4 votes

Decidedly Bad - War Of The Spark: The Forsaken - A Magic: The Gathering Novel by Greg Weisman

9 comments

  1. [9]
    Grzmot
    Link
    I completely missed the release of the sequel to War of the Spark. After a day of research, I conclude that they fucked everything up. If you like drama, we have queer characters becoming...

    I completely missed the release of the sequel to War of the Spark. After a day of research, I conclude that they fucked everything up. If you like drama, we have queer characters becoming straight, a romantic subplot uncereminously dragged behind the next dumpster and shanked, lorebreaking plot points and overall, terrible writing. Oh, also character motivations just don't matter anymore.

    Wizards of the Coast never seemed to have good quality control on their novels, but they seemed to be doing fairly great with their short stories with Zendikar, Kaladesh and my personal favourite, Ixalan, which actually finally gave some character development.

    This entire fiasco has lead to public apologies from WotC in particular due to the retconning of a bi characters sexuality to straight, cause that got the most people angry. It's in all honesty just the tip of the iceberg, and I would expect better from a company like WotC, especially since they seem to care enough to publish novels but not enough to make them good.

    3 votes
    1. [8]
      Death
      Link Parent
      How does one retcon a bisexual character back to being straight short of them just stating it outright? How did they bungle it that badly?

      How does one retcon a bisexual character back to being straight short of them just stating it outright? How did they bungle it that badly?

      1 vote
      1. [7]
        Grzmot
        (edited )
        Link Parent
        They stated it outright. Basically said all past feelings were platonic (literally the words platonic love were used) and how in the past she only was in the brawny dudes. EDIT: @Death here's the...

        They stated it outright. Basically said all past feelings were platonic (literally the words platonic love were used) and how in the past she only was in the brawny dudes.

        EDIT: @Death here's the section in question: https://twitter.com/CubeApril/status/1194305407164076033

        2 votes
        1. [6]
          Death
          Link Parent
          That's... really bad. Who signed off on that, why even do that unless the writer has specific hangups about a woman loving other women?

          That's... really bad. Who signed off on that, why even do that unless the writer has specific hangups about a woman loving other women?

          1 vote
          1. [5]
            Grzmot
            Link Parent
            The writer denied being responsible, and stated that WotC blocked him from getting them together.
            3 votes
            1. [4]
              Death
              Link Parent
              That's kind of messed up on WotC's part.

              That's kind of messed up on WotC's part.

              1 vote
              1. [3]
                zaarn
                Link Parent
                I suspect this is coming from higher up; Hasbro. Hasbro has prevented any sort of non-straight relationships in quite a few of their products, even having a studio retroactively edit out a VA from...

                I suspect this is coming from higher up; Hasbro. Hasbro has prevented any sort of non-straight relationships in quite a few of their products, even having a studio retroactively edit out a VA from an episode of a show because they received a few complaints.

                2 votes
                1. [2]
                  Grzmot
                  Link Parent
                  I just found out that WotC's apology and promise to do better was blocked internally from countries like Russia, China, Singapore and the Philippines. This was definitely a financial decision made...

                  I just found out that WotC's apology and promise to do better was blocked internally from countries like Russia, China, Singapore and the Philippines.

                  This was definitely a financial decision made by suits.

                  1. zaarn
                    Link Parent
                    Suits at Hasbro I bet.

                    Suits at Hasbro I bet.