V17's recent activity

  1. Comment on The tech industry is investing in mega gas plants to power their data centers in ~enviro

    V17
    Link Parent
    Generally the projects that want to build their own gas plants are significantly larger than those, but I admit I don't know where the boundary is.

    Generally the projects that want to build their own gas plants are significantly larger than those, but I admit I don't know where the boundary is.

    1 vote
  2. Comment on The tech industry is investing in mega gas plants to power their data centers in ~enviro

    V17
    Link Parent
    Perhaps, but you still need to keep the gas power plant ran in a way that allows you to quickly start it (I have no idea if that makes maintenance more expensive than running continually, I would...

    Perhaps, but you still need to keep the gas power plant ran in a way that allows you to quickly start it (I have no idea if that makes maintenance more expensive than running continually, I would guess it does, but in any case you still need to keep it ready, have employees there at all times etc.), you still need batteries to load balance things like passing clouds, you still need a ton of land for the solar. Not worth it at the moment.

  3. Comment on The tech industry is investing in mega gas plants to power their data centers in ~enviro

    V17
    Link Parent
    I did some back of the napkin calculations earlier this year and based on those we're not nearly at the point where this would be anywhere close to worth it. The energy requirements of data...

    Not necessarily full time though. Natural gas plants can serve as backup for alternative energy.

    I did some back of the napkin calculations earlier this year and based on those we're not nearly at the point where this would be anywhere close to worth it. The energy requirements of data centers are massive and the cost of batteries even for just overnight storage is brutal. When we want more than overnight, it gets insane. And that doesn't take into account the amount of land it would take. If the trends in battery costs continue, we may get there, but for this generation of data centers it's not going to happen because it's simply not viable.

    2 votes
  4. Comment on The tech industry is investing in mega gas plants to power their data centers in ~enviro

    V17
    Link Parent
    Long term gas storage seems like an orders of magnitude cheaper problem than even short term battery storage.

    What happens to the gas line pressure when that second gas-fired power generation system that has the capacity equal to the renewables but almost never gets turned on... gets turned on? Well, it goes down.

    Long term gas storage seems like an orders of magnitude cheaper problem than even short term battery storage.

    5 votes
  5. Comment on Share something niche! in ~talk

    V17
    Link
    How about offline instead? Almost every time I go to an exhibition and most times I go to a concert I think "holy shit, the curated youtube/instagram/reddit experience is so limited and you never...

    What's going on in your far-away corner of the web?

    How about offline instead? Almost every time I go to an exhibition and most times I go to a concert I think "holy shit, the curated youtube/instagram/reddit experience is so limited and you never realize until you get out!" Even in the niche communities (including Tildes), almost everything that's shared has to have some sort of slight meme-like qualities, not necessarily in a stupid way, but it has to have some immediate hook, because otherwise people don't spontaneously share it.

    Here's some incredible art I recently saw in the offline world.

    I went to see a documentary about one my second favorite Czech visual artist, František Skála. He's primarily a sculptor and painter, but he also does music, sometimes theatre and other things. He's 70 years old and still crowdsurfs at concerts of... a brass band. Incredibly likeable, creative and inspirational personality. Some of his works are in the trailer, automatic subtitle translation into English works, though not that much is said. Some of his works can be seen here or just on google images, but honestly the best thing about the documentary was just seeing how he lives his life - full of energy, ideas, (non-toxic and honest) positivity, laughter.

    I've had a poster with one of his works above my various beds for at least 20 years, since I was a teenager, it's called Art Does Not End With Death and shows a decorated human skeleton. Feels like home.


    I also went to see some contemporary music, which is not something I do regularly. One of the pioneers of microtonal music, Alois Hába, invented a sixth-tone (instead of standard half-tone) pump organ about a century ago, which is in the Czech national museum and since it's a world unique, it's quite difficult to convince the museum to move it and use it in concerts.

    Recently some contemporary music enthusiasts had a replica made, so now for the first time ever there are two such instruments in existence and people are writing new sixth-tone music, using it as a solo instrument with a small "standard" orchestra (which is anything but - playing microtonal music requires very high skill levels). I think the concert I went to was the second concert ever with the new instrument, and it included one classic piece from the inventor and five world premieres of new pieces written specifically for this orchestra.

