63 votes

Two cisgender people were killed in separate attacks motivated by transphobia in the US

6 comments

  1. [2]
    AlienAliena
    Link
    This article raises a very important point, especially in regard to minority communities. A big TERF slogan is that "we can always tell," referencing how they can always tell when a trans person...
    • Exemplary

    This article raises a very important point, especially in regard to minority communities.

    It’s worth noting that cis Black women are often targeted by transphobia, especially as it intertwines with white supremacy. As Derrick Clifton wrote for Them in 2021, there’s a long history of Black women athletes’ bodies being policed in sports, with people “mak[ing] cruel remarks about their perceived femininity and creat[ing] racist depictions of their physicality.”

    A big TERF slogan is that "we can always tell," referencing how they can always tell when a trans person is using the bathroom that aligns with their gender identity. The thing is, they can't. They constantly get it wrong, time and time again, and end up just throwing harassment at random cis people.

    Of course they'll never admit they're wrong. There's people out there who still claim the Michelle Obama, of all people, is trans. They will make up conspiracy theories to support their claims, just fucking make up evidence.

    This is all in the greater goal of alienating people who look different from the majority, or in any way break societal norms. In the case of the article, the woman was black and that's all that the murderer needed. Calling her trans was just his way of finding a socially acceptable way to punish her for being a minority because the culture around hating trans people is more acceptable today than the culture around hating black people.

    It was the same thing with the one-drop rule of accusing people of secretly being bi-racial. It was the same thing with the red scare and accusing whoever you disagreed with of being a communist. It was the same thing in the Holocaust of being Jewish or associating with Jewish peoples.

    It's so laughable that people who participate in this fear mongering finger pointing even call themselves feminist when all they are doing is creating a narrower and narrower definition of womanhood until being a woman just means being conventionally attractive and nuclear-family feminine. They want the freedom of self-expression to be crushed for all but the few that fit inside their boxes just so they can be certain that no trans people are in the bathroom at the same time they are.

    This right here is why there must always be solidarity in the fight for the rights of minority peoples.

    53 votes
    1. JuDGe3690
      Link Parent
      Heath Fogg Davis mentions one such incident in his book Beyond Trans: Does Gender Matter? (New York University Press, 2017), where a cis black woman was forcibly kicked out of a New York City...

      It’s worth noting that cis Black women are often targeted by transphobia, especially as it intertwines with white supremacy.

      Heath Fogg Davis mentions one such incident in his book Beyond Trans: Does Gender Matter? (New York University Press, 2017), where a cis black woman was forcibly kicked out of a New York City bar's female restroom by the [male] bouncer (all because someone complained that they thought a "man" was in the ladies' room). Eventually a trans organization had to go to bat for her legally (even though she wasn't trans at all).

      16 votes
  2. [3]
    SnakeJess
    (edited )
    Link
    Trans rights are human rights , and I don't just mean it in the "everyone is equal" way. In the way that if people aren't allowed to be trans we are effectively legislating huge portions of...

    Trans rights are human rights , and I don't just mean it in the "everyone is equal" way. In the way that if people aren't allowed to be trans we are effectively legislating huge portions of everyone's lives. This kind of treatment and abuse will be lobbied at anyone who doesn't conform to an arbitrary standard set by the right. This is why we have to push back on this culture war. It hurts everyone.

    26 votes
    1. [2]
      JuDGe3690
      Link Parent
      I'm reminded of a quote from a book I read a few years ago: —Chris Hedges, American Fascists: The Christian Right and the War on America (2007)

      I'm reminded of a quote from a book I read a few years ago:

      The hypermasculinity of radical Christian conservatism, which crushes the independence and self-expression of women, is a way for men in the movement to compensate for the curtailing of their own independence, their abject obedience to church authorities and the calls for sexual constraint. It is also a way to cope with fear. Those who lead the churches fear, perhaps most deeply, their own internal contradictions. They make war on the internal contradictions in others. Those who are not subdued, who do not bow before the church authorities, are seen as contaminants. […]

      There runs through the fundamentalist belief system a deep dread of ambiguity, disorder and chaos. Accordingly, the cult of masculinity keeps all ambiguity, especially sexual ambiguity, in check. It fosters a world of binary opposites: God and man, saved and unsaved, the church and the world, Christianity and secular humanism, male and female.

      —Chris Hedges, American Fascists: The Christian Right and the War on America (2007)

      17 votes
      1. SnakeJess
        Link Parent
        I'm going to put this book on my reading list. Thank you.

        I'm going to put this book on my reading list. Thank you.

        2 votes
  3. spit-evil-olive-tips
    Link
    archive link

    archive link

    Trans people have long maintained that transphobia does not just affect us. That’s been proven true in the worst way, with reports of two cis people being murdered for allegedly misdirected anti-trans hostility.

    23 votes