-
10 votes
-
What is truth? - Perspectives from Buddhism
6 votes -
Anyone interested in a philosophical logic study group?
Intermittently, for the past 15 years or so, logic has been an interest of mine. Back then I had trouble understanding exactly why certain things people said sounded so right/wrong, and how could...
Intermittently, for the past 15 years or so, logic has been an interest of mine. Back then I had trouble understanding exactly why certain things people said sounded so right/wrong, and how could I come up with proper responses.
Among others, in this time I've read one great book on informal logic (which I lost, unfortunately), quite a few articles, and studied the first chapters of the stupendous Gary Hardegree's symbolic logic.
Even though I love the subject, it is hard to sustain motivation alone. I wish to acquire a firmer grasp of logic and its applications to philosophy. Hence the suggestion of forming a study group.
It is my understanding that most Tilderinos are in STEM, especially areas surrounding computer science. So I anticipate that many users have an understanding of logic that greatly surpasses my own. Because of that, for some, a philosophical logic study group may seem too elementary to be of any value. Others may find it interesting to approach logic from a philosophical point of view.
In any case, the idea is to start from scratch. Besides the ability to read and write in the English language, no previous knowledge is required. No mathematics either.
I have two initial proposals.
1. An Illustrated Book of Bad Arguments
This one is ideal for a light, relaxed approach.
This awesome book describes 19 common logical fallacies using accessible language, with clear examples and suggestive illustrations. Not very technical, and a lot of it is well-known territory if you have an interest in logic. One chapter for each fallacy, each chapter is one page long. A great conversation starter.
2. Symbolic Logic: A First Course, by Gary Hardegree
I would choose this one myself. Hardegree is a wonderful teacher.
This book is one of the best teaching materials I have ever known, and surprisingly superior even to paid alternatives. A more proper introduction to logic. Hardegree is an excellent teacher, introducing concepts with precision in accessible language. The progression is smooth, you never feel that the exercises are either too easy or too hard. And there are plenty of exercises (with answers!) which are great for self-study.
We could start with either one of these books and follow from there. Just meeting once a week (or maybe biweekly) to discuss the chapter or chapter section we studied in that period.
I understand a lot of people like to do that kind of stuff on Discord, so that's a possibility.
5 votes -
If the age-old theory of soulmates is but a theory, why are so many inclined to believe in it?
5 votes -
The Emergence of the Global Heartland
4 votes -
The fact/opinion distinction
4 votes -
What is truth?
2 votes -
Cancel culture and critical race theory
8 votes -
Semantics and understanding
3 votes -
The end of analytic philosophy
4 votes -
The Argument Clinic and introduction to philosophy
3 votes -
The Machine - A webcomic about consciousness, identity and teleportation
14 votes -
A theory of creepiness
4 votes -
A century ago Ludwig Wittgenstein changed philosophy for ever
4 votes -
The death of the author
5 votes -
Battle of Drøbak Sound, 1940 - "Either I will be decorated or court martialed. Fire!"
6 votes -
Qualia
3 votes -
Ignorance and censorship
7 votes -
The abolition of work
13 votes -
For Leo Strauss, public life was muddied by opinion and persecution, so philosophers should shield their work from view
4 votes -
The filing cabinet was critical to the information infrastructure of the 20th-century. Like most infrastructure, it was usually overlooked.
10 votes -
Introducing the pervert’s dilemma: A contribution to the critique of deepfake pornography
13 votes -
The secret of how Roald Amundsen beat Captain Robert Falcon Scott in race to south pole? A diet of raw penguin
7 votes -
Why study philosophy?
2 votes -
What is existentialism? Three core principles of existentialist philosophy.
6 votes -
Creeps and creepiness
3 votes -
Graham Oppy & Luke Wybranczyk - Naturalism - Its virtues and vices
2 votes -
Why Confederate lies live on
6 votes -
Spirited Away meets Heidegger: We killed the gods with technology
4 votes -
Nothingness (Why is there something rather than nothing?)
7 votes -
Holes
3 votes -
The history of the worst SeaWorld ride, Submarine Quest
5 votes -
ValuJet Flight 592
6 votes -
Lincoln's great depression
6 votes -
Bertrand Russell’s ‘scientific’ philosophy was a bulwark against nationalism
5 votes -
Happiness
2 votes -
Megan Rohrer elected as first openly transgender bishop in US Lutheran church
11 votes -
The existence of God and the beginning of the universe
11 votes -
The legendary Commando raid at St. Nazaire | The greatest raid of all time
4 votes -
Impossible Worlds
3 votes -
Roads into Norway will get new signs with the country name also written in the indigenous Sámi language depending on the region
10 votes -
The Paradox of Fiction
3 votes -
Why did the Democratic and Republican parties switch platforms?
6 votes -
The Hume Paradox: How great philosophy leads to dismal politics
4 votes -
For the first time, researchers have identified the remains of a sailor from the doomed 1845 Franklin expedition of the fabled Northwest Passage
10 votes -
How to disagree
8 votes -
Thinking and Being
4 votes -
Which Scientific Disciplines Cite Philosophy of Science?
2 votes -
Political Epistemology
4 votes -
The plan to kill Osama bin Laden—from the spycraft to the assault to its bizarre political backdrop—as told by the people in the room
11 votes