    I wanted to share the music here as some of it was actually quite easy to like, nothing hyper intellectual, and somebody in the first row made a bootleg video with good sound and put it on youtube. But apparently that was just a mistake and the videos were made private a few days later. Most of the sixth-tone music available is not exactly easy to appreciate. I am sharing it nevertheless so that you can be aware that it exists:

    Here's some century old music by Hába, the inventor, which shows how it looks from up close.

    Here's a contemporary piece by Phil Niblock, a rather famous composer who died a couple years ago. It's basically a 20 minutes long harmonically complex drone.

    Here's a contemporary piece by Ian Mikyska, a young Czech composer, who uses the instrument in a completely different, much simpler style and combines it with electronic music and field recordings - which makes some sense, since the pump organ is sonically and in its controls something akin to a vintage mechanical synthesizer.

    6 votes
  6. Comment on A couple of posts about AI and the Independent Games Festival awards in ~games

    V17
    Link Parent
    That sounds improbable because there's a ton of money in not doing that. IP law was respected in the past because it wasn't financially worth it to go against it and, on the contrary, there was a...

    That sounds improbable because there's a ton of money in not doing that. IP law was respected in the past because it wasn't financially worth it to go against it and, on the contrary, there was a lot of money in upholding it. These days it seems to be the opposite, whoever creates and upholds strict IP laws against AI model training voluntarily forfeits their place in the AI arms race. Maybe the EU is going to do it because we love to shoot ourselves in the foot and reduce our economic competitiveness with regulation, but I don't think the US will.

    9 votes
  7. Comment on Swipeblocked: the phrases your iPhone won't suggest in ~tech

    V17
    Link Parent
    Yeah, it reminds me of when "we" changed the gun emoji to a water gun emoji.

    Yeah, it reminds me of when "we" changed the gun emoji to a water gun emoji.

    7 votes
  8. Comment on US Democrats win enough seats nationwide to (potentially) end Electoral College via the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact in ~society

    V17
    (edited )
    Link Parent
    No, my argument is that they care about state rights if it affects red states, and getting rid of electoral college would plausibly affect red states negatively. That part is not a lie and it's a...

    No, my argument is that they care about state rights if it affects red states, and getting rid of electoral college would plausibly affect red states negatively. That part is not a lie and it's a strong argument on its own, it's just that they will undoubtedly build a more effective argument than I can do in five minutes.

    The problem with "republicans always lie about and spin anything democrats do anyway" is that it's a binary statement and reality is anything but. Republicans are not all idiots and their reaction to various "democrats are doing xxxx" is different not only based on how elaborate the spin is or other semi-random factors but also based on how bad and blatant the act is. Unilaterally ending electoral college would be quite high on that spectrum.

    edit: another true argument that requires no hypocrisy from the republicans is simply that such a change would have far reaching consequences that are impossible to predict, and that it goes against the principles based on which the country was established.

    5 votes
  9. Comment on RIP Cybertruck. You were unloved, unwanted, and utterly absurd. in ~transport

    V17
    Link Parent
    I think that's to a large degree because the other Tesla cars mostly look and function normal, whereas the Cybertruck screams "look at me!" and is less practical, so it naturally gets more hate....

    I think that's to a large degree because the other Tesla cars mostly look and function normal, whereas the Cybertruck screams "look at me!" and is less practical, so it naturally gets more hate. The majority of online hate towards how the Cybertruck looks that I've seen is Elon-related.

    3 votes
  10. Comment on RIP Cybertruck. You were unloved, unwanted, and utterly absurd. in ~transport

    V17
    Link Parent
    Normally my personal values say that since the car is not sold anymore and you're not giving any money to Musk, anybody who has an ethical problem with it can suck a bag of dicks. But imo for the...

    Normally my personal values say that since the car is not sold anymore and you're not giving any money to Musk, anybody who has an ethical problem with it can suck a bag of dicks. But imo for the foreseeable future you're going to be perceived as a Musk fan by anybody who doesn't know you, and that would be really annoying, plus the non-existent third party maintenance issue is a good point. EVs generally require way less maintenance than ICE vehicles, but surely they require some at some point.

    3 votes
  11. Comment on RIP Cybertruck. You were unloved, unwanted, and utterly absurd. in ~transport

    V17
    Link Parent
    I think that was already after the weird "calling a diver a pedophile" incident, and in any case right next year he became very unpopular on the left due to his reaction to various covid related...

    I think that was already after the weird "calling a diver a pedophile" incident, and in any case right next year he became very unpopular on the left due to his reaction to various covid related restrictions etc.

