8 votes

Topic deleted by author

4 comments

  1. [2]
    mycketforvirrad
    Link
    I always prefer to avoid acronyms wherever possible in the tags, but united states of america would be an unwieldy tag for the amount that it gets used. Here the acronym makes sense. I tag all UK...

    I always prefer to avoid acronyms wherever possible in the tags, but united states of america would be an unwieldy tag for the amount that it gets used. Here the acronym makes sense.

    I tag all UK posts with united kingdom followed by a separate scotland.edinburgh tag. This is more to do with sensitivity to the issue of governance among the residents of these regions under the UK umbrella, rather than following a rigid rule such as united kingdom.scotland.edinburgh. Plus personal preference, I try to avoid double dots in any tags wherever I can.

    The tags should be more organic in my eyes, more instinctive to implement for first time users, rather than getting bogged down in the mire that can be the Dewey decimal style classification.

    9 votes
    1. drannex
      Link Parent
      +1 Scotland should never be listed under the United Kingdom as a secondary tag, especially with the way things are looking for their independence.

      +1 Scotland should never be listed under the United Kingdom as a secondary tag, especially with the way things are looking for their independence.

      6 votes
  2. [2]
    SheepWolf
    (edited )
    Link
    Tags and hierarchy are two topics that get discussed every now and then (along with groups and subgroups). Since Tildes is still in early development, I am not certain if there are strict...

    Tags and hierarchy are two topics that get discussed every now and then (along with groups and subgroups). Since Tildes is still in early development, I am not certain if there are strict standards implemented yet (nor do I think there should be). I do however trust that the ones most familiar with Tildes development are aware of those topics and working towards that end.

    Related topics:

    GitLab issues that I think apply:

    4 votes
    1. SheepWolf
      Link Parent
      Off-topic, but I think I like topics like these. They make Tildes feel a bit organic. I imagine something like: User(s) identify something that might be fixed or suggest features they might want...

      Off-topic, but I think I like topics like these. They make Tildes feel a bit organic.

      I imagine something like:

      1. User(s) identify something that might be fixed or suggest features they might want to see.
      2. Someone proposes what might work e.g. a set of standards for tagging. Others also submit what they might prefer.
      3. Discussion and debate of 2.
      4. A GitLab issue is submitted
      5. Issue gets assigned a priority and processed somewhere along the development workflow.
      6. Eventually, if it's not rejected or redesigned, the feature gets implemented. Alternatively more discussion is opened.
      7. Feedback is then given. Maybe more improvements follow that?
      5 votes