11 votes

Overpopulation, eugenics and capitalism

5 comments

  1. alopex
    Link
    This video is a kind of documentary about the history of the idea of overpopulation and how this idea is often closely tied to ideas about eugenics. I want to be clear that I'm not totally...

    This video is a kind of documentary about the history of the idea of overpopulation and how this idea is often closely tied to ideas about eugenics. I want to be clear that I'm not totally endorsing everything Peter Coffin says in this video and I definitely think there are discussions to be had on overpopulation and resource usage, but I just thought it would be an interesting perspective to share.

    5 votes
  2. [4]
    AFineAccount
    Link
    Honestly, I think there are things we shouldn't be discussing and eugenics is one of them. It's a cruel, insidious idea born out of absolute inhumanity. To say that killing people is a responsible...

    Honestly, I think there are things we shouldn't be discussing and eugenics is one of them. It's a cruel, insidious idea born out of absolute inhumanity. To say that killing people is a responsible thing to do to save the rest of the world only makes the world hell to live in; it makes the killed the lucky ones.

    There is no situation in which eugenics should be seen as a valid solution. In a functioning society, people act together to solve the problems everyone is faced with. It doesn't self-destruct in a paradoxical attempt to keep moving forward.

    5 votes
    1. [2]
      padraigd
      Link Parent
      While I agree eugenics is bad its not really about killing people, it can be about selective or restrictive breeding and stuff too. Still bad tho.

      While I agree eugenics is bad its not really about killing people, it can be about selective or restrictive breeding and stuff too. Still bad tho.

      2 votes
      1. eladnarra
        Link Parent
        Yeah, involuntary or coerced sterilization is eugenics, and while some might consider it ancient history, it's still being put into practice or debated today. (Tennessee Jails Are Offering Inmates...

        Yeah, involuntary or coerced sterilization is eugenics, and while some might consider it ancient history, it's still being put into practice or debated today. (Tennessee Jails Are Offering Inmates Shorter Sentences In Exchange For Sterilization and Washington State May Make It Easier to Sterilize People With Disabilities)

        3 votes
    2. alopex
      Link Parent
      Yeah - if I didn't make it clear enough I am in no way in favor of eugenics. It's horrible and often very racist. Overpopulation just happens to be something people on environmentally conscious...

      Yeah - if I didn't make it clear enough I am in no way in favor of eugenics. It's horrible and often very racist. Overpopulation just happens to be something people on environmentally conscious circles talk about frequently maybe without knowing it's more unsavory past, and that's why I wanted to share this video.

      1 vote