    13 votes
  12. Comment on US Democrats win enough seats nationwide to (potentially) end Electoral College via the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact in ~society

    V17
    Link Parent
    Not really. "Blue states have slightly more people due to immigration (or whatever) and ending electoral college would ultimately give them more power over red states, reducing our state rights as...

    The NavPoInterCo is ultimately an expression of the freedom that the US constitution gives to states. If the republicans want to argue against it, the party of states rights will need to argue that states should have less rights.

    Not really. "Blue states have slightly more people due to immigration (or whatever) and ending electoral college would ultimately give them more power over red states, reducing our state rights as a consequence". The second part of the sentence is not even wrong exactly, and the fact that the immigration part is made up doesn't matter. And I'm sure they could come up with something more sophisticated than I could.

    2 votes
  13. Comment on US Democrats win enough seats nationwide to (potentially) end Electoral College via the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact in ~society

    V17
    (edited )
    Link Parent
    I agree with this and the amount of delusional black and white thinking here like "republicans always lie about and spin anything democrats do anyway, so it doesn't matter what they actually do"...

    I agree with this and the amount of delusional black and white thinking here like "republicans always lie about and spin anything democrats do anyway, so it doesn't matter what they actually do" is insane. It's like people think that everyone who votes republican is an idiot whose opinion doesn't matter and that they don't all have to live in the same country. Attitudes like this are what got Trump elected twice.

    But.

    At the same time, even though the immediate consequences would almost certainly be bad, maybe it's the only way to push it through and force Republicans to slightly reform in order to stay competitive, which could be good for everyone. That, or it would create a new Trump, I think it's about 50:50.

    In any case the consequences would be far reaching and almost impossible to predict. So yeah, likely a terrible idea and I think most democrats know this.

    4 votes
  14. Comment on RIP Cybertruck. You were unloved, unwanted, and utterly absurd. in ~transport

    V17
    (edited )
    Link Parent
    I never post or comment but as someone who just follows people Twitter is one of the better platforms. Many non-political or even leftist (Benn Jordan for example) people still post there, some of...

    I never post or comment but as someone who just follows people Twitter is one of the better platforms. Many non-political or even leftist (Benn Jordan for example) people still post there, some of them do not post anywhere else, and as opposed to almost any other platform it easily allows you to set up feeds with content only from selected people, chronologically, and not encounter The Algorithm anywhere. Plus community notes actually work pretty well too. I assume Bluesky is similar, feature-wise, but some of the people I follow aren't there and I'm not thrilled about having western leftist politics everywhere either.

    edit: also it's crazy that Musks insane cost-cutting treatment that happened right after the purchase seemingly just worked. I'd love to see some unbiased analysis done today.

    9 votes
  15. Comment on RIP Cybertruck. You were unloved, unwanted, and utterly absurd. in ~transport

    V17
    Link
    I'm going to go against the grain here and say that I actually like how it looks. Yes, it's childish, it's like a young boy's idea of what a cool and futuristic car would look like, without...

    I'm going to go against the grain here and say that I actually like how it looks.

    Yes, it's childish, it's like a young boy's idea of what a cool and futuristic car would look like, without considering practicality. And that is precisely what I like about it. I'd bet that if the author wasn't Elon, it would be much more popular in some online circles. It is also supposedly quite comfortable and fun to drive.

    Ultimately as a product it is kind of stupid, especially because they failed to do the basics, like making it actually tough and durable, that's relevant even for people who don't care about safety. So I'm hardly sad about this, but I do think that the hate is overblown due to Elon's personality and not the actual car.

    16 votes
  16. Comment on Could El Salvador’s Nayib Bukele be Haiti’s savior? in ~society

    V17
    Link
    I don't trust Bukele and the issues of his system are obvious - CECOT can be and likely is abused, corruption still surely happens, there's evidence of him collaborating with some of the gangs,...

    I don't trust Bukele and the issues of his system are obvious - CECOT can be and likely is abused, corruption still surely happens, there's evidence of him collaborating with some of the gangs, the question of when if ever the restrictions to freedom are going to be lifted...

    ...But at the same time I think some of his ideas are brilliant and are currently the best and possibly only practically tested ways to deal with a failed state like El Salvador. I don't know enough about El Salvador and Haiti to tell if it could translate, but it was designed specifically for situations like these.

