68 votes

After Steam, indie videogame store itch.io has also delisted erotic content

31 comments

  1. [14]
    Grzmot
    (edited )
    Link
    Similar as with Steam, itch.io came under pressure from payment providers to remove erotic content. The source of this is a campaign by NGO Collective Shout, which lobbied payment providers like...

    Similar as with Steam, itch.io came under pressure from payment providers to remove erotic content. The source of this is a campaign by NGO Collective Shout, which lobbied payment providers like Visa and Mastercard directly to pressure Steam to remove games that offend the NGO or leave the platform: https://www.collectiveshout.org/open-letter-to-payment-processors

    As an enjoyer of the occasional NSFW game, this all sucks. It sucks especially because Collective Shout is a notable sex-negative NGO with ties to Christian conversatives. They tried to get Detroit: Become Human banned from shops for depicting violence against women. They are not your friend.

    57 votes
    1. [11]
      0x29A
      Link Parent
      And a lot of the times the MO of these kinds of organizations is to ask for removal of the "worst offenders" because their removal is harder to argue against, so that they can wedge that into a...

      And a lot of the times the MO of these kinds of organizations is to ask for removal of the "worst offenders" because their removal is harder to argue against, so that they can wedge that into a full attack on NSFW content altogether. It being a religious organization makes it quite clear that their intent is likely suppression of all NSFW content, or even stuff that isn't (like LGBTQ+ content) the same way they want book bans and so on

      Given that it's a conservative Christian NGO there is no doubt in my mind that's the case here.

      37 votes
      1. [9]
        TheRtRevKaiser
        Link Parent
        I don't think it's actually a Christian group, I think they are a Radical Feminist group that has some ties to conservative christian groups. That's my understanding, anyway. There's been some...

        I don't think it's actually a Christian group, I think they are a Radical Feminist group that has some ties to conservative christian groups. That's my understanding, anyway. There's been some weird cross-pollination between RadFem groups (especially TERF groups) and conservatives in recent years.

        13 votes
        1. [5]
          DefinitelyNotAFae
          (edited )
          Link Parent
          They don't strike me as Radical Feminist, do you have some sources there? (I don't mean they're not "radical" or claiming feminist motivations but that Rad Fem is a particular thing and this...

          They don't strike me as Radical Feminist, do you have some sources there? (I don't mean they're not "radical" or claiming feminist motivations but that Rad Fem is a particular thing and this doesn't strike me as it.) They are SWERFs and I wouldn't surprise if they're a SWERF and TERF shop, but they seem to be coming from a conservative angle.

          They definitely have pro-life and "protect the children" mindsets which are generally rather conservative. And the founder threatened to sue over this blog post pointing out her ties to fundamental Christianity.

          Anti-porn activist threatens to sue blogger over religion claims

          They're using the language of this type of feminism, but not advocating for, for example, women's bodily autonomy. And the group supported the show Cuties which was incredibly exploitative while claiming to highlight exploitation. And has gotten sex Ed books yanked from schools. I don't see them dismantling the patriarchy or even being consistent about their beliefs.

          (I'm personally on board with the theoretical level of radical feminism, less so the fixation on pornography and sex work, but they influenced mainstream feminism in a positive direction IMO at least at one point. And hey maybe radfem is old enough to be conservative now, idk)

          14 votes
          1. [4]
            TheRtRevKaiser
            Link Parent
            So it's entirely possible that I'm misunderstanding or mischaracterizing the group and/or Radical Feminism - I probably should be more careful when I'm not as informed as I should be on different...

            So it's entirely possible that I'm misunderstanding or mischaracterizing the group and/or Radical Feminism - I probably should be more careful when I'm not as informed as I should be on different feminisms, which is definitely the case. I was tying them to what I knew about TERF groups, and the very little I know about SWERF groups - both of which I thought fit under the Radical Feminist umbrella, and both of which have had some eyebrow raising ties to far right christian extremism in recent years.

            I haven't seen any articles from sources that I would trust to use the terminology responsibly, so it's possible - maybe probable - that this is a Christian anti-porn group using the language of feminism.

            5 votes
            1. [3]
              DefinitelyNotAFae
              Link Parent
              It's one of those things where Radical Feminism gets used very loosely and to mean a bunch of things. Like genuinely calling someone a TERF means calling them a radfem but the person is rarely...

              It's one of those things where Radical Feminism gets used very loosely and to mean a bunch of things. Like genuinely calling someone a TERF means calling them a radfem but the person is rarely actually a radical feminist. They're often, but not always an extremist, and may or may not be a feminist. And most of us don't actually mean Radical Feminism when we say SWERF/TERF (my apologies for the imprecision there)

              This group flags to me as a conservative "for the children" from people who probably call themselves feminists but vote against abortion and for male politicians and would not be radfems.

