13 votes

Megathread for news/updates/discussion of Russian invasion of Ukraine - April 27-28

This thread is posted Monday/Wednesday/Friday - please try to post relevant content in here, such as news, updates, opinion articles, etc. Especially significant updates may warrant a separate topic, but most should be posted here.

If you'd like to help support Ukraine, please visit the official site at https://help.gov.ua/ - an official portal for those who want to provide humanitarian or financial assistance to people of Ukraine, businesses or the government at the times of resistance against the Russian aggression.

22 comments

  1. cfabbro
    Link
    They Flooded Their Own Village, and Kept the Russians at Bay (NYT) Article has lots of photos, along with more details of the Ukrainian defensive efforts, and interviews with the locals.

    They Flooded Their Own Village, and Kept the Russians at Bay (NYT)

    All around Demydiv, a village north of Kyiv, residents have been grappling with the aftermath of a severe flood, which under ordinary circumstances would have been yet another misfortune for a people under attack by Russia.

    This time, though, it was a tactical victory. The Ukrainians flooded the village intentionally, along with a vast expanse of fields and bogs around it, creating a quagmire that thwarted a Russian tank assault on Kyiv and bought the army precious time to prepare defenses.

    The residents of Demydiv paid the price in the rivers of dank green floodwater that engulfed many of their homes. And they couldn’t be more pleased.

    “Everybody understands and nobody regrets it for a moment,” said Antonina Kostuchenko, a retiree, whose living room is now a musty space with waterlines a foot or so up the walls.

    “We saved Kyiv!” she said with pride.

    Article has lots of photos, along with more details of the Ukrainian defensive efforts, and interviews with the locals.

    6 votes
  2. [5]
    vektor
    Link
    Lots of talk on social media recently about two things that I'd request info on if any of you have it: Explosions and fires in Russia, some of which far away from Ukraine. Is there any info beyond...

    Lots of talk on social media recently about two things that I'd request info on if any of you have it:

    • Explosions and fires in Russia, some of which far away from Ukraine. Is there any info beyond "yeah, that happened", e.g. Ukrainian statements on the matter.

    • Transdnistria. I have no clue WTF is going on, except that people are talking about it again. What exactly happened?

    4 votes
    1. [2]
      cfabbro
      (edited )
      Link Parent
      Related post from the last megathread: Russia reports blasts in south that Ukraine calls payback for invasion (Reuters) This Guardian article has a good overview of the situation there, including...

      Explosions and fires in Russia, some of which far away from Ukraine. Is there any info beyond "yeah, that happened", e.g. Ukrainian statements on the matter.

      Related post from the last megathread:
      Russia reports blasts in south that Ukraine calls payback for invasion (Reuters)

      Transdnistria. I have no clue WTF is going on, except that people are talking about it again. What exactly happened?

      This Guardian article has a good overview of the situation there, including some background info:
      Where is Transnistria and why is it being drawn into Ukraine war?

      But also worth mentioning is this gov.ua post:
      Explosions in Transnistrian Region of the Republic of Moldova Are Planned Provocations by Russia’s Special Services. Document

      4 votes
    2. skybrian
      Link Parent
      Regarding the explosions in Russia, it seems notable that the US isn't warning about false flag attacks like they do in other places?

      Regarding the explosions in Russia, it seems notable that the US isn't warning about false flag attacks like they do in other places?

      3 votes
    3. FishFingus
      Link Parent
      People were reportedly fleeing Transnistria in the last 48 hours, and the government has now said that all males of enlistment age are prohibited from leaving. Moldova is worried that they are...

      People were reportedly fleeing Transnistria in the last 48 hours, and the government has now said that all males of enlistment age are prohibited from leaving. Moldova is worried that they are going to try and mobilize. The government of Ukraine has said that they are happy to assist, if invited to.

      3 votes
  3. [2]
    cfabbro
    Link
    German parliament approves petition to deliver heavy arms to Ukraine (Reuters)

    German parliament approves petition to deliver heavy arms to Ukraine (Reuters)

    Germany's Bundestag lower house of parliament on Thursday overwhelmingly approved a petition on support for Ukraine backing the delivery of weapons including heavy arms to the country to help it fend off Russian attacks.

    "Alongside the broad economic isolation and decoupling of Russia from international markets, the most important and effective means to stop the Russian invasion is to intensify and speed up the delivery of effective weapons and complex systems including heavy arms," the petition read.

    The petition was backed by both the three parties in the ruling coalition as well as the opposition conservatives, passing with 586 votes in favor, 100 against and seven abstentions, according to Bundestag Vice President Wolfgang Kubicki.

    4 votes
    1. vektor
      Link Parent
      I'm not sure this will have a material effect. As in, I'm not sure to what degree it compels the government to act in ways it otherwise wouldn't have. As far as I can tell, this is mostly about...

      I'm not sure this will have a material effect. As in, I'm not sure to what degree it compels the government to act in ways it otherwise wouldn't have.

