12 votes

In northern Ontario, a dozen First Nations have been left struggling. A court’s attempt to enforce treaty promises could see them getting up to C$126bn

1 comment

  1. cfabbro
    (edited )
    Link
    This article does a good job of covering the history, the involved indigenous communities' struggles, and the 2018 Superior Court ruling, but it kinda glosses over the settlement deal itself. And...

    This article does a good job of covering the history, the involved indigenous communities' struggles, and the 2018 Superior Court ruling, but it kinda glosses over the settlement deal itself. And I feel like it's also missing some pretty important information about the still ongoing Robinson Huron treaty annuities case, which has potentially far-reaching financial implications regarding other violated treaties throughout Canada. Which is why, despite agreeing to the $10bn settlement, the Ontario government is actually still appealed that Superior Court ruling discussed in this article (which was later upheld by our Court of Appeal in 2021) to the Supreme Court of Canada.

    CBC article from last month:
    Supreme Court of Canada hears Ontario's appeal of landmark Robinson Huron treaty annuities case

    And here's the SCC case docket (if anyone wants to follow the proceedings):
    https://www.scc-csc.ca/case-dossier/info/dock-regi-eng.aspx?cas=40024

    p.s. The requested "media lock-up" is not quite as harsh as it sounds:
    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Media_lock-up#Use

    The Supreme Court of Canada has stated that it uses media lock-ups "to improve the accuracy of media reporting of Supreme Court of Canada decisions and to assist members of the media in reporting on cases that have attracted a high level of public interest."

    3 votes