8 votes

Ask Tildes: I'm looking for (FOSS? Self-hosted?) photo manager software

Specifically, I've got a big honkin' pile of photos stored on an online storage space, and I want some kind of software that lets me share links to a pic, or a group of pics, or a folder, etc ...

... and here's the crux ... without making extra copies of the pics ... just has renamed, custom-permissioned links to the original pic(s).

In database terms, I want something that gives me Views of my photo collection.

I run my own Nextcloud instance, which is close. It has very nice, very granular photo management and sharing capabilities ... but as far as I can tell, whenever I share a pic with someone, it actually makes another copy of it for the shared instance. If I share the photo 5 times w/5 different people/groups, then suddenly, I have 6 copies of the pic.

Any recommendations?

7 comments

  1. [3]
    nobody
    Link
    Have you looked into PhotoPrism? I am not sure how sharing works internally, but it seems to be a solid alternative.

    Have you looked into PhotoPrism? I am not sure how sharing works internally, but it seems to be a solid alternative.

    7 votes
    1. Eric_the_Cerise
      Link Parent
      First I've heard of it, just spent a half-hour browsing the documentation (and BTDub, Great documentation! This is usually the weakest part of FOSS apps, but this is beautifully documented) ... I...

      First I've heard of it, just spent a half-hour browsing the documentation (and BTDub, Great documentation! This is usually the weakest part of FOSS apps, but this is beautifully documented) ... I can't find explicitly whether or not it generates duplicates for shares, but the documentation does show a strong preference towards unnecessary dupes in general (such as when importing a new batch).

      Generally, very nice looking app, too. Very polished.

      Thanks for the tip.

      4 votes
    2. mxuribe
      Link Parent
      I wasn't really in the market for photo manager/gallery software, but never heard of PhotoPrism so was curious...All i can say is wow; looks quite impressive! Beyond being FLOSS - which nowadays...

      I wasn't really in the market for photo manager/gallery software, but never heard of PhotoPrism so was curious...All i can say is wow; looks quite impressive! Beyond being FLOSS - which nowadays for me is a strict requirement - i like that it uses tensorflow for auto tagging. Really neat; thanks for sharing!

      2 votes
  2. calm_bomb
    Link
    I looked for something like this for ages and never found anything good. All products I've found will make a copy of your existing photos, doubling the needed space.

    I looked for something like this for ages and never found anything good. All products I've found will make a copy of your existing photos, doubling the needed space.

    4 votes
  3. [2]
    viridian
    Link
    Hey for what it's worth, I think nextcloud may actually do what you want. For instance, my wife and I had a wedding planning document shared between us. The filesystem only shows one instance of...

    Hey for what it's worth, I think nextcloud may actually do what you want. For instance, my wife and I had a wedding planning document shared between us. The filesystem only shows one instance of that document in var/snap/nextcloud, in my permissioned folder, even though two people have access to it.

    I was actually just looking into this since I'm going to set up daily backups from nextcloud to s3 and I don't want duplicate data getting zipped and shipped.

    4 votes
    1. Eric_the_Cerise
      Link Parent
      I'm right now in the process of overhauling, upgrading, and moving my Nextcloud ... I will take the time to drill into this more, just in case it is already working as I'd prefer.

      I'm right now in the process of overhauling, upgrading, and moving my Nextcloud ... I will take the time to drill into this more, just in case it is already working as I'd prefer.

      3 votes
  4. helloworld
    Link
    Edit: After properly reading the post, I interpreted wrong. Feel free to ignore this comment. Original: I wholeheartedly recommend Digikam. I sync my photos using Syncthing, and then use Digikam...

    Edit: After properly reading the post, I interpreted wrong. Feel free to ignore this comment.

    Original:
    I wholeheartedly recommend Digikam. I sync my photos using Syncthing, and then use Digikam for deduplication, tagging, sorting and everything inbetween.

    They recently released a major update that uses local neural networks for face detection. 100% FLOSS and 200% awesome.

    1 vote