17 votes

Norway's national football stadium has the world's largest vertical solar roof – new solution for northern regions, yielding 20% more energy than traditional panels

3 comments

  1. zipf_slaw
    Link
    Shouldn't the word "but" imply something contrary to the initial clause? These two characteristics are not exclusive to each other...

    At first glance, the panels look fragile, and one might worry about stepping on them. But during a visit to the stadium, we quickly learn that they are incredibly efficient in generating solar power.

    Shouldn't the word "but" imply something contrary to the initial clause? These two characteristics are not exclusive to each other...

    9 votes
  2. [2]
    Arthur
    Link
    As I was reading this I thought, 'why don't they paint the roof white, wouldn't that boost power generated?' But since they hadn't, I assumed there was a good reason the roof wasn't painted white....

    As I was reading this I thought, 'why don't they paint the roof white, wouldn't that boost power generated?' But since they hadn't, I assumed there was a good reason the roof wasn't painted white. Perhaps it didn't work. Then I read this:

    Vertical PV panels also benefit from the albedo effect, where snow falling between the rows reflects sunlight on

    So perhaps they just don't paint it white because white paint isn't as reflective as snow or it isn't cost efficient? Maybe the white paint will dirty?

    But later it says:

    The company observed how its product performs in southern regions as well. “It performs well, especially when paired with white coloured roofs, which is highly reflective and which are common in hotter, sunnier countries to reduce heat absorption,” notes Mongstad.

    So now I'm even more confused why they don't paint the roof white? I thought perhaps it was for heat absorbtion, but... It's a stadium, so it's not exactly like they're using that heat to heat the building.

    5 votes
    1. Englerdy
      Link Parent
      In northern climates a white roof isn't as beneficial as a darker colored roof since it's a cold climate and building energy use is heating dominated. The increased thermal energy from a dark roof...

      In northern climates a white roof isn't as beneficial as a darker colored roof since it's a cold climate and building energy use is heating dominated. The increased thermal energy from a dark roof is very beneficial in winter compared to the little bit of cooling that's reduced in summer. I'd be very surprised if the extra energy production from these solar panels with a white roof wasn't offset by increased heating demand from the building's heating system.

      The other possiblity is just cost. If heating wasn't an issue, the extra cost to install a white roof (which is more than just paint, I think it's usually a full tarp system that doubles as a water barrier), likely exceeded the money saved from extra production. The cost analysis likely flips for a more southern location. A white roof that would reducing cooling needs AND boosts power output from the panels probably makes a lot of sense financially.

      6 votes