9 votes

Europa Universalis V: Across The Pillars | Release trailer

5 comments

  1. [5]
    CptBluebear
    Link
    This appears to be another swing and a miss for EU5. This DLC is currently at a comfortable 25% mostly negative on Steam. This one in particular seems to be in dire straits, with the main nations...

    This appears to be another swing and a miss for EU5. This DLC is currently at a comfortable 25% mostly negative on Steam.

    This one in particular seems to be in dire straits, with the main nations in this DLC breaking down rapidly. The Castilians start without boats, main events like the Iberian wedding fail unless you own 50% of the land. No not over 50%, exactly 50%.

    These seem like harmless oversights if it was that in isolation, mistakes happen, but these are just two of many in this DLC alone. Other releases and patches haven't been confidence inspiring either with many other, in what appears to be simple, mistakes.

    9 votes
    1. [2]
      MimicSquid
      Link Parent
      I don't know what's going on with Paradox as a studio. The only remaining game of theirs that seems to still be doing well is Hearts of Iron, with Crusader Kings trailing behind. Something in...

      I don't know what's going on with Paradox as a studio. The only remaining game of theirs that seems to still be doing well is Hearts of Iron, with Crusader Kings trailing behind. Something in their vision or formula broke, and it doesn't look like it's getting fixed.

      3 votes
      1. CptBluebear
        (edited )
        Link Parent
        I have a multitude of opinions, unsubstantiated all, though learnt from experience. Plenty of questionable choices that led them here. In no particular order: Clausewitz was a serviceable engine....

        I have a multitude of opinions, unsubstantiated all, though learnt from experience. Plenty of questionable choices that led them here. In no particular order:

        Clausewitz was a serviceable engine. Nothing great, but it sufficed. It seems that Clausewitz 2 broke their ability to create something that doesn't fall apart when you look at it funny.
        It made their graphics more "modern", but in my opinion it made it visually muddy. Complaints about the UI and UX have been heard since. Optimization is an afterthought.

        Acquisition of the company by outside capital frequently changes the standard operating procedures. Paradox saw this decline happen to them. Smaller patches and higher priced DLC followed. Bug fixes and optimization no longer prioritized. It appears we're at the stage testing barely happens too?

        Their decision to drill down into minutiae turns impactful choices into a flat landscape of boring +1/-1 decisions where every nation plays the same. Can't have anything too wacky, lest the entire numbers upon numbers systems conjured up years ago collapses under its own weight.

        As an extension to that, the absolute breadth of different levers and pulleys they intend to balance like a multitude of spinning plates just makes it all too complex for their own good. Change one thing in system A and system X, Y, and Z collapse because nobody could see it coming. This is then mitigated by introducing the same +1/-1 choices because that's how you keep it safe. The AI frequently chokes up because of some unintended change, either they stop working entirely, or suddenly work too well and can't stop doing that thing only.

        Punishing the player for pushing the envelope. It's no secret the likes of Johan were against world conquests as a matter of principle. Fine in a vacuum, not if that makes your entire balancing principles no more than a game of whack a mole. Argh, a player finally found something fun to do outside of the imposed historical railroad, let's kill that strategy!

        Most importantly, Johan needs someone to rein him in. His unwavering single-minded goal of making everything historical is preventing their games from being games. Their older entries worked better because they were an abstraction of real life, not a simulation of it. Once you enter sim territory you start taking away player agency, as more and more systems become historically guided rather than malleable.
        One of the most frustrating aspects of EU5 (and Victoria 3 for that matter) is that things just happen to me without recourse, and if I do try to respond I hit an invisible wall preventing me from doing so for inexplicable reasons other than it's decided that's not historical or too gamey.
        That loss of player agency is really hurting their games as a whole. There's cosmic irony in how their eternal quest and singular mission for historicity is turning out to be the biggest driver for their lack of vision.

        5 votes
    2. [2]
      Raistlin
      Link Parent
      Seriously, what happened with this game? The devs still seem to be floundering here.

      Seriously, what happened with this game? The devs still seem to be floundering here.

      1 vote
      1. CptBluebear
        Link Parent
        See my other post for an assortment of unstructured ranting. All that aside, EU4 upon release was... Not.. great. It's typical of them to release first and polish later and with the way EU4 was...

        See my other post for an assortment of unstructured ranting.

        All that aside, EU4 upon release was... Not.. great.
        It's typical of them to release first and polish later and with the way EU4 was spruced up people do have (or had) some glimmer of hope, myself included.

        But the longer I look, EU5 especially seems rotten to the core. Something is foundationally not correct and I doubt they can fix themselves out of it.

        6 votes