24 votes

Israel election: Inconclusive?

10 comments

  1. [6]
    TheMediumJon
    Link
    Exit polls have started rolling out in Israel. Things look... interesting. The Arab-Israeli Parties seem to have made major gains, Netanyahu's coalition is facing major losses. And yet the...

    Exit polls have started rolling out in Israel.

    Things look... interesting.
    The Arab-Israeli Parties seem to have made major gains, Netanyahu's coalition is facing major losses.
    And yet the construction of a rival coalition is constrained by conflicting promises.

    It should be noted that the opposition mostly doesn't have very far differences regarding Gaza.

    17 votes
    1. [2]
      Interesting
      Link Parent
      It's worth noting that it's not been unusual in the last few years for it to take multiple elections before a majority coalition is formed. Israel's electoral system prioritizes protecting...

      It's worth noting that it's not been unusual in the last few years for it to take multiple elections before a majority coalition is formed. Israel's electoral system prioritizes protecting minority viewpoints (parties) and so there are many different points of contention. It takes just 3.25% of the national vote for a party to get a seat in the Knesset. No single party has ever formed a government by itself - it has always been coalitions.

      16 votes
      1. TheMediumJon
        Link Parent
        That is a good point to note, yes. But as the projections develop currently... There appears to be a shift back towards Netanyahu's Likud over his jewish opposition, with the arab Parties still...

        That is a good point to note, yes.

        But as the projections develop currently...

        There appears to be a shift back towards Netanyahu's Likud over his jewish opposition, with the arab Parties still strong.

        They would theoretically be more than sufficient for a governmental change, except that all but one of the jewish opposition parties have pledged not to include them in a government (and one also rejecting a confidence/supply reliance on them).

        On the other hand, Netanyahu also lacks any sufficient majority, unless he obtains defections (or himself gets support from the arab parties, which is less likely for one but more possible for the other).

    2. [3]
      LukeZaz
      Link Parent
      How so? A quick glance at the various parties and coalitions suggest that several of them support a two-state solution, which is a lot more than can be said for Netanyahu et al.

      It should be noted that the opposition mostly doesn't have very far differences regarding Gaza.

      How so? A quick glance at the various parties and coalitions suggest that several of them support a two-state solution, which is a lot more than can be said for Netanyahu et al.

      5 votes
      1. TheMediumJon
        Link Parent
        As far as I'm aware, of the non-Arab opposition parties three out of the four have more or less spoken out explicitly against the two-state solution during the current election and have all spoken...

        As far as I'm aware, of the non-Arab opposition parties three out of the four have more or less spoken out explicitly against the two-state solution during the current election and have all spoken out in favor of "winning in Gaza" in some form or another, fwiw.

        The Arab Parties, Raam and the Joint List, obviously are different in that regard but even among the opposition to Netanyahu they are sort of looked at leper-like (mostly).

        Edit: I will counter-argue to some extent in the sense that the opposition does not have the ultra-religious fanatics which and openly explicitly call for the destruction of Gaza.

        12 votes
      2. BartHarleyJarvis
        Link Parent
        Technically, the official US position is in support of a two-state solution, yet the US provided unconditional support and upwards of 70% of the weapons that Israel has used in its relentless...

        Technically, the official US position is in support of a two-state solution, yet the US provided unconditional support and upwards of 70% of the weapons that Israel has used in its relentless aggression in Gaza, the West Bank, and Lebanon.

        As it currently stands, the phrase "two-state solution" has as much meaning as someone saying, "That diet I'm on officially starts Monday." It ain't happening.

        For another glance at the current state of Israeli politics and the overall mood in the country, see this clip from a debate earlier this month, this brief video from The Guardian, or any poll that examines Israeli attitudes towards Palestinians.

        11 votes
  2. [4]
    KapteinB
    Link
    In big, improbable shift, UTJ said to consider supporting an Eisenkot-led minority government (Times of Israel)

    In big, improbable shift, UTJ said to consider supporting an Eisenkot-led minority government (Times of Israel)

    In what would amount to a landmark political shift, figures in the ultra-Orthodox United Torah Judaism party are reportedly considering offering support to a minority government led by leading opposition candidate Gadi Eisenkot without formally joining his coalition.

    10 votes
    1. [3]
      TheMediumJon
      Link Parent
      Huh, considering both sides theoretically have opposite stances on one of the big hot-button issues of the election, curious to see the idea there.

      Huh, considering both sides theoretically have opposite stances on one of the big hot-button issues of the election, curious to see the idea there.

      3 votes
      1. [2]
        Lyrl
        Link Parent
        I'm assuming the idea is to prevent a government that includes an Arab party from forming, which is currently the most straightforward way to create a majority coalition.

        I'm assuming the idea is to prevent a government that includes an Arab party from forming, which is currently the most straightforward way to create a majority coalition.

        6 votes
        1. TheMediumJon
          Link Parent
          I don't think they are enough on their own (IIRC they got less than either of the Arab parties) to enable the formation of a government of the opposition. And that's leaving aside the political...

          I don't think they are enough on their own (IIRC they got less than either of the Arab parties) to enable the formation of a government of the opposition. And that's leaving aside the political goals (I consider it more likely that they hope to reconcile the opposition to some form of continued exemption for their religious base).

          FWIW, as far as I've seen the numbers, the center-liberal block ended up slightly shy of having a majority and needs to include or get a confidence/supply agreement from one of these four options:

          • The two Arab parties (nominally most likely despite the staunch disavowal)
          • Likud itself (while Netanyahu hasn't ruled out a broad government he has proclaimed it under be under his largest party as its chief and his deposition was essentially the rallying cry of the opposition)
          • The two ultra orthodox parties (who want a continuation of their military service exemptions which were probably complaint nr 2 or 3 of the opposition)
          • The two national-religious parties (who's fanaticism and desire to keep inflaming things arguably was raison d'etre nr 3 or 2 of the opposition coalition).

          Either way, except for the Likud it needs to be both parties of one of these slices. UTJ on their own aren't sufficient and the other has announced it favors Netanyahu.

          3 votes