10 votes

How do we change America?

3 comments

  1. [2]
    NaraVara
    Link
    I was conflicted on posting this in the George Floyd thread. It seemed inappropriate since the intent of the article is to zoom out from the specific issue of police brutality itself to...

    I was conflicted on posting this in the George Floyd thread. It seemed inappropriate since the intent of the article is to zoom out from the specific issue of police brutality itself to interrogating the wider dynamics of race relations. Two money quotes (emphasis mine):

    We cannot insist on “real change” in the United States by continuing to use the same methods, arguments, and failed political strategies that have brought us to this moment. We cannot allow the current momentum to be stalled by a narrow discussion about reforming the police. In Obama’s essay, he wrote, “I saw an elderly black woman being interviewed today in tears because the only grocery store in her neighborhood had been trashed. If history is any guide, that store may take years to come back. So let’s not excuse violence, or rationalize it, or participate in it.” If we are thinking of these problems in big and broad strokes, or in a systemic way, we might ask: Why there is only a single grocery store in this woman’s neighborhood? That might lead to a discussion about the history of residential segregation in that neighborhood, or job discrimination or under-resourced schools in the area, which might, in turn, provide deeper insights into an alienation that is so profound in its intensity that it compels people to fight with the intensity of a riot to demand things change. And this is where the trouble actually begins. Our society cannot end these conditions without massive expenditure.

    If we are serious about ending racism and fundamentally changing the United States, we must begin with a real and serious assessment of the problems. We diminish the task by continuing to call upon the agents and actors who fuelled the crisis when they had opportunities to help solve it. But, more importantly, the quest to transform this country cannot be limited to challenging its brutal police alone. It must conquer the logic that finances police and jails at the expense of public schools and hospitals. Police should not be armed with expensive artillery intended to maim and murder civilians while nurses tie garbage sacks around their bodies and reuse masks in a futile effort to keep the coronavirus at bay.

    7 votes
    1. joplin
      Link Parent
      Yeah, I'm definitely learning a lot about the myriad ways that being a person of color in the US compounds problem on top of problem. You get shittier health care, which causes you to spend more...

      Yeah, I'm definitely learning a lot about the myriad ways that being a person of color in the US compounds problem on top of problem. You get shittier health care, which causes you to spend more on your health; you can't get loans to buy the house you want so you can't build equity; then you get brutalized by the cops for just existing. The fix definitely needs more than just reforming the police, but that's as good a place as any to start. (And honestly it might be the best first step because you won't need healthcare or a house if the police shoot you for being black.)

      I would think that groups like Black Lives Matter know the score and are working on multiple fronts. This one is just the one that's in the forefront right now. The trick is going to be to keep people interested in the cause and get them to lobby and vote for the changes we need to fix this after the protests and riots and looting have gone out of the news cycle. And getting people to vote to fix these problems locally as well as nationally.

      7 votes
  2. vord
    Link
    I think this really embodies what drives a lot of the rhetoric I espose through various platforms. It should be blatantly obvious by now that so many things are not providing results, after...

    I think this really embodies what drives a lot of the rhetoric I espose through various platforms.

    It should be blatantly obvious by now that so many things are not providing results, after decades of them not working. Some examples:

    • Means testing for welfare
    • Imprisoning addicts and mentally ill
    • Privatization of schools
    • Privatization of utilities
    • Allowing monopolies to form, and not breaking them up when they do.
    • Tax cuts for businesses
    • Tax cuts for the wealthy
    • Union busting
    • Commodification of housing
    • Outsourcing labor and manufacturing
    • Reducing environmental protections

    This is just a small sample off the top of my head. There's so, so many more issues that just keep getting dismissed or shut down with reasons that basically boil down to 'well we've done it before so we'll do it again.'

    We don't need food stamps, medicare, housing vouchers, social security, and whole other hosts of programs. We need to evaluate the underlying reasons we feel these programs are necessary, and remove the root cause.

    So far most policies have been about addressing symptoms, not the causes of those symptoms.

    6 votes