    Everybody heard about CECOT, whose purpose is to separate the most dangerous gang leaders from society so that they cannot escape or run their organizations from the prison as they usually do, and to minimize the probability of corruption within the prison to ensure those things. This is understandable and logical, but it comes at the cost of borderline inhumane conditions and possibly serving as a way to just hide politically inconvenient people from society.

    But the other half is prisons for the rest of the population. In a failed state with extreme criminality the issue is that nearly everyone is a criminal, you have to punish them in some way if you want to send a society-wide signal that crime is no longer acceptable and things are going to change from now on, but also you need to actually rehabilitate them and give them a way to integrate into society.

    So the "normal people prisons" are completely different and are based on the "zero leisure" concept - do not give the prisoners any time for normal prison shit and instead fill all of their time with mandatory education and labor that iirc is not technically mandatory, but every day worked reduces your sentence by another day, cutting your sentence in half if you work every day.

    This can only work in a failed state like El Salvador where the prison population does not consist of criminals as we see them in the western world, but to a large degree normal people - all of the education, job organizing and training are done by other inmates because enough of them are qualified in various fields. The labor is used to rebuild the state: maintaining vehicles for the emergency services and the army, building furniture for schools, sewing uniforms, inmates with good behavior and low escape risk can even work outside in agriculture etc. They get trained in jobs that they can generally do after they get out.

    The problems here are also obvious when you think about it - the absolutely massive numbers of criminals mean the due process is questionable, some of these experimental prisons work worse than others, so there are issues with overcrowding, bad conditions, and the whole "not technically forced labor" is ethically questionable at best.

    But I think many of these criticisms are also written from a narrow minded view of people living in the comfort of reasonably safe and functional societies. Even with their issues the prisons generally offer much better conditions than before. And more importantly, I just don't see a better way to transform the country and rebuild its society from such an extreme state it was in than this.

    And so if any recipe was going to work in Haiti, it would be something similar. The issue is that it would be expensive and it would require active participation from the inside, not just force from the outside. Coming from an ex-failed state in central America could help here, as Haitians understandably have a dislike and distrust towards foreign interventions, but it's aimed primarily towards the west. However, even if they decided to implement a similar plan, Haiti seems a level more screwed than El Salvador and I'm not sure if they have enough competent people to do it.

    So I guess I too am skeptical, but for different reasons. I dislike Bukele and his methods should be scrutinized, but many of the arguments against him don't hold up if you consider how unimaginably terrible the situation was before him and for how long, how everyone else failed.

    2 votes
  17. Comment on Timasomo 2026: The Showcase in ~creative.timasomo

    V17
    Link
    Untitled Golf Game I did not openly participate and share progress since my project was already started in September, but I have now noticed that actually this year's Timasomo is called...

    Untitled Golf Game

    I did not openly participate and share progress since my project was already started in September, but I have now noticed that actually this year's Timasomo is called TIMASOORCOANOLPRTHYOALSTMO and allows this, and therefore I will now happily share. The majority of the work was done in October.


    What is it

    My project is an in-browser golf videogame - name not decided yet. I have never played golf or made a videogame, but I have played several golf videogames, so I guess I'm good. Golf games have been done countless times and aren't super popular these days, so what makes mine special?

    I love the look of late 90s/early 00s golf games, which had a weird contrast of abstract and photorealistic graphics, because they were low-poly and low-res, but at the same time used photo cutouts for all the plants and other objects that make a golf course. For me they're cozy, relaxing games while avoiding all the cozy clichés of pastel colors, pixel art, anthropomorphic animals etc. The downside is that the traditional photo cutouts are not exactly universal - their lighting is baked in, so they work in one type of weather, one time of the day and one sun orientation. It doesn't scale.

    My goal is to make a game that can be constantly supplied with a metric fuckton of courses, some quite realistic, some fictional, and some slightly weird or whimsical. I really want to make a golf course with a crashed UFO and a golf course with several dug holes and police tape plus a patrol car nearby, implying we're playing around buried bodies. I will also make a golf course that's a huge scaled version of some standard miniature golf course.

    The physics is reasonably complex and hopefully realistic, but that's not interesting.

    The interesting part

    So the main part of the game, which stays completely hidden from the player, is a relatively complex and branching system for creating golf courses, or at this moment (and perhaps it'll stay that way) only individual holes. The goal is to use a combination of procedural generation, real public data, visual-language model AI agents plus a normal, human-driven level editor to reduce the time and effort needed to create a course by at the very least an order of magnitude, while still creating interesting holes and scenery.

