the Duke Forest FACE experiment) recording tree growth and calculating biomass.
What's especially frustrating about the wasted space we could be devoting to trees is that a maximally carbon-sequestering forest can still be highly economically valuable to humans. This can be a win-win.
On a per-hectare basis, a young forest captures carbon faster than an old forest — which favors tree farms, where you harvest the trees relatively young and immediately replant. And you can arrest all that carbon in the timber by making permanent products out of it, such as houses and furniture/cabinetry (specifically higher-quality products that don't just end up in a dump).
Locking up tree-farm-grown wood by building houses is so effective that, on average, building a timber-framed house removes more carbon from the atmosphere than it adds, despite the heavily polluting techniques widely used across the construction industry (heavy fossil fuel vehicles, cement foundations, long distance transport of materials, etc.). This ratio could be improved even further with minimal disruption — but more importantly, we should simply be building more wood houses even if we don't improve our construction techniques.
In every region of the world where a forestry industry is viable, governments should be subsidizing them heavily, particularly tree farms destined for the construction and carpentry industries. Let's make wood cheap again!
I'm glad that you're interested in this stuff too! It's good that people are actually imagining a way out of this, instead of surrendering to the doom and gloom, or leaping to destructive actions.
It might be worth prodding some local organizations to see what sort of interventions they think are useful for your region? E.g. rooftop solar can be extremely valuable since it's otherwise flat, ecologically dead space -- but building performance improvement initiatives (e.g. replacing windows, insulating walls, air sealing homes, ripping out natural gas heaters, etc.) can get crazy good bang for the buck by comparison. It kinda depends on whether you're in a heating climate, what solar gains are like in your area, etc.
As my boss put it "We shouldn't look at putting panels on homes until there is an array on every commercial/industrial box and EV chargers in every parking lot."
My point is that a roof being covered by a tree >>>> solar panels on that roof. And the tree will do most of the hard work for you after about 2 years.
Parking lots are an excellent target for that effort though, considering that you can practically boil water on unshielded asphalt.
Fair enough! Afaik, the main issue with building in a parking lot is that you require a bunch of steel/concrete structures to get the panels off the ground (plus the maintenance costs), whereas a roof is already sitting there. And I don't think there's strong evidence that a tree is universally >>>> solar panels on a roof, but hopefully whenever these initiatives are funded, the people who look into them will perform adequate research for whatever is appropriate in your region.
Generally I'd propose the opposite to what you're noting -- prioritize trees in parking lots, and solar panels on roofs -- since the trees can largely take care of themselves (given adequate planning, and a good watering schedule up front). But whatever the data supports is best.
Agree in the abstract, but solar panels on roofs always struck me as an 'Murika Individualism Bootstraps' answer. Never really a practical one. Speaking as someone who had a 15kw system on his roof before moving.
Asphalt and concrete don't really provide a lot of opportunties for root growth that would be required for trees that could blanket it. But it's pretty trivial to install steel beams and run wires.
Additionally, shading a parking lot helps keep some cars cool, but shading buildings directly reduces peak energy demands.
But almost every tiny back lot in American city backyards could host a gigantic tree or two.
Looking at approximate costs, to get 10,000 households to cover 80% of their electric needs with solar, that's approximately $200,000,000 for about 70MW of power. Distributed in a hot mess across 10,000 housholds. That will need to be disrupted for roof repairs, requires 10,000 people to manage the logistics of yet another finicky appliance every time a squurrel decides to nibble the wires, etc.
Estimates for a 100MW solar farm run something like 10-30% cheaper than that, probably due to a simpler installation process per kwh. It's now easily monitored and maintained by 1 entity.
And then when you plant trees to cover the houses, you also get a greater reduction in the electrical demand for those 10,000 households.
I get this is doing a lot of arbitrary handwaving, as this is an internet post and not a detailed 20 year plan. My point being that centralizing the complex technology while decentralizing the finicky nature (that a lot of people love having around them anyway), has a lot more benefits than the reverse.
Not to say this is an either/or situation. But if you have the option to throw some solar panels on a carport over your driveway instead of your roof and you plant a tree to cover your roof, it's gonna be a net win.
Fair enough! Disagreed with the characterization, but I get that tone is difficult to convey on the internet. For personal context, I'm looking into a solar array for a property that will see frequent power outages, and although the rooftop will be technically capable of mounting solar panels, I'll likely be setting them up solar pergolas and/or greenhouses as some site restrictions limit the utility of rooftop solar.
As you note, we're just having an internet chat, so I won't go crazy with citations. But I suppose to broadly counterpoint, there are a bunch of examples of people tearing up parking lot sidewalks in parking lots to install green islands. And hard surfaces are less problematic for root development when deployed with silvacells or permeable asphalt. Overall, I dislike status quo biases, especially towards unjustified centralization (e.g. the IMF dislikes solar microgrids because they don't work like a regular grid, without providing evidence for their stance), hence my general disagreement on the uncited, strongly worded, broad claim that centralized solar farms are unequivocally better than rooftop solar without direct head-to-head systems level studies comparing approaches. Really resisting the urge to whip out the napkin and soapbox, here ...
Agreed. Again, as noted above, I'm hoping that the folks who research policy for a living will produce an analysis indicating which approaches make the most sense given the current state of the world. Internet jousting aside, any progress is still progress, but it'd be great not to blow a tonne of money on less effective solutions (or which leave a bunch of trash to remediate later). My main experience with solar panels in parking lots are experimental sun tracking systems which rust out in a couple of years, then overcharge compared to standard grid tied chargers down the street. Anecdotes aren't data, in other words.