              But in the same way 2nd wave feminists would seem conservative in some ways to 3rd wave feminists, etc, it's possible actual RadFem has turned into, well, this.

              Their founder is actively a conservative Christian as far as I can see, and that doesn't seem to be a recent change or something.

              12 votes
              1. [2]
                TheRtRevKaiser
                Link Parent
                I did see one article where the founder of this group called herself a "Pro-life Feminist" so seems like you might be spot on. I grew up in (and was part of) conservative evangelical churches for...

                I did see one article where the founder of this group called herself a "Pro-life Feminist" so seems like you might be spot on.

                I grew up in (and was part of) conservative evangelical churches for the first three decades of my life, so I'm still figuring out a lot of things that I learned wrong or just didn't learn at all. So I apologize if I misrepresented anything, definitely wasn't my intention.

                10 votes
                1. DefinitelyNotAFae
                  Link Parent
                  Nah in some sense I'm being particular, mostly because I think this is a more right wing group playing at left wing. And because the language has shifted around the term Radical Feminism. And also...

                  Nah in some sense I'm being particular, mostly because I think this is a more right wing group playing at left wing. And because the language has shifted around the term Radical Feminism. And also I don't think they're actually feminists by a standard definition but I may be getting too "no true scotsman" on that.

                  7 votes
        2. [2]
          Grumble4681
          (edited )
          Link Parent
          Where does the money come from behind this organization? I assume any organization that gains this kind of traction has money backing it, is it targeted effectively to individual donors or are...

          Where does the money come from behind this organization? I assume any organization that gains this kind of traction has money backing it, is it targeted effectively to individual donors or are there more wealthy people behind it? I tried looking it up but I can't seem to find anything.

          Edit: OK so I guess they're an Australian registered non-profit which seemingly the normal non-profit tracking sites I guess don't track Australian registered non-profits or for whatever reason don't track this one.

          https://www.gg.org.au/charity/30162159097/collective-shout-limited/

          That appears to be their financials, which seems relatively diminutive if they were able to successfully influence payment processors to pressure Valve to make those removals from the Steam store. I would have expected it would take more financial backing to apply that kind of pressure to these large companies.

          8 votes
          1. post_below
            Link Parent
            Payment processors have been notoriously anti adult content, and anything else they deem risky, for a long time now. It likely didn't take much prodding.

            I would have expected it would take more financial backing to apply that kind of pressure to these large companies.

            Payment processors have been notoriously anti adult content, and anything else they deem risky, for a long time now. It likely didn't take much prodding.

            2 votes
        3. 0x29A
          (edited )
          Link Parent
          Ah well, close enough, and esp for them to work together on this, they might as well be identical in my book (as in, I despise them all). No problem with actual sex-positive...

          Ah well, close enough, and esp for them to work together on this, they might as well be identical in my book (as in, I despise them all). No problem with actual sex-positive inclusive/intersectional feminism of course, but TERFs and those that misuse feminism in certain ways like that can F off

      2. sparksbet
        Link Parent
        Worth noting that because itch is also the main platform for indie ttrpgs, this action is already affecting books in addition to videogames.

        Worth noting that because itch is also the main platform for indie ttrpgs, this action is already affecting books in addition to videogames.

        4 votes
    2. [2]
      CannibalisticApple
      Link Parent
      This is just infuriating to me on so many levels. The thing is, I can agree with the sentiments in that letter. I've seen plenty of games on Steam that are just rape simulators or glorify violence...

      This is just infuriating to me on so many levels. The thing is, I can agree with the sentiments in that letter. I've seen plenty of games on Steam that are just rape simulators or glorify violence against women as sick, twisted wish fulfillment. There is some stuff that just shouldn't exist, or at least not on the "mainstream" parts of the internet like Steam and itch.io.

      And that's what's so infuriating. They're weaponizing an actual good cause to further their own selfish agenda. It delegitimizes the actual good cause because their intent isn't noble, so it creates a mindset among people that "giving in" will open the door to get so much else banned. And in this case, it does. There are already multiple reports from LGBTQ+ developers claiming their content got shadowbanned despite not having an NSFW tag. As best as people can figure, one reason is due to the content being tagged "adult", but that tag is often used for non-sexual reasons such as depicting drugs or violence.

      The fact they campaigned against Detroit: Become Human just solidifies it. The "violence against women and children" in that game wasn't meant for sick fantasies, because we're playing AS the woman. We actually need that kind of representation, where the players are put in the shoes of the victim, because so many people just can't empathize with that scenario since they've never experienced it, or even witnessed it up close. Actually playing through those sorts of scenes has a different impact from even just seeing characters be abused...

