3 votes

Topic deleted by author

5 comments

  1. [4]
    Comment deleted by author
    Link
    1. [2]
      Jedi
      Link Parent
      What if bots could only see comments they're mentioned in? That way @RemindMeBot could be pinged to make a request but CommonMisspellingsBot couldn't butt in with an unsolicited comment.

      What if bots could only see comments they're mentioned in? That way @RemindMeBot could be pinged to make a request but CommonMisspellingsBot couldn't butt in with an unsolicited comment.

      1 vote
      1. [2]
        Comment deleted by author
        Link Parent
        1. Jedi
          Link Parent
          Okay, how about the parent comment/post has to approve the response? This should prevent dumb/useless bots from even being created as they'll likely not even get their comments approved.

          Okay, how about the parent comment/post has to approve the response?

          This should prevent dumb/useless bots from even being created as they'll likely not even get their comments approved.

    2. Inothernews1
      Link Parent
      Yeah, I agree 100%. Another point to consider: I remember very specifically on one thread where three automated bots responded to a guys post with the same information. Each of the bots on their...

      Yeah, I agree 100%. Another point to consider: I remember very specifically on one thread where three automated bots responded to a guys post with the same information. Each of the bots on their own were posting something helpful, and when the coder was designing it was probably thinking along the lines of helping the community, however it just created unnecessary spam.

      However I don't think we should discount the idea of some humorous bots too. In the right context, bots like HaikuBot and the like can be quite funny. But then we get into the muddy waters of how to regulate it and the like... Maybe restricting bots to certain ~'s? Funny ones for the funny ~'s, and serious ones for the serious ~'s? Slippery slop indeed...

      This is a very good question, hopefully someone much smarter than I will propose a solution :)

  2. elf
    Link
    I do tend to like bots, but groups should have to manually approve them they should only respond when invoked

    I do tend to like bots, but

    1. groups should have to manually approve them
    2. they should only respond when invoked
    1 vote