      As far as I can tell, this is mostly about posturing of opposition vs coalition parties: The coalition parties had this petition in the works, when the major opposition party (CDU) was going to come out with a similar petition that would have put pressure on Greens and FDP (pro arms deliveries) to choose between their conscience and party/coalition lines. Basically, if I'm a Green MP, I can't vote for the CDU proposal because it's by the opposition and the senior coalition partner disagrees. But I can't vote against it, because in essence it's a stance I agree with. Basically, this is the kind of stuff that -under the right circumstances- can fracture a coalition government and lose a government its support in parliament.

      In order to avoid this bind, the coalition cut the CDU a deal: You get to make some light changes, we all vote on this together, no one gets hurt. The changes the coalition wanted to make were largely symbolic in nature, it seems, and they largely didn't happen.

      Again, not so sure what to think of the matter, aside from the usual posturing described above. As far as I can tell, what's in it largely encodes existing political consensus, and I was not aware the government needed an invitation or permission to act on that. I know I'm the resident German voice in this thread, but I really can't give a concrete statement as to the significance of this petition.

      3 votes
  4. [4]
    skybrian
    Link
    Poland confirms T-72 tank delivery to Ukraine, with Challenger 2 tanks to fill gap [...]

    Poland confirms T-72 tank delivery to Ukraine, with Challenger 2 tanks to fill gap

    Poland’s prime minister has confirmed the country supplied its Soviet-designed T-72 tanks to Ukraine to support the fight against Russia, which invaded Ukraine Feb. 24.

    The announcement came shortly after his British counterpart Boris Johnson unveiled plans to supply an undisclosed number of Challenger 2 tanks to Poland to “backfill” the operational needs of its military.

    [...]

    Earlier this month, Poland signed a deal worth about $4.75 billion to buy 250 M1A2 Abrams SEPv3 tanks from the U.S.

    3 votes
    1. [3]
      vektor
      Link Parent
      Challenger 2s? Doesn't Poland operate Leopard 2s? And they want to introduce another tank to their fleet? Sad KMW noises.

      Challenger 2s? Doesn't Poland operate Leopard 2s? And they want to introduce another tank to their fleet? Sad KMW noises.

      1. [2]
        JakeTheDog
        Link Parent
        What do you mean?

        Sad KMW noises.

        What do you mean?

        1 vote
        1. vektor
          Link Parent
          KMW is the manufacturer of the German Leo 2 tanks. I was thinking if they want to backfill, they'd do it using more of the modern tanks they already operate. That said, the above was a joke. I'm...

          KMW is the manufacturer of the German Leo 2 tanks. I was thinking if they want to backfill, they'd do it using more of the modern tanks they already operate.

          That said, the above was a joke. I'm not sad because KMW didn't get the deal or anything.

          2 votes
  5. skybrian
    Link
    Poland spent decades trying to quit Russian gas. Now it has no choice. (Washington Post) [...]

    Poland spent decades trying to quit Russian gas. Now it has no choice. (Washington Post)

    Poland consumes about 20 billion cubic meters (bcm) of gas a year. About half of that has come via pipelines from Russia. Poland produces 3 bcm domestically and imports more than 6 bcm of liquefied natural gas, or LNG, a year through a relatively new Baltic Sea port that is set to expand this year. Much of that LNG comes from the United States and Norway.

    The most important piece of Poland’s independence strategy is the soon-to-be christened pipeline from Norway, which the nation’s minister of climate and environment, Anna Moskwa, calls “the great pride of Mr. Naimski.”

    When that underwater link starts shipping gas in a few months, it will have the capacity to deliver 10 bcm to Poland a year — more than making up for the quantities Russia was supplying.

    A big question now is whether Norway and Denmark, whose territory the pipeline crosses, will cooperate to speed the start date of the pipeline.

    Roszkowski said it might be possible to open the pipeline earlier. But even if not, he and other analysts said Poland should be able to weather the next several months because its gas storage tanks are more than 75 percent full and because it can probably import some gas from Germany in a pinch.

    [...]

    Naimski’s next priority is to complete construction of a second LNG terminal, in the port city of Gdansk. It was originally scheduled for completion in late 2027, but he’s aiming to get it done by 2025.

    After Poland secures its own domestic supply, Naimski hopes to have gas left over to provide to the nation’s E.U. allies.

    3 votes
  6. [2]
    FishFingus
    Link
    The US's Lend-Lease act (2.0) has passed 417-10 and is on its say to Biden's desk. Bulgaria will repair Ukrainian military hardware. They will also, IIRC, be providing tanks of their own, along...

    The US's Lend-Lease act (2.0) has passed 417-10 and is on its say to Biden's desk.

    Bulgaria will repair Ukrainian military hardware. They will also, IIRC, be providing tanks of their own, along with Poland, Czechia and Slovenia. Slovenia will receive German military hardware to replace their own tanks.

    Britain will replenish Poland's tank stocks with Challenger 2 tanks, while also sending Stormer IFVs with Starstreak missile systems to Ukraine.

    3 votes
    1. cfabbro
      (edited )
      Link Parent
      Speaking of heavy weaponry, here's another interesting bit of news related to the German Gepards: Ammo problem solved? Brazil wants to equip German Gepard tanks for Ukraine with 300,000 rounds...