      Or, even worse: being the abuser like in those very games that the open letter references. Those games that encourage violence against women, and which will always, always exist. It is so vital to have good games that show the harm it causes to counteract that. If you ban even the slightest implication of violence against women and children, or even the slightest implication of sex, then the only games that will be out there are the horrible ones that are exclusively about harming them.

      Just... GAH. This situation is messed up on so many levels. These groups should not have this much influence over payment processors, and payment processors should not have this much influence over content.

      22 votes
      1. V17
        Link Parent
        Salami slicing tactic works and is commonly used in situations like this one. That mindset is completely rational.

        It delegitimizes the actual good cause because their intent isn't noble, so it creates a mindset among people that "giving in" will open the door to get so much else banned. And in this case, it does.

        Salami slicing tactic works and is commonly used in situations like this one. That mindset is completely rational.

        11 votes
  2. [5]
    CannibalisticApple
    Link
    There is now an ACLU petition to get Mastercard to reverse this policy in regards to all sex work. Also, Collective Shout reportedly made 1,000 calls to lobby MasterCard and Visa to push for this...

    There is now an ACLU petition to get Mastercard to reverse this policy in regards to all sex work.

    Also, Collective Shout reportedly made 1,000 calls to lobby MasterCard and Visa to push for this ban, so there are now calls for people to start calling them.

    I want to emphasize that this isn't just about people wanting to goon over NSFW games or OnlyFans. This is about censorship in general. Itch is one of the few platforms for LGBTQ+ erotic content, including novels, and now many queer creators have lost their main source of income. Some are even reporting that Itch may now be withholding outstanding payments for now-delisted content, which is vital to their livelihoods.

    This HAS to be undone.

    33 votes
    1. [2]
      CannibalisticApple
      Link Parent
      Update: Change.org also has a petition.
      10 votes
      1. [2]
        Comment deleted by author
        Link Parent
        1. DefinitelyNotAFae
          Link Parent
          That org absolutely wants to target OF and more traditional pornography too. So it's not even that it isn't a priority for them. Their website actively opposes both.

          That org absolutely wants to target OF and more traditional pornography too. So it's not even that it isn't a priority for them. Their website actively opposes both.

          14 votes
    2. [2]
      raze2012
      Link Parent
      I think it's even simpler than that. If we're going to argue that guns shouldn't be accountable for school shootings, I have no idea how we are going to also say that "credit cards should be...

      I want to emphasize that this isn't just about people wanting to goon over NSFW games or OnlyFans. This is about censorship in general.

      I think it's even simpler than that. If we're going to argue that guns shouldn't be accountable for school shootings, I have no idea how we are going to also say that "credit cards should be accountable for literally everything" in the same breath. If we're carving exceptions in this, I'd think the main thing drivign all digital purposes should be a high priority.

      9 votes
      1. CannibalisticApple
        Link Parent
        I can absolutely agree with that. My main point was to make sure people didn't dismiss it as just people being horny, because it is so much more serious.

        I can absolutely agree with that. My main point was to make sure people didn't dismiss it as just people being horny, because it is so much more serious.

        5 votes
  3. d32
    Link
    Hopefully this is not the end of it. Once the US empire falls.... But even before that, it would be a high time for Europe and other countries to come with their own alternatives to the American...

    Hopefully this is not the end of it.
    Once the US empire falls....
    But even before that, it would be a high time for Europe and other countries to come with their own alternatives to the American payment processors, especially now that the US is turning into hostility and fascism.

    18 votes
  4. [3]
    Comment deleted by author
    Link
    1. [2]
      0x29A
      Link Parent
      Yeah banking/payment industry is so large and integral to existence at this point, that they should be seen more as infrastructure or some other neutral industry/body, restricted to the point that...

      Yeah banking/payment industry is so large and integral to existence at this point, that they should be seen more as infrastructure or some other neutral industry/body, restricted to the point that they can only deny payments for things that are actually illegal, but otherwise not allowed to maintain any policy that allows them to be an arbiter of morality or a proxy for censorship. This doesn't mean I argue neutrality for all forms of business, necessarily, but for this one I think it makes more sense given its ubiquity

      6 votes
      1. skybrian
        Link Parent
        Banking is both essential infrastructure (most money is bank money) and an integral part of how governments regulate money. Typically, a government doesn't write the rules for banks, but banks are...

        Banking is both essential infrastructure (most money is bank money) and an integral part of how governments regulate money. Typically, a government doesn't write the rules for banks, but banks are required to have policies that meet certain requirements, or the government could shut them down. (Things like "know your customer" policies work this way.) Also, banks don't necessarily want to spend time reviewing anything sketchy - they'll just shut down things that look like they might be sketchy. Not illegal (they wouldn't know) but looks like it might involved in illegal activity.

        So, they're not going to be neutral infrastructure. But, businesses could shop around to find a more specialized bank that caters more to customers like them - and will likely have more of a clue, watch customers more closely, and charge a bit more.

