39 votes

Cartoons such as Steven Universe, Gravity Falls, or Avatar?

What I love about these series is the overarching plot that isn't too obvious, lots of character growth, and a great mix of comedy and seriousness between episodes.

A show I tried that was advertised as similar was Star vs. the Forces of Evil that was a little too in your face with a lol random personality that I don't really click with.

No restrictions on time period, and feel free to suggest anime if it fits the bill, I just posted in TV as I these aren't anime and I don't have much experience in the area.

79 comments

  1. [12]
    canekicker
    Link
    "Adventure Time" and "Legend of Korra" are ones that come to mind. "Over the Garden Wall" as well but it's not what I'd called comedic. If movies are on the table here's what checks your boxes...

    "Adventure Time" and "Legend of Korra" are ones that come to mind. "Over the Garden Wall" as well but it's not what I'd called comedic.

    If movies are on the table here's what checks your boxes that immediately came to mind
    "Nimoa"
    "TMNT Mutant Mayhem"

    Other recent things I'd probably recommend that perhaps aren't as readily recommended

    "Scavengers Reign" - serious, surreal sci-fi. Beautifully done but no comedy
    "Less popular" Miyazaki films - less comedy but lots of character development without being overly dour. "Kiki's Delivery Service", "Ponyo", "My Neighbor Totoro" are some of my favorite but they're all really good

    24 votes
    1. [4]
      tomf
      Link Parent
      This absolutely blew my mind from a world-detail perspective. I've got Pantheon in the queue. No idea if its the same level, though.

      Scavengers Reign

      This absolutely blew my mind from a world-detail perspective. I've got Pantheon in the queue. No idea if its the same level, though.

      7 votes
      1. arghdos
        Link Parent
        I enjoyed pantheon, but for entirely different reasons than scavengers reign. It was a pretty well thought out AI (ish) scenario, decent pacing, good characters, etc. Definitely worth the watch

        I enjoyed pantheon, but for entirely different reasons than scavengers reign. It was a pretty well thought out AI (ish) scenario, decent pacing, good characters, etc. Definitely worth the watch

        5 votes
      2. [2]
        Foreigner
        Link Parent
        Oh you're in for a treat when you watch Pantheon. I had a slight existential crisis after watching each season. Definitely one of my favourites out of all the series mentioned so far

        Oh you're in for a treat when you watch Pantheon. I had a slight existential crisis after watching each season. Definitely one of my favourites out of all the series mentioned so far

        2 votes
        1. tomf
          Link Parent
          nice! I'm stoked. I had that sort of response after Midnight Gospel ended.

          nice! I'm stoked. I had that sort of response after Midnight Gospel ended.

          2 votes
    2. [2]
      TheD00d
      Link Parent
      This is always a favorite of mine. To anyone who is lurking on this thread. Watch it. But do yourselves a favor and wait until fall. The whole vibe of the show is very fall centric to me and it...

      Over the Garden Wall

      This is always a favorite of mine. To anyone who is lurking on this thread. Watch it. But do yourselves a favor and wait until fall. The whole vibe of the show is very fall centric to me and it just feels right. Its short, like 10 episodes and you can knock it out in a weekend. Really beautifully animated show with stellar voice actors.

      6 votes
      1. Exellin
        Link Parent
        It will likely take me a few years to get through all the recommendations in this thread, so I'll schedule this for the fall!

        It will likely take me a few years to get through all the recommendations in this thread, so I'll schedule this for the fall!

        1 vote
    3. zoroa
      (edited )
      Link Parent
      There's a lot I don't like about Korra Weak spoiler for end-of-season action scene. Why were giant mech battles how TWO seasons ended?! But it's hard not to acknowledge how the show runners swung...

      There's a lot I don't like about Korra

      Weak spoiler for end-of-season action scene. Why were giant mech battles how TWO seasons ended?!

      But it's hard not to acknowledge how the show runners swung for the fences in both series with the themes they portrayed in a children's show.

      Spoiler for a theme in Season 4 of Korra Korra's journey with PTSD was one of my earliest exposures to the idea, and felt like a very powerful depiction of how trauma can trap someone.
      1 vote
    4. Stranger
      Link Parent
      Much as I enjoyed it (and generally recommend it), I don't think it really fits OP's criteria at all beyond "animated" and "overarching plot". It has a very different feel than the shows OP...

      Scavenger's Reign

      Much as I enjoyed it (and generally recommend it), I don't think it really fits OP's criteria at all beyond "animated" and "overarching plot". It has a very different feel than the shows OP listed.

      On top of being much more somber, SR's story is told in a different way that give it a more disjointed feeling imho. The shows OP mentioned all have an overarching plot but by and large follow the perspective of the same character (or character group) with each episode being a sort of "problem of the day", which is to say each episode is it's own fairly self contained story. Major plot developments happen more infrequently so you could skip some episodes and generally pick right up without feeling lost. It's very casual. SR's story is told by jumping back and forth through multiple, independent storylines that eventually converge but mostly feel like completely separate stories. Some episodes favor different threads more heavily, but the overall density means that missing an episode means missing a lot of important info.