Planting trees over roads and parking lots, instead of over houses, is also safer from a wildfire standpoint, which is a pretty major concern in a lot of places (particularly those with dry, hot summers), and it's only going to get worse as droughts become more frequent and more intense.
Where I live (rural Australia), large trees have to be planted at a pretty significant setback from buildings, which means lots and lots of roofs exposed to lots and lots of sun — perfect conditions for solar panels.
People here make up for the lack of trees next to homes by planting shady avenues all over the place. These trees can still catch fire, but the road accessibility ensures firefighters can reach them quickly, making it dramatically easier to get fires under control before they reach buildings.
Edit:
I'd also like to mention that planting trees (specifically native trees) along roads has other environmental benefits. One of the biggest is that tree-lined roads function as wildlife corridors and go a long way toward mitigating the effects of habitat fragmentation. Tree-lined roads mean you can have lots of smaller parks instead of just a few really big parks. Small parks are more affordable/achievable for local governments, more human-friendly (who doesn't like having a park nearby?), and allow a greater variety of habitats to be preserved.
Another big one is that trees along roads are generally left in a more natural state than trees around people's homes. For example, if a tree dies next to a house, it needs to be removed before it damages the house. But along roads, dead trees can often be left standing (depending on how close they are to the road and how busy the road is). Dead trees are important for a lot of wildlife, especially birds and mammals that nest in hollows. In my region, the loss of dead trees is by far the biggest factor in bird decline, and they are protected more carefully than living trees (e.g., if the council needs to choose between cutting down a live tree and a dead tree to build an access road, they will preserve the dead tree if it has hollows).
110%!! And I heard that eucalyptus trees explode during wildfires out there, which is extra terrifying?! In my region (the Canadian west coast), an entire village burned down a few years back due to a wildfire, with a primary cited reason for the devastation being an absence of defensible space within 30m of the buildings. Trees are beautiful, and I absolutely understand people wanting to preserve them everywhere, but permanent structures are definitionally generational investments, and due care is necessary when planning them out.
(also, relatedly, frequently having leaves on one's roof makes safe rainwater harvesting more difficult ...)
Huh! That's fascinating; I hadn't considered that before, but it makes sense.
This reminds me that about a month ago there was an article posted about how carbon capture is a scam and can never possibly work.
So if you take that piece at face value I guess we're all boned.
I cant see the actual text of this article though, so who knows.
TBH, that sounds about right. The solution we actually need now mostly exists in the form of charlatans selling snake oil funded by the people causing the problem in the first place.
Mostly because the people causing the problem spent more than 50 years hiding and lying about it. Sowing misinformation and actively campaigning against things that would have rendered that solution pointless.
What sort of things do you have in mind?
I do think that pretty much any "capture and sequester carbon" scheme involving technological solutions is dooming us to WALL-E levels of self-destruction via hubris.
We need to acknowledge that this is an extinction-level crisis we have inflicted upon ourselves, and requires that level of serious, humble, and somber approach to the solution.
What's that solution going to look like without massive loss of life? A worldwide planned economy with WWII levels of mobilization of resources and the complete destruction of wealth inequality.
To that end, we need to strip billionaires of their fortunes. Money is power, and we need to eliminate the ability for any given individual to exert their will upon the world.
We need to level off energy use. 100% freeze on added capacity until 100% off fossil fuels (natural gas inclusive). Yup, that means pretty much a freeze on all technological development not explicitly targeted at sustainability.
Thus, growth needs to be explicitly targetted at bringing up standards of living for those at the bottom, paired with sunsetting standards of living at the top. We kind of need to put a halt to pushing performance boundries on computing and focus on improved efficiency and long term durability. Goods need to reflect their actual environmenral costs from extraction until burial. Wages need to be standardized globally so that efficienies come from proximity to resources and not which country has the cheapest labor. We need to actively shrink the economy that does not bring people up out of poverty. Sharing luxuries needs to be the norm. Even the wealthiest should not be able to afford whatever they want without sacrifice. Having a car should require sacrifices elsewhere in life, even for the wealthiest. The richest among us should still only just barely be able to afford a business class flight or two, let alone private chartered jets.
We need to pay people handsomely to rebuild public transit infrastructure. To re-integrate with nature instead of paving it over. We need to de-industrialize farming (and thus have more farmers) to reduce reliance on mass poisoning of the ground. We need to undo a century of approaching stormwater management like a waste product to be disposed of and treat it like the precious resource for reducing wildfires and mitigating droughts that it is.
I do not forsee this happening until it is much too late. Because it is exponentially harder than dealing with slightly worse hairspray like the CFC phase out was.
I do not think half of this would have been necessary if we neutered wealth inequality in the 90s. Or if we began seriously addressing the problem in the 1980s.
Climate Goals Missed, U.N. Says World Must Now Remove Carbon at Scale gift link
Realistically for things to change significantly it would require developed nations to subsidize clean industrial development for developing countries (ironically, you can argue that Trump has been a great force in global decarbonization).
If you’re a developing country, rationally it just makes no sense for you to care about emissions while industrializing. The benefits of economic development far outweigh the harms. Today’s developed countries had their environmental disasters already (see: the famous smog of London), so why wouldn’t you get your turn?
So as a developed country, with hypothetically more to lose, you can either take over these countries militarily and force them to deindustrialize, or fork over lots and lots of money, with the only string attached being that the developing countries must use it on clean energy.
Of course, there’s no way that’s happening. Voters balk at the slightest increase in inflation - spending tax money to help “others” get rich?
Kinda is what it is. We’ll get the global warming we deserve, not the global warming we need. Not everyone will die but a lot of people will, and even more displaced. It do be like that sometimes.