        5 votes
  5. [7]
    shrike
    Link
    The only way to "fix" this is to completely move off the big payment processors and use crypto. And crypto is complete shit for a marketplace like itch.io that kinda relies on people making...

    The only way to "fix" this is to completely move off the big payment processors and use crypto.

    And crypto is complete shit for a marketplace like itch.io that kinda relies on people making impulse purchases just to support a project they like - they might never play it, but want to have more of it in the world.

    Maybe a restructuring so that they have one company with full-on sfw content and an alt-store where the suspicious stuff goes?

    11 votes
    1. [3]
      0xSim
      Link Parent
      Crypto is not a solution. What is needed is another (European?), correctly regulated, payment processor to break the current duopoly.

      Crypto is not a solution. What is needed is another (European?), correctly regulated, payment processor to break the current duopoly.

      37 votes
      1. SloMoMonday
        Link Parent
        I don't know if another or even a few centralized payment processor is really solving the problem. Because how I see it, you're just kicking the can down and it's just begging for an international...

        I don't know if another or even a few centralized payment processor is really solving the problem. Because how I see it, you're just kicking the can down and it's just begging for an international incident when some some specific thing becomes a hot button topic. Like Andrew Tate or crypto exchanges or adult content being blocked in one place but allowed in another and it prompts all this discussion about free trade and the like.

        But I think systems like SWIFT prove that cross border banking instructions is not impossible. If your bank is willing to work with you and facilitate international transfers, they probably trust you to be above board and in line with local laws. And if a company has any services that are objectionable in certain places, we can agree on some international tagging system to verify if the spesific transfer is allowed.

        And if there is an objection, be it frivolous like this or completely valid, the bank is likely far better situated to investigate and take proper action then a central body overseeing everything everywhere or a nebulous decentralized peer to peer system that would let anything go.

        And now you've got morality police needing to penetrate multiple layers to impose their standards globally. You could apply focused pressure on a few bodies if you know what to do. But can you pressure every bank or every country to act in a certain way. And I don't think it will go over well when foreign religious nutjobs are picking fights with banks and governments where they have no say or business.

        11 votes
      2. Wulfsta
        Link Parent
        I really can’t decide if I agree or disagree with either side of using crypto for once. On one hand, the original idea of cryptocurrency was simply decentralized currency, which would allow for an...

        I really can’t decide if I agree or disagree with either side of using crypto for once. On one hand, the original idea of cryptocurrency was simply decentralized currency, which would allow for an alternative to these payment processors if correctly regulated as the financial instrument it is. On the other, there are a lot of reasons that crypto is generally wasteful or predatory.

        5 votes
    2. ButteredToast
      Link Parent
      I think some form of crypto might work, but it’s going to take a lot of heavy lifting in terms of smoothing out UX. A model that could be reused here is Steam credits. Rather than using the...

      I think some form of crypto might work, but it’s going to take a lot of heavy lifting in terms of smoothing out UX.

      A model that could be reused here is Steam credits. Rather than using the cryptocurrency directly, have a store currency and encourage shoppers to preload store currency in lumps by giving a % bonus on preloads and maybe an increased bonus on recurring preloads, and/or a discounted price when buying with store currency. This keeps shopper accounts in a state conducive to impulse spending since there’s no payment details page when buying with credits, plus it reduces transaction fees and network burden with fewer bigger transactions instead of many smaller ones.

      3 votes
    3. [2]
      moocow1452
      Link Parent
      Maybe crypto does become a little more accessible in the future, but I can't help feeling that it's going to become a issue where crypto is exclusively associated with unsavory purchases. Maybe...

      Maybe crypto does become a little more accessible in the future, but I can't help feeling that it's going to become a issue where crypto is exclusively associated with unsavory purchases. Maybe that's already the case, or maybe being able to cut out a pay processor makes a lot of vendors willing to get on board, I don't know.

      3 votes
      1. raze2012
        Link Parent
        The president of the US scamming people out of a billion dollars the second he swore the oath more or less solidified that in mind. It's also simply less stable than a risky stock. Crypto booms...

        The president of the US scamming people out of a billion dollars the second he swore the oath more or less solidified that in mind. It's also simply less stable than a risky stock. Crypto booms and crashes so rapidly. I wouldn't want to trust my money in there.

        4 votes
  6. AugustusFerdinand
    Link
    Itch.io Reindexing adult NSFW content

    Itch.io Reindexing adult NSFW content

    Today, we are re-indexing free adult NSFW content. We are still in ongoing discussions with payment processors and will be re-introducing paid content slowly to ensure we can confidently support the widest range of creators in the long term.

    10 votes
  7. d32
    Link
    "partners", right.

    we must prioritize our relationship with our payment partners and take immediate steps towards compliance

    "partners", right.