      Speaking of heavy weaponry, here's another interesting bit of news related to the German Gepards:
      Ammo problem solved? Brazil wants to equip German Gepard tanks for Ukraine with 300,000 rounds (Business Insider DE, auto translated)

      The alleged problem with the lack of ammunition for the approximately 50 Cheetah anti-aircraft tanks for Ukraine seems to have been solved: According to information from Business Insider from government circles, Brazil is planning to sell Ukraine around 300,000 rounds of ammunition. So far it was only known that the Munich manufacturer Kraus-Maffei Wegmann (KMW), which wants to deliver the vehicles, only had around 23,000 rounds of ammunition in stock, according to "Bild". With up to 1100 rounds per minute, the supply would only have lasted for a few minutes.

      Apparently, the Ukrainian Ministry of Defense managed to get the ammunition itself. After all, the deal between KMW and Ukraine was also bilateral, but the federal government had to agree to the delivery - which has since been done. Jordan and Qatar are also said to have been asked to supply ammunition. However, it is unclear whether these countries also sell ammunition.

      Federal Defense Minister Christine Lambrecht (SPD) said on ZDF on Wednesday evening that the federal government would "of course continue to support Ukraine to ensure that sufficient ammunition can be organized". The training on the cheetah will run through the manufacturer. According to information from Business Insider, the Bundeswehr has not yet been asked for support.

      2 votes
  7. [2]
    skybrian
    Link
    Here's a long Twitter thread talking about US (mostly) missile logistics and how it can be screwed up: https://twitter.com/TrentTelenko/status/1519401885534498816

    Here's a long Twitter thread talking about US (mostly) missile logistics and how it can be screwed up: https://twitter.com/TrentTelenko/status/1519401885534498816

    2 votes
  8. cfabbro
    Link
    Canada lawmakers vote unanimously to label Russia's acts in Ukraine as 'genocide' (Reuters)

    Canada lawmakers vote unanimously to label Russia's acts in Ukraine as 'genocide' (Reuters)

    Canadian lawmakers voted unanimously on Wednesday to call Russia's attacks in Ukraine a "genocide", with members of parliament saying there was "ample evidence of systemic and massive war crimes against humanity" being committed by Moscow.

    The Canadian House of Commons' motion said war crimes by Russia include mass atrocities, systematic instances of willful killing of Ukrainian civilians, the desecration of corpses, forcible transfer of Ukrainian children, torture, physical harm, mental harm, and rape.

    2 votes
  9. skybrian
    (edited )
    Link
    How Kyiv was saved by Ukrainian ingenuity as well as Russian blunders From April 9. I think I've read most of these stories before, but not this one detail.

    How Kyiv was saved by Ukrainian ingenuity as well as Russian blunders

    Moscow’s forces were thwarted, too, by pieces of foam mat — the Ukrainians call them karemats — costing as little as £1.50. The mats prevent Russian thermal imaging drones from detecting human heat. “We held the karemats over our head,” said Konoko, explaining how his men moved stealthily in tiny groups at night.

    In that way soldiers armed with anti-tank weapons supplied by the US, Britain and others could sneak up on the Russians, fire their deadly and accurate missiles and then slip away.

    From April 9. I think I've read most of these stories before, but not this one detail.

    2 votes
  10. [2]
    skybrian
    Link
    #RF economy weekly April 19, 2022 — April 25, 2022 This Medium account has weekly updates on the Russian economy, by a Ukrainian economist or journalist it seems? Found via a Twitter thread from...

    #RF economy weekly April 19, 2022 — April 25, 2022

    This Medium account has weekly updates on the Russian economy, by a Ukrainian economist or journalist it seems?

    • Energy: In the 1st half of Apr, the average daily refining fell by 6%. Shipments of Russian oil by sea for the week fell by 25% — Bloomberg. India’s state-owned oil refining companies plan to buy as much oil as possible from Russia. Export of Russian coal in April collapsed by more than 20%, and since the beginning of the year, the decline was 9%.

    • Divestment of Japanese, US and British companies from RF LNG projects poses a risk of China taking over more control of RF offshore oil and gas development, thus making Japan hesitate over withdrawal. Japanese trading company Marubeni Group (owns 30% of the Sakhalin-1; ExxonMobil owns 30% withdrawing from RF; the rest is owned by India and Russia) decided to withdraw from Russia. Yet, Japanese companies Mitsubishi and Mitsui decided to continue Sakhalin-2 LNG project (they own 22.5%; Shell owns 27.5% withdrawing from RF; Gazprom holds 50%). Chinese state companies have already announced plans to buy Shell’s stake.

    Found via a Twitter thread from the Ukrainian economist Tymofiy Mylovanov, which retweets similar information. Mylovanov has been awarded funds by Marginal Revolution.

    1 vote
    1. cfabbro
      Link Parent
      https://kse.ua/people/natalya-shapoval/

      by a Ukrainian economist or journalist it seems?

      https://kse.ua/people/natalya-shapoval/

      Chairman of KSE Institute, Vice President for Policy Research, Member of Advisory Board of Center of Excellence in Procurement, Member of Editorial Board of VoxUkraine, Trade +, Center of Excellence in Procurement

      1 vote