NaraVara's recent activity
-
Comment on Famous hippo Fiona passes away in ~news
-
Comment on Famous hippo Fiona passes away in ~news
NaraVara Link ParentThe kid apparently had his hat thrown up in the air where it was hit by a ceiling fan that flung it through a 1 ft hole for air circulation in Fiona’s enclosure. Genuine freak accident.The kid apparently had his hat thrown up in the air where it was hit by a ceiling fan that flung it through a 1 ft hole for air circulation in Fiona’s enclosure.
Genuine freak accident.
-
Comment on Big balk: On Big Walk, Independent Games Festival, and the present unpleasantness in ~games
NaraVara Link ParentYeah I’m speaking purely from a standpoint of finding it tacky and aesthetically unpleasant. Thoughtless LLM outputs are also that, but at least I assume no effort was put into it.Yeah I’m speaking purely from a standpoint of finding it tacky and aesthetically unpleasant.
Thoughtless LLM outputs are also that, but at least I assume no effort was put into it.
-
Comment on Big balk: On Big Walk, Independent Games Festival, and the present unpleasantness in ~games
NaraVara Link ParentThat’s just not an accurate description of how LLMs are used to develop code. This guy has cut himself off understanding how these tools and harnesses have developed over the past few years. The...That’s just not an accurate description of how LLMs are used to develop code. This guy has cut himself off understanding how these tools and harnesses have developed over the past few years.
The training data was mostly “taken” from the commons. It’s a non-rival good. You can’t “take” it, it’s just used. I’m old enough to remember when the leftish position was that intellectual property is fake.
-
Comment on Big balk: On Big Walk, Independent Games Festival, and the present unpleasantness in ~games
NaraVara Link ParentIs using a canned game engine like Unreal better because you could theoretically count the number of developers generating most of the code for you? How about generating your game off the backs of...you're generating a game off the backs of uncountable developers whose work has been used to train the models that are generating the code for you.
Is using a canned game engine like Unreal better because you could theoretically count the number of developers generating most of the code for you?
How about generating your game off the backs of the developers who did the GPU drivers, DirectX/OpenGL/Vulkan, or other hooks into the OS? Or the ones who created various open-source packages to use?
-
Comment on Big balk: On Big Walk, Independent Games Festival, and the present unpleasantness in ~games
NaraVara Link ParentHmmmm. . . it's a trolley problem, but instead of people on tracks it's VRAM utilization.Hmmmm. . . it's a trolley problem, but instead of people on tracks it's VRAM utilization.
-
Comment on Big balk: On Big Walk, Independent Games Festival, and the present unpleasantness in ~games
NaraVara (edited )Link ParentThe entire discipline of software development exists to make things faster and cheaper by doing with computers what used to be done by hand or human effort. That’s literally why it came into...The entire discipline of software development exists to make things faster and cheaper by doing with computers what used to be done by hand or human effort.
That’s literally why it came into being. That is its purpose. Software developers have been annihilating entire industries and career paths for going on 3 decades now without a second thought, but when the bell tolls for them suddenly it’s a four-alarm ethical fire?
There’s certainly ethical implications with its use, the IP standards around it, the degradation in quality and lack of consideration in its outputs, the hardening of biases embedded in training data in opaque ways that can’t be audited or interrogated.
But none of those considerations are served by treating LLM use like it’s analogous to using conflict minerals or something. That’s just the sort of change aversion grasping at shadows of ethical concerns to justify sticking our heads in the sand and hoping it goes away.
-
Comment on Big balk: On Big Walk, Independent Games Festival, and the present unpleasantness in ~games
NaraVara Link ParentFascists have produced quite a bit of media with powerful cultural impacts. We’ve got Wagner, Leni Riefenstahl, Birth of a Nation, Heidegger, 300. Compelling aesthetic products are some of the...More to the point though, I can't say that the products in question merit discussion because, like all products made by fascists, they exist in a space of hate and violence, which means that they will not be very good.
Fascists have produced quite a bit of media with powerful cultural impacts. We’ve got Wagner, Leni Riefenstahl, Birth of a Nation, Heidegger, 300. Compelling aesthetic products are some of the only things they CAN do right.
It’s just the modern iterations of them are especially clownish because they’re a weird atavism of theater kids LARPing as fascists who were themselves LARPing as Teutonic warrior knights. It’s a copy of a copy so of course everything is garish and exaggerated.
-
Comment on Big balk: On Big Walk, Independent Games Festival, and the present unpleasantness in ~games
NaraVara Link ParentTo be honest all else being equal I’d rather install an application made with assistance from an LLM than have one be made in Electron. Now THAT disgusts me.To be honest all else being equal I’d rather install an application made with assistance from an LLM than have one be made in Electron. Now THAT disgusts me.
