31 votes

How Zohran Mamdani fought the master plan | The key factor isn’t his ads or charisma — it is a public campaign finance system that can be replicated across the US

6 comments

  1. [2]
    dustylungs
    Link
    The idea goes back to Teddy Roosevelt who was responding to corruption in the Gilded Age:

    Thanks to New York City’s nearly four-decade-old clean elections system that publicly finances candidates for municipal office, Mamdani has had nearly $13 million of government funds to run a competitive campaign against tens of millions of dollars that oligarchs spent to boost disgraced Democratic former governor Andrew Cuomo.

    the biggest lesson in Mamdani’s race is that — regardless of your political party or ideology — if you want candidates who come from outside the system and aren’t puppets of big donors and corrupt political machines, then you should get behind the nonpartisan movement to publicly finance the elections in your community, your state, and your country.

    The idea goes back to Teddy Roosevelt who was responding to corruption in the Gilded Age:

    “There is a very radical measure which would, I believe, work a substantial improvement in our system of conducting a campaign,” Roosevelt wrote in his annual message to Congress that year. “The need for collecting large campaign funds would vanish if Congress provided an appropriation for the proper and legitimate expenses of each of the great national parties, an appropriation ample enough to meet the necessity for thorough organization and machinery, which requires a large expenditure of money.”

    22 votes
    1. PuddleOfKittens
      Link Parent
      As an Australian, I would like to smugly remind everyone that we already have this in law for every party that gets at least 4% of the vote. It has room for improvement, particularly in the form...

      if Congress provided an appropriation for the proper and legitimate expenses of each of the great national parties, an appropriation ample enough to meet the necessity for thorough organization and machinery, which requires a large expenditure of money.”

      As an Australian, I would like to smugly remind everyone that we already have this in law for every party that gets at least 4% of the vote.

      It has room for improvement, particularly in the form of banning corporate donations (and capping donations to ~$1000/year/person), but it exists, it works, and it's not new.

      7 votes
  2. [3]
    donn
    Link
    Well, now I'm concerned. If his success involves passing similar laws around the US then it's borderline irreplicable.

    Well, now I'm concerned. If his success involves passing similar laws around the US then it's borderline irreplicable.

    10 votes
    1. [2]
      dustylungs
      Link Parent
      I still see it as a glimmer of hope. But along the lines of your concern, I can already imagine the anti-public-campaign-financing media blitz: "He's Muslim! He's a socialist! He's probably...

      I still see it as a glimmer of hope. But along the lines of your concern, I can already imagine the anti-public-campaign-financing media blitz: "He's Muslim! He's a socialist! He's probably gay-friendly too! Look what happens when you let liberals use your tax dollars to finance public office campaigns."

      6 votes
      1. teaearlgraycold
        Link Parent
        I can see it working in other liberal cities. If he works out in practice then maybe SF would try public funding.

        I can see it working in other liberal cities. If he works out in practice then maybe SF would try public funding.

        4 votes
  3. raze2012
    Link
    Ahh yes, "non-partisanship". Somehow that will be taken to mean bipartisan pressure to not let this happen elsewhere. Neither establishment truly wants outsiders to have a shot. But I do hope we...

    you should get behind the nonpartisan movement to publicly finance the elections in your community, your state, and your country.

    Ahh yes, "non-partisanship". Somehow that will be taken to mean bipartisan pressure to not let this happen elsewhere. Neither establishment truly wants outsiders to have a shot.

    But I do hope we start to see more push on this in coming years. It's not quite taking money out if politics, but it's a good step forward

    6 votes