    This involves various interesting things, like using a semantic level format that is understandable by an AI agent (so it cannot require working with huge arrays of numbers like height maps or item coordinates directly, which agents are bad at), generating easily readable top-down minimaps or annotated screenshots. So we procedurally generate the most likely ball locations on a course, the agent looks at the screenshots that represent what the user will see from those places and say "this tree covers an important sand bunker next to the green, let's move it, and let's add some interesting terrain feature and scattered bushes over there because the area is empty and boring". The changes are made and the agent looks at it again, etc. until it looks good. I can then edit whatever I want of course.

    Things like that have a proof of concept implementation and are being refined. I don't know how well it's going to work, but I know it's going to work. Currently I'm working on a basic level editor, which would allow me to edit the courses by hand, but also mark specific spots, areas and features, and create jobs for the agent to do to fix or improve them. I can also create rough facsimiles of real golf courses in Czechia (and hopefully later elsewhere) from publicly available orthophotography and lidar terrain data largely automatically. That works and looks pretty great. And it turns out that an image to image model, in this case GPT Image, is an excellent segmentation tool for the aerial photos.

    Graphics: the other interesting part

    One struggle that I have is graphics. I deliberately chose the oldschool-inspired style not just because I like it but also because it's cheap to produce, of course. I never wanted to copy the old games, that's not good enough these days, but I sort of wanted to recreate how they look in our memory - improve, but keep it simple.

    So instead of using actual tree photo cutouts, I still used 2D tree bilboards, but in the form of tree textures with removed shadows, and created a way to shade them dynamically as if they were 3D (it's a fake of course, but it looks really good). In the process I accidentally approached photorealism, which made everything else in the game look kind of bad in comparison.

    So now (like literally this evening) I'm recreating the very basic ground textures, testing effects like ambient occlusion that I can add in the game thanks to it being almost entirely static (therefore many things can be precomputed and don't make the game more demanding to run), and consulting various techniques with a senior engine developer at an AA gamedev company, who happens to be my friend. The issue is that the whole thing is made in javascript and should run on phones as well, so I'm heavily computationally limited and most of the obvious optimizations are already done.

    The state of the game

    I wanted to release an alpha by the end of October, which didn't happen, but it will almost certainly happen by the end of November.

    The graphics work is the most important one now. I need to create/redo a couple tree sprites, maybe add some more grass/flowers, plus improve a couple materials. Possibly create some actual horizon strips instead of the unedited HDRI skyboxes I use now. Then I need to redo the HUD, but that doesn't need to be final, it just needs to fix some current annoying UX nonsense, so that should be relatively quick. Oh, yeah, and a good enough tutorial page, well, hopefully I can make it by the end of November anyway. The course creation tools at least are already good enough to create a few decent testing holes.

    Here are some screenshots, fresh off the press - so fresh in fact that this comment has been waiting here for the last two hours till I finish everything I wanted to do:

    A very similar golf hole actually exists in Prague, not in the Alps
    This one is just outside of Prague
    Very happy with the sand, less so with the rough grass
    This was the first, completely procedurally-agentic made hole
    Same screenshot as below, for comparison

    For comparison these are the first and last screenshots above, only with yesterdays engine version, at the "well now that the trees look realistic, the rest of the game looks bad" stage: https://imgur.com/a/untitled-golf-game-engine-test-EiLzcuI

    10 votes
  18. Comment on What programming/technical projects have you been working on? in ~comp

    V17
    Link Parent
    Yeah, the collision mesh is different from the rendered mesh, so this should be easy and I was already considering it. I'll test it.

    Yeah, the collision mesh is different from the rendered mesh, so this should be easy and I was already considering it. I'll test it.

    1 vote
  19. Comment on What programming/technical projects have you been working on? in ~comp

    V17
    Link Parent
    Thanks, yeah, that makes sense. I'm currently exploring how more modern golf games do it, and it seems like they too mostly use simple textures, though sometimes supplemented with things like...

    Thanks, yeah, that makes sense. I'm currently exploring how more modern golf games do it, and it seems like they too mostly use simple textures, though sometimes supplemented with things like grass particles.

  20. Comment on What programming/technical projects have you been working on? in ~comp

    V17
    Link Parent
    I see imgur seems to be broken at the moment, so I reuploaded the screens here: https://postimg.cc/gallery/LJ8hbFg

    I see imgur seems to be broken at the moment, so I reuploaded the screens here: https://postimg.cc/gallery/LJ8hbFg