-
Comment on Big balk: On Big Walk, Independent Games Festival, and the present unpleasantness in ~games
NaraVara Link ParentI picked a quote that made it clear Unkz had an accurate read on the tone. The two extracts you have here don’t really change that. We can reproduce extracts until we’ve got the entire article in...I picked a quote that made it clear Unkz had an accurate read on the tone. The two extracts you have here don’t really change that. We can reproduce extracts until we’ve got the entire article in these comments but ultimately it is a very one-sided screed with a very puritanical argument about LLM use, as was said.
-
Comment on Big balk: On Big Walk, Independent Games Festival, and the present unpleasantness in ~games
NaraVara Link ParentI dunno. Seems to me like @unkz hit the nail on the head. I wish the comment thread disputing their interpretation didn’t lead me to read it just to confirm.Everything I know tells me that this wasn't the case, and using an LLM was an expedient, not a necessity. Unity being buggy and underdocumented is nothing new. House House could have worked around the issue (note that the worst case with the given issue was that the game was a bit frame-y for 20 seconds occasionally during play) or engaged the help of an actual human expert, many of whom they would have had access to just in their local scene around Melbourne. Many of these people are out of work right now.
House House, an already very successful studio with not insignificant resources, made a real choice to rely on a morally abhorrent software system rather than engage the help of real people—whether in the form of paid contracting or just friendly help. I want to say this not to try to exaggerate the scope of what they did but to make it absolutely clear that there is a real, material dimension to this, even if some want to characterize this issue as a purely abstract test of ritual purity.
I dunno. Seems to me like @unkz hit the nail on the head. I wish the comment thread disputing their interpretation didn’t lead me to read it just to confirm.
-
Comment on This battery-less piezoelectric toothbrush generates electricity every time you brush your teeth and removes more than 99% of plaque in lab tests in ~science
NaraVara Link ParentI feel like if it doesn’t involve paste and rinsing you can probably have a different type of device entirely. So even if it’s less effective per brush session, if you carry around a mouth guard...I feel like if it doesn’t involve paste and rinsing you can probably have a different type of device entirely. So even if it’s less effective per brush session, if you carry around a mouth guard type thing with you and use it after each meal your teeth will end up being great.
-
Comment on US Democrats win enough seats nationwide to (potentially) end Electoral College via the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact in ~society
NaraVara Link ParentThe thing is the truth value of the claim is irrelevant to whether they buy it or not. So it doesn’t matter, they’ll say it no matter what you do.The thing is the truth value of the claim is irrelevant to whether they buy it or not. So it doesn’t matter, they’ll say it no matter what you do.
-
Comment on US Democrats win enough seats nationwide to (potentially) end Electoral College via the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact in ~society
NaraVara Link ParentThat argument mostly stopped making sense once we all had TVs. Back when retail campaigning meant only rallies yeah, you can only go to a couple of big cities and be good. With TV ad buys it's...Good point, but I'm not really sure it's an avoidable conversation, since the argument that that just means NY/CA/cities/etc. decide the election has been made for decades?
That argument mostly stopped making sense once we all had TVs. Back when retail campaigning meant only rallies yeah, you can only go to a couple of big cities and be good. With TV ad buys it's more about "media markets," which will encompass rural areas around urban cores as well. So all it changes is encourages people to spread their ad spending around to more TV and radio stations.
With online advertising the relationship is even more attenuated. Geography barely matters at all and they target advertising based on demographics and affinity groups. Attending a rally is not the primary way people meet candidates, and at the Presidential level basically nobody is coming face to face with the candidate unless they're spending $1k+ a plate at a fundraising dinner.
-
Comment on US Democrats win enough seats nationwide to (potentially) end Electoral College via the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact in ~society
NaraVara Link ParentDepending on who you talk to the "modern political era" is either post-civil rights/Watergate or post-New Deal. By either definition Rutherford B. Hayes is only relevant as an answer in a bar...The first time a president won on the electoral college while losing the popular vote was Rutherford B. Hayes in 1876.
Depending on who you talk to the "modern political era" is either post-civil rights/Watergate or post-New Deal. By either definition Rutherford B. Hayes is only relevant as an answer in a bar trivia question for NERDS.
-
Comment on US Democrats win enough seats nationwide to (potentially) end Electoral College via the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact in ~society
NaraVara Link ParentNo they wouldn't. Nobody cares. A few hyper-plugged-in news junkies would bloviate about it for a month and then move on to the next ragebait. Come election-time it will be 5 minutes of Steve...Ultimately I think Democrats would have to be very clever to spin the optics in a way that doesn't look like they're just trying to grab power.
No they wouldn't. Nobody cares. A few hyper-plugged-in news junkies would bloviate about it for a month and then move on to the next ragebait. Come election-time it will be 5 minutes of Steve Kornacki explaining it counts differently this year and the median voter still will not give a shit.
