13 votes

What is the One Piece? Eiichiro Oda has put an answer to paper and hidden it 651m under the ocean.

7 comments

  1. [6]
    Well_known_bear
    Link
    My gut reaction is that this feels like a bit of an unnecessary stunt. Oda has long maintained that he had a concrete idea of what the One Piece was from the outset, going as far as to confirm it...

    My gut reaction is that this feels like a bit of an unnecessary stunt.

    Oda has long maintained that he had a concrete idea of what the One Piece was from the outset, going as far as to confirm it was an actual object and not just 'the friends we made along the way'. Where's the need for this kind of stage magician showmanship when it's about to be revealed in the manga anyway?

    6 votes
    1. [5]
      stu2b50
      Link Parent
      It's fun thing to do? Does it need more of a reason?

      It's fun thing to do? Does it need more of a reason?

      9 votes
      1. [4]
        Well_known_bear
        Link Parent
        Sure. My thinking was more that it feels odd to play up the 'we have the answers planned out in advance!' angle. I mean, that's what the readers have assumed all along (based on the author's own...

        Sure. My thinking was more that it feels odd to play up the 'we have the answers planned out in advance!' angle. I mean, that's what the readers have assumed all along (based on the author's own earlier comments), right?

        I guess someone could dive down there and find out early...

        2 votes
        1. [3]
          stu2b50
          Link Parent
          I feel like that’s overthinking it. One piece is a series about pirates trying to find treasure. For one piece fans, nothing could be as important as to how the series presumably ends, or at least...

          I feel like that’s overthinking it. One piece is a series about pirates trying to find treasure. For one piece fans, nothing could be as important as to how the series presumably ends, or at least what the central mystery of the one piece resolves to.

          It’s a cute stunt to put that in a chest literally on the sea floor. A fan will watch the video and go “how neat”. And that’s about it.

          11 votes
          1. [2]
            Well_known_bear
            Link Parent
            That's fair. I feel like the long serialisation and all the elaborate backstories and theories really have me overthinking everything about this series!

            That's fair. I feel like the long serialisation and all the elaborate backstories and theories really have me overthinking everything about this series!

            1 vote
            1. thereticent
              (edited )
              Link Parent
              Haha, it makes sense. I've watched quite a bit of this insanely long series, and it never occurred to me to check out a fan community or question whether the One Piece is predetermined. So for me,...

              Haha, it makes sense. I've watched quite a bit of this insanely long series, and it never occurred to me to check out a fan community or question whether the One Piece is predetermined. So for me, this teaser is the first time hearing that!

              2 votes
  2. Protected
    Link
    I haven't paid any attention to One Piece in many years, but is this going to be like Harry Potter, where "the last chapter has been written since the beginning" and it ended up feeling crappy and...

    I haven't paid any attention to One Piece in many years, but is this going to be like Harry Potter, where "the last chapter has been written since the beginning" and it ended up feeling crappy and dated?

    1 vote