9 votes

Mario 64's unofficial PC port will look glorious once modders get done with it

5 comments

  1. [5]
    mrbig
    Link
    That’s looking awesome, but I can’t stop thinking about the lawsuits...

    That’s looking awesome, but I can’t stop thinking about the lawsuits...

    4 votes
    1. nothis
      Link Parent
      Right? I can't imagine putting all that work into something that will so predictably get sued into oblivion. It's also funny how fairly mainstream sources report on it as something just "neat",...

      Right? I can't imagine putting all that work into something that will so predictably get sued into oblivion. It's also funny how fairly mainstream sources report on it as something just "neat", because so obviously nobody is harmed in any of this. There's rumors Nintendo has plans for a huge Mario bundle for the Switch (Mario 64, Sunshine, Galaxy and 3D World) and I can't think of any scenario in which this fan project could possibly hurt sales of that, for example. At the same time, yea, it's basically a pirate version of Mario 64, I couldn't blame them for suing.

      6 votes
    2. [3]
      moocow1452
      Link Parent
      Modding a console game that was unofficially ported to PC is unprecedented, so we don't really have a good point of comparison. Mod Texture Packs for Emulators are okay, because Emulators are...

      Modding a console game that was unofficially ported to PC is unprecedented, so we don't really have a good point of comparison. Mod Texture Packs for Emulators are okay, because Emulators are okay, but a mod specifically created for an unlicensed copy of a game is... questionable.

      I guess the game still exists somewhere though, so mods will be in similar places.

      6 votes
      1. [2]
        Wes
        Link Parent
        If they're just patch files, I don't see that Nintendo would have any claim. It's only a problem if the mod contains Nintendo code or assets.

        If they're just patch files, I don't see that Nintendo would have any claim. It's only a problem if the mod contains Nintendo code or assets.

        3 votes
        1. mrbig
          Link Parent
          That may be true but Nintendo can ruin people’s lives even without legal basis.

          If they're just patch files, I don't see that Nintendo would have any claim

          That may be true but Nintendo can ruin people’s lives even without legal basis.

          2 votes