9
votes
Hong Kong police families call for independent inquiry into protest clashes (translation of the demonstration's speakers in comments)
Link information
This data is scraped automatically and may be incorrect.
- Authors
- Elson Tong
- Published
- Aug 25 2019
- Word count
- 469 words
Though it's hardly the most dramatic thing to happen today (off the top of my head: water cannons used for the first time, guns drawn and pointed at protesters and journalists & at least one shot fired in the air, protesters and police beaten, more white-shirted thugs with metal bars, protesters attacking a triad-linked establishment, more tear gas and arrests) I thought this offered an interesting and not-often talked about perspective. It's easy to dehumanize the police themselves and think of them as a monolith but whatever moral responsibility individual officers have they do not all have the same thoughts and have not all taken the same actions, and in the end the main responsibility for oppressing the people of Hong Kong lies with the totalitarian state that rules them.
The live thread on Reddit included translations of the speakers at the police families demonstration and I think it's worth reading their words. What's below is copy-pasted from the live thread but any formatting errors are my own.
The speakers are standing between banners that say “Return the police to the people.”
Speaker 1 (woman in large sunglasses and blue medical mask):
Speaker 2 (a woman wearing a grey, wide brim hat with silver sunglasses and black full-face mask):
Please note: There is no Speaker 3.
Speaker 4:
Speaker 5:
Speaker 6:
Speaker 7:
Speaker 8 (a man with no mask):
Speaker 9 (a man with no mask in black and wearing backpack against his chest):
Speaker 10 (young woman with black floppy hat and black mask):
Organizer:
Music plays.
Organizer:
Organizer reads and crowd follows.
Organizer:
The organizer and crowd chants:
The march begins.
This is potentially a big development, from what I know of so-called color revolutions, if the police join the protesters then it's a matter of time until the revolution is successful. IIRC that's exactly how it played out in the Orange Revolution in Ukraine.