-
Comment on US Democrats win enough seats nationwide to (potentially) end Electoral College via the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact in ~society
NaraVara Link ParentA different system would have had the Harris campaign focus on doing national ad-buys instead of hyper-focusing on building up a campaign infrastructure in the 5 swing states since she only had 3...though I’d note that Trump won the popular vote in 2024, so a different system would not have prevented his presidency
A different system would have had the Harris campaign focus on doing national ad-buys instead of hyper-focusing on building up a campaign infrastructure in the 5 swing states since she only had 3 months to get a campaign off the ground.
Look at the 2020 vs. 2024 swing in the electorate. You notice how the arrows in PA, GA, NC, WI, and MI seem shorter and even have some blue swinging counties in them? Those are the places where they poured all their ad spending!
If they had to run a national campaign instead, they'd have spread the spending around the country and reduced the vote margin there too, which would have resulted in either a win or a different percentage of the popular vote.
The structural incentives of the system matter beyond just how the votes get counted. It determines what platforms the parties pick, how they build their organizing machines, how they fundraise, how they spend their money, and which candidates get selected to run. You can't just assume that things will go the way they do now if the system is different.
-
Comment on US Democrats win enough seats nationwide to (potentially) end Electoral College via the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact in ~society
NaraVara Link ParentSo you can only reform broken aspects of the political system if the people who benefit from it being broken go along with it? You must understand how silly this sounds. It's not "technically...If the republicans and democrats jointly agreed to get rid of the EC, that would be great. I’m opposing getting rid of it now, in this way, because to push for it would be a terrible idea politically.
So you can only reform broken aspects of the political system if the people who benefit from it being broken go along with it? You must understand how silly this sounds.
I suppose that’s technically true, but article II refers to “electors” and per the US federal archives, the EC was established by the constitution. I will concede that the specific mechanisms are not described in the constitution.
It's not "technically true" it is simply true. All the Constitution says is that electors choose the President. That those electors' choices are locked into whoever got the majority of the aggregated vote of their state is made-up bullshit. Having those same electors allocate their votes to the winner of the national popular vote instead of the state one is the exact same kind of made-up bullshit. It just happens to make more sense as far as made-up bullshit goes.
Come on. The EC is massively important every election, especially when republicans win via the college despite losing the popular vote. Most people don’t think the president is elected by a popular vote. That really doesn’t matter for your point at all, so, you know, whatever, but this is a bit of a reach.
They do. Most people would fail a social studies test going over how the government works. They vote for the President, they expect whoever gets the most votes to be the President. Every election Republicans share the stupid map showing how much of the country is colored red because a substantial number of people think the land mass correlates to people.
The idea of the EC deviating from the popular vote was regarded as a potentially weird thing that could theoretically happen for most of the modern era, and the assumption was that it would cause a full blown Constitutional crisis if it did. The only reason it didn't in 2000 was because we happen to be ruled by a class of procedurally-fixated status quo fetishists who are terrified of ever hashing out systemic problems. And once we broke the seal on it then it was more acceptable to do it again with Trump.
It wasn't even a for-sure Republican advantaging thing until the the political parties divided starkly on urban-rural lines, and part of the reason the country is so divided is BECAUSE the EC skews the game theory of running national campaigns towards focusing on turning out your base in purple states instead of getting the 20% minority party vote in a state to 23%. What makes the Republican and Democratic parties the way they are is based on how the political system ends up allocating constituencies across parties. If you change the system the parties change too.
-
Comment on US Democrats win enough seats nationwide to (potentially) end Electoral College via the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact in ~society
NaraVara Link ParentYou're talking around whatever point you're trying to make and I suspect it's because you know it's a flimsy one. You aren't "necessarily opposed" to getting rid of the EC even though you're here...You're talking around whatever point you're trying to make and I suspect it's because you know it's a flimsy one. You aren't "necessarily opposed" to getting rid of the EC even though you're here opposing it while not giving much of a reason as to why besides some circuitous reasoning about how making things fair and equal is actually unfair.
Also the way the EC works isn't in the Constitution. The current system is itself a quasi-legal process hack that most people don't understand. In fact, most people actually think the President is elected by a popular vote and the fact that it's technically an EC vote is a bit of nonsense trivia that everyone who isn't a dyed in the wool Republican thinks is absurd.
-
Comment on I bought the $100,000 Amazon Rivian van you’re not supposed to own in ~engineering
NaraVara Link ParentAs with all roller coasters, it ends where it began.As with all roller coasters, it ends where it began.
There is no level of attentiveness in parenting that can keep an excited child from throwing something up in the air.
People have really unrealistic expectations for how contained kids can be. Kids are still people with their own opinions and desires and a level of cognitive development that doesn’t permit full impulse control. It’s actually unhealthy for their emotional development if parents are supervising them so heavily that they are always effectively being straightjacketed out of misbehaving. (To say nothing of the toll that sort of hypervigilance would take on the caregivers.)