8
votes
A study on the online "filter bubble" found that liberals and conservatives were actually recommended similar stories on Google News, representing a fairly homogeneous set of mainstream news sources
Link information
This data is scraped automatically and may be incorrect.
- Title
- Does your Google News change based on whether you're conservative or liberal?
- Authors
- Laura Hazard Owen
- Word count
- 1168 words
This recently published study in Computers in Human Behavior sampled N=168 people to examine what content the Google News algorithm presented to liberal and conservative users.
Nechushtai, E. & Lewis, S. C. What kind of news gatekeepers do we want machines to be? Filter bubbles, fragmentation, and the normative dimensions of algorithmic recommendations. Computers in Human Behavior (2018).
The problem is that websites shouldn't be doing this to begin with, or at the very least it should be opt-in. When you go on Facebook you don't want to see more of friends posts and less of other friends posts just because you liked more of their posts. When you go on Google you expect it to be neutral and give you the most relevant results. When you go on Youtube you don't want the same 5 videos recommended to you constantly.
That is exactly what this study indicates Google News does. Users are presented a homogeneous set of news sources, regardless of their political inclinations. The algorithm isn't creating a per-user filter bubble of sources. It presents the same large media sources to everyone.
Now if the problem is that websites like Breitbart or InfoWars aren't showing up in the results, then maybe that's an indication of how far a user has deviated from the majority of news consumers.