-
9 votes
-
“Overstressed” NASA Mars exploration budget threatens missions
5 votes -
Planetary science decadal survey to include astrobiology and planetary defense
3 votes -
Satellite operators hint at fear of SpaceX, Blue Origin becoming competitors
4 votes -
NASA wants the public to help track light pollution from VLEO satellites
7 votes -
Momentus to offer last-miles service from SpaceX rideshare flights
3 votes -
SpaceX launches final Dragon 1 mission to the ISS
12 votes -
NASA still doesn’t know if it wants Boeing to perform another test flight of its passenger spacecraft
7 votes -
Inside Elon Musk’s plan to build one Starship a week—and settle Mars
10 votes -
NASA won't be able to send commands to Voyager 2 for the next eleven months, while upgrades are made to the Deep Space Network
8 votes -
ExoMars parachute tests delayed, mission faces review
4 votes -
WFIRST, proposed for cancellation, is approved for development
3 votes -
Falcon Heavy to launch NASA Psyche asteroid mission
6 votes -
How rockets are made (Rocket factory tour - United Launch Alliance)
6 votes -
The Pope's Astronomer, Telescopes, & Space Rocks
Three related videos of Brady Haran in Italy interviewing Brother Guy Consolmagno, director of The Vatican Observatory, were released today on his various channels... and rather than submit them...
Three related videos of Brady Haran in Italy interviewing Brother Guy Consolmagno, director of The Vatican Observatory, were released today on his various channels... and rather than submit them individually:
The Pope's Astronomer - Sixty Symbols
The Pope's Telescopes - Deep Sky Videos
The Pope's Space Rocks - Objectivity #2216 votes -
A new understanding of Mars is beginning to emerge, thanks to data from the first year of NASA's InSight lander mission
9 votes -
What is space? It’s not what you think.
7 votes -
MIT engineers devise the best way to deflect an incoming potentially hazardous near-Earth asteroid
7 votes -
Inside the Pentagon's secret UFO program
5 votes -
New exoplanet search strategy claims first discovery
6 votes -
NASA selects four finalists for next Discovery mission
8 votes -
How to optimise your headspace on a mission to Mars
6 votes -
Details pour in from New Horizons’ visit to Arrokoth, an object in the Kuiper Belt
7 votes -
A two-year investigation of the ties between a network of deceptive dating sites and Firefly Aerospace, a company selected by NASA for bidding on lunar payloads
9 votes -
SpaceX is taking over the tiny village of Boca Chica
7 votes -
What we know about dark matter
3 votes -
Highlights from ten years of observations of the Sun by NASA's Solar Dynamics Observatory
9 votes -
Iranian rocket fails to reach necessary speed for putting Zafar 1 communications satellite into orbit
6 votes -
There are no known commodity resources in space that could be sold on Earth
13 votes -
NASA brings Voyager 2 fully back online, 11.5 billion miles from Earth
21 votes -
Boeing's Starliner could have failed catastrophically during a December mission if a software error hadn't been found and fixed while the vehicle was in orbit
10 votes -
SpaceX will now let you book a rocket launch online starting at $1 million
9 votes -
Voyager 2 engineers working to restore normal operations
10 votes -
A small rocket maker is running a different kind of space race
6 votes -
Inside SpinLaunch, the space industry’s best kept secret
13 votes -
First images from the National Science Foundation's Inouye Solar Telescope show the surface of the sun at the highest resolution ever
8 votes -
NASA selects Axiom Space to build commercial space station module
5 votes -
James Webb Space Telescope: Technical challenges have caused schedule strain and may increase costs
7 votes -
Dark Energy may be an illusion: Gravitons themselves may have mass
20 votes -
NASA prepares to shut down Spitzer Space Telescope
6 votes -
NASA administrator Jim Bridenstine on the year ahead: ‘A lot of things have to go right’
10 votes -
DirecTV fears explosion risk from satellite with damaged battery
7 votes -
SpaceX conducts successful Crew Dragon In-Flight Abort Test
16 votes -
Power loss halves GEO satellite Eutelsat 5 West B capacity, while ESO hosted payload spared
4 votes -
Sierra Nevada explores other uses of Dream Chaser
4 votes -
NASA wants to grow a Moon base out of mushrooms
13 votes -
SpaceX tests black satellite to reduce ‘megaconstellation’ threat to astronomy
15 votes -
Ask Tildes: Design a spacecraft! You've been offered to submit a space exploration misson, with a cost cap of $1 billion. What is your proposal?
You've been asked to submit a proposal for a space exploration mission of your own desire, to the New Frontiers spaceflight program. These missions have a cost cap of approximately $700 million to...
You've been asked to submit a proposal for a space exploration mission of your own desire, to the New Frontiers spaceflight program. These missions have a cost cap of approximately $700 million to $1 billion, and have famously produced the following spacecraft:
- New Horizons, a flyby probe to Pluto.
- Juno, a polar orbiter of Jupiter.
- OSIRIS-REx, a sample return mission to a rocky asteroid.
- Dragonfly, a drone lander to Saturn's moon Titan.
These are medium-sized missions in both scope, and cost. You can't build the Mars 2020 Rover, or the James Webb Space Telescope. What do you send, and where? Things to consider:
Technology Readiness Level
Administrators are less likely to choose your mission if you choose to integrate risky or untested flight hardware, or novel concepts into the mission design. You're more likely to get selected with more conventional hardware.
Power Source
Your best bet is probably solar panels, maybe something commercial off the shelf like NG's Ultraflex panels? The downside is that these are only effective up to about Jupiter's orbit, and generate power according to the inverse square law. How much do these cost and weigh? How much energy do you generate?
If you go further out into the solar system than that, you'll need a Radioisotope Thermoelectric Generator (RTG). There aren't many of those around, in fact, after Mars 2020 has taken its RTG, there's two left. What makes your mission deserving of an RTG? Is there enough power in the MMRTG to power your mission?
Propulsion
Does your mission need in-flight propulsion? Either for orbit insertion, landing, or maybe a long coast with Ion thrusters like Dawn? If the latter, you can get some pretty good Xenon-powered thrusters, like NEXT, which gives you 236mN of force from 7kW of input power (this rules out an RTG as your power source).
Don't need long-term burn capability? Maybe a COTS bipropellant engine like LEROS is your thing. Watch your weight though, bipropellants aren't efficient! Often more than half the mass of large spacecraft can be dedicated to just propulsion alone.
Instruments
Go crazy. What are you looking to research? Do you need a long range camera, a wide angle camera, something outside of the visible spectrum, a spectrometer, ground-penetrating radar? Do you have a mass-budget in mind?
Launch Vehicle
Every dollar you save on your launch vehicle, you get to add to your mission profile. Your best bet in terms of performance and cost is probably Falcon 9, which retails for $62-90 million, depending on the amount of assurance for success you need. Of course, if you can find a cheaper launch vehicle, feel free to pick it if it fits into your mission weight.
Objectives
What scientific questions do you want to answer? What are you interested in exploring the most?
13 votes -
SpaceX Falcon 9 rocket to be "destroyed in Dragon fire" as part of upcoming Inflight Abort Test, scheduled for January 18
8 votes -
NASA's exoplanet-seeking satellite TESS has discovered its first Earth-size planet in its star’s habitable zone
7 votes