19 votes

Chinese whispers in Dhaka: 1000s of vloggers film suburb, claim they’re in ‘dirty’ India. No one knows why.

7 comments

  1. [3]
    unkz
    Link
    Found this other source which may actually be the only source https://en.prothomalo.com/bangladesh/ietymx1n03 Very weird. I could understand one or two vloggers out there farming engagement but...

    Found this other source which may actually be the only source

    https://en.prothomalo.com/bangladesh/ietymx1n03

    Very weird. I could understand one or two vloggers out there farming engagement but this seems vastly too large in scale. Who could be directing this and to what end?

    14 votes
    1. xk3
      Link Parent
      I get similar vibes as articles like this: https://blockclubchicago.org/2026/10/13/a-billionaires-squirrel-feeding-operation-is-driving-lincoln-park-neighbors-nuts/ It definitely feels to...

      I get similar vibes as articles like this:

      https://blockclubchicago.org/2026/10/13/a-billionaires-squirrel-feeding-operation-is-driving-lincoln-park-neighbors-nuts/

      It definitely feels to coordinated to be self organized.

      If you search "Tekpara in Dhaka" you'll see that more news stations are picking it up just with a more realistic 150+ number instead of 5000. Perhaps the real number is 15.

      12 votes
    2. bkimmel
      Link Parent
      Yeah very strange. I feel like one of two things must be true; Someone benefits from creating/reinforcing the perception in China that India is unhygienic/dirty It's cover for some other kind of...

      Yeah very strange. I feel like one of two things must be true;

      1. Someone benefits from creating/reinforcing the perception in China that India is unhygienic/dirty
      2. It's cover for some other kind of surveillance China is doing in Bangladesh
      6 votes
  2. [2]
    gary
    Link
    Hard to tell if this is still happening or it's being re-reported. I see mention of this phenomenon on reddit from almost 2 years ago and it contains a link to a YouTube short as an example. I...

    Hard to tell if this is still happening or it's being re-reported. I see mention of this phenomenon on reddit from almost 2 years ago and it contains a link to a YouTube short as an example. I downloaded the video and had Claude translate it as I can only understand a small subset of what he's saying:

    但是呢,我受不了这边三嫂的身上的这种味道。三嫂身上有一股味道的,你知道吧?嗨,朋友们,嗨,朋友们。这些女孩子是长得比较漂亮,她看我的眼神都有点拉丝了。但是呢,我不敢去消费,我怕我老婆在直播间里面看着我。我也不敢问她多少钱。

    你看这些男的呢,就是在这里排队。这些男的在这边玩手机在排队,看到没有?因为他没有地方,这里一个是排队的地方,还有一个是……嗨。No thank you. No no no no, thank you. 那边有一个男人排队的地方是什么?就是他们用来一个凉亭,一个凉亭是男人……

    Where are you from? Sorry, I [don't] know English. Where are you from? I am Chinese. Chinese. Yeah. Thank you. OK, thank you.

    他们问我是不是过来这边消费的,我说我真的不是过来消费。你看这些男人穿着裙子,就是过来消费的。而且他们消费之前也不洗澡,消费之前都不洗澡的。你说我怎么敢去找那个三嫂?那个三嫂的那个味道啊,真的是……而且他们扫地的垃圾直接从这里倒出来,看到没有?Hello. 你看这扫地这个垃圾直接就倒出窗口这边,[听不清]又特别大。那男人经常去,他肯定消费。哎呀,反正就是脏不垃圾的。

    朋友,你们知道印度最出名的河是哪条河吗?知道的打在公屏上。印度最出名的河是哪条河?我给你们看一下。这条是印度恒河的一个支流,朋友。那我给你们说,前面那里呢,就是印度男人在排队的一个凉亭,那春花呢就是在这边。我等一下带你去春花家,我先带你到那个男人排队的凉亭那里去啊。这个是印度河流,恒河的一个……

    English:

    But I can't stand the smell on the Indian women here. They have a certain smell, you know? Hi, friends. Hi, friends. These girls are fairly pretty, and the way she's looking at me is getting a little flirty. But I don't dare to pay for anything. I'm afraid my wife is watching me on the livestream. I don't even dare ask her how much.

    Look, these men are lining up here. They're on their phones while they wait in line, see? Since there's nowhere else, this is one place to wait, and the other one is… hey. No thank you. No no no no, thank you. Over there is another place where men wait. It's a pavilion they use, a pavilion for the men…

    "Where are you from?" "Sorry, I [don't] know English." "Where are you from?" "I am Chinese." "Chinese." "Yeah." "Thank you." "OK, thank you."

    They asked if I came here to pay for services. I told them I really didn't. See these men in sarongs? They're here as customers. And they don't even shower beforehand. They never shower first. So how could I dare go with one of those women? That smell, it's really… And they dump the swept-up trash straight out here, see? Hello. Look, the trash gets dumped right out the window, and [unclear] is really big. The men who come here a lot are definitely customers. Ugh, anyway, it's all filthy.

    Friends, do you know India's most famous river? Type it in the chat if you do. What's India's most famous river? Let me show you. This is a tributary of the Ganges, friends. Up ahead is the pavilion where Indian men line up, and "Chunhua" is over here. I'll take you to Chunhua's place in a bit, but first I'll take you to the men's pavilion. This is an Indian river, part of the Ganges…

    My guess is that it's just exploitation of racist views for money. I don't think this is a government-crafted scheme to make India look bad. I think this caters to Chinese people where there is rampant racism against Indians; Chinese people look down on Indians as inferior and dirty. They do this in Bangladesh and fake that it's in India because they'd get their shit kicked in if they get caught in India, but less likely so in Bangladesh since it's not outright shit-talking them.

    13 votes
    1. WhistlePig
      Link Parent
      I think this is right. There's a knee-jerk reaction to things like this in the west where we start with the assumption that the Chinese government is an all-controlling hydra, always meddling and...

      I think this is right. There's a knee-jerk reaction to things like this in the west where we start with the assumption that the Chinese government is an all-controlling hydra, always meddling and manipulating to nefarious ends, when there's usually a simpler explanation.

      Look at the garbage on Youtube for example; there's plenty of content exploiting homeless people for content. Is the US government engaged in a psyop to do something shady? Or is it just the case that content creators have found a type of provocative video that drives views and are willing to be amoral to get those views? Then consider how many more similar people there are in China, and I think we have a reasonable explanation.

      10 votes
  3. [2]
    Bullmaestro
    Link
    I thought Douyin was meant to be the more tightly controlled and moderated sister of TikTok. Kinda shocks me that the CCP would let their people openly mock South Asians online.

    I thought Douyin was meant to be the more tightly controlled and moderated sister of TikTok. Kinda shocks me that the CCP would let their people openly mock South Asians online.

    1. Hollow
      Link Parent
      My dude China and India are still in conflict over their borders, keeping up the grassroots propaganda would just be part of rahrah sabre rattling.

      My dude China and India are still in conflict over their borders, keeping up the grassroots propaganda would just be part of rahrah sabre rattling.

      4 votes