34 votes

The most dangerous Canadian internet bill you’ve never heard of is a step closer to becoming law

7 comments

  1. ZeroGee
    Link
    Using the "What about the children" defense has to end. Make parents accountable. Kids will be the first ones to figure out how to circumvent porn-blocks. It's literally all they will spend their...

    Using the "What about the children" defense has to end. Make parents accountable.

    Kids will be the first ones to figure out how to circumvent porn-blocks. It's literally all they will spend their time on.

    32 votes
  2. [3]
    Oslypsis
    Link
    How would a VPN affect this? I'm not tech savvy enough to know. Nor have I ever used a VPN before.

    How would a VPN affect this? I'm not tech savvy enough to know. Nor have I ever used a VPN before.

    6 votes
    1. Delgalar
      Link Parent
      Im just as likely to be wrong ,but I think a VPN would get around this. The traffic without a VPN goes: Your computer > your ISP > out into the wwwilds on its way to the server holding the data...

      Im just as likely to be wrong ,but I think a VPN would get around this.

      The traffic without a VPN goes:
      Your computer > your ISP > out into the wwwilds on its way to the server holding the data for the URL, eventually returning data back to you. Your ISP can see this, obviously

      I'm preeeeettysomewhat, kinda sure that with a VPN it goes:

      Your computer > your ISP > the VPN servers > out into the wwwilds, and eventually back the same way.

      I'm not sure if the ISP sees the original URL and such, or if it only sees a request to the VPN.

      This is a long way of saying I don't know I guess :)

      10 votes
    2. mild_takes
      Link Parent
      It should get around it. The website would see the VPNs Ip address as the location requesting the site.

      It should get around it. The website would see the VPNs Ip address as the location requesting the site.

      7 votes
  3. [3]
    kingofsnake
    Link
    Did I read that it'll apply to global websites? Nevermind whether you agree with it, to me it seems like another example of a governments ability to talk big and legislate but not deliver on...

    Did I read that it'll apply to global websites? Nevermind whether you agree with it, to me it seems like another example of a governments ability to talk big and legislate but not deliver on promises well outside of their capacity to do so

    5 votes
    1. [2]
      Pistos
      Link Parent
      Can you expand on this? The article explains that the blockage would happen at the Canadian ISP level, so it wouldn't matter where in the world the sites are being hosted, or where the site owners...

      not deliver on promises well outside of their capacity to do so

      Can you expand on this? The article explains that the blockage would happen at the Canadian ISP level, so it wouldn't matter where in the world the sites are being hosted, or where the site owners are (because the ISPs could just block by domain name or IP address).

      4 votes
      1. kingofsnake
        Link Parent
        Good read - mine was just a lazy comment about government's attempt to do a lot but have a hard time delivering. See delivering provincial healthcare, see upholding federal competition law, tax...

        Good read - mine was just a lazy comment about government's attempt to do a lot but have a hard time delivering. See delivering provincial healthcare, see upholding federal competition law, tax collecting and communications trade rules.

        2 votes