      1 vote
    5. [3]
      Exellin
      Link Parent
      I watched all of Legend of Korra already and really enjoyed the steampunk atmosphere, but agree the characters are not as strong as in TLA. I'll check out a few episodes of Adventure time to see...

      I watched all of Legend of Korra already and really enjoyed the steampunk atmosphere, but agree the characters are not as strong as in TLA.

      I'll check out a few episodes of Adventure time to see if I enjoy it or not, I have been somewhat sceptical just from clips online but that is not giving it a fair shot.

      Movies are great recommendations and I was thinking about watching Nimoa, will be sure to check it out!.

      1. PancakeCats
        Link Parent
        I will say, Adventure Time definitely starts to get better and a little more mature around season 3 onwards. Still a lot of good stuff in the first two seasons but i feel like it really hits its...

        I will say, Adventure Time definitely starts to get better and a little more mature around season 3 onwards. Still a lot of good stuff in the first two seasons but i feel like it really hits its stride and grows out of its lol random goofy wacky phase into something a little more refined and unique to its own vibe and identity. The episodes are all short too, 10m a pop, so try to give it time if you dont exactly vibe with the initial outings.

        2 votes
      2. canekicker
        (edited )
        Link Parent
        As others have said, season 1 and most of season 2 is a bit whacky but they do a good job of showing its potential and where it'll go. From there on its brilliant. The HBO one off specials and the...

        As others have said, season 1 and most of season 2 is a bit whacky but they do a good job of showing its potential and where it'll go. From there on its brilliant. The HBO one off specials and the Fiona and Cake spin off are really fantastic as well. For me, its the best cartoon I've ever seen.

        1 vote
  2. [2]
    jess
    Link
    The new She Ra reboot (haven't seen the original) is pretty great and fits a similar feel to Avatar for me. It has a little weaker character growth and story than Avatar, but not so much to render...

    The new She Ra reboot (haven't seen the original) is pretty great and fits a similar feel to Avatar for me. It has a little weaker character growth and story than Avatar, but not so much to render it unenjoyable.

    22 votes
    1. Exellin
      Link Parent
      Thanks will add She Ra to the list especially with how many others are endorsing it in this thread!

      Thanks will add She Ra to the list especially with how many others are endorsing it in this thread!

      2 votes
  3. [5]
    arghdos
    Link
    Some others that haven’t been mentioned Owl House Infinity Train (later seasons are kinda just ok) Adventure Time (though there’s lots of random episodes as well) Star Wars Rebels (if you’re into...

    Some others that haven’t been mentioned

    Owl House
    Infinity Train (later seasons are kinda just ok)
    Adventure Time (though there’s lots of random episodes as well)
    Star Wars Rebels (if you’re into Star Wars)

    18 votes
    1. Akir
      Link Parent
      Owl House was a really fantastic show. I really loved the themes of love and acceptance, and the animation could be outstanding at times. It was full of surprisingly compelling lore and a cast of...

      Owl House was a really fantastic show. I really loved the themes of love and acceptance, and the animation could be outstanding at times. It was full of surprisingly compelling lore and a cast of lovable characters and pathos.

      7 votes
    2. cuteFox
      Link Parent
      "Star Wars: The Clone Wars" is great too and now there is "Star Wars: The Bad Batch" too! all of them are worth watching. I suggest watching in this order (chronological order): the clone wars the...

      "Star Wars: The Clone Wars" is great too and now there is "Star Wars: The Bad Batch" too! all of them are worth watching. I suggest watching in this order (chronological order):

      1. the clone wars
      2. the bad batch
      3. rebels
      4 votes
    3. Bonooru
      Link Parent
      The Owl House is magnificent and deserving of all the praise. It's a shame the 3rd season was cut short, but Disney making weird decisions is par for the course there.

      The Owl House is magnificent and deserving of all the praise. It's a shame the 3rd season was cut short, but Disney making weird decisions is par for the course there.

      4 votes
    4. Exellin
      Link Parent
      Not a fan of star wars but I'll add Owl House to the list! I'm sceptical about Adventure time from what I've seen but I'm down to give it a shot. Infinity train looks like a really cool concept,...

      Not a fan of star wars but I'll add Owl House to the list!

      I'm sceptical about Adventure time from what I've seen but I'm down to give it a shot.

      Infinity train looks like a really cool concept, will check out the first season eventually.

      3 votes
  4. [2]
    GravySleeve
    Link
    There aren't many cartoons as good as Avatar, but any time this question is asked my first recommendation that comes to mind is always The Dragon Prince. It's not as good, but it is co-created...

    There aren't many cartoons as good as Avatar, but any time this question is asked my first recommendation that comes to mind is always The Dragon Prince. It's not as good, but it is co-created with Aaron Ehasz who was the head writer and co-producer on Avatar.

    15 votes
    1. terr
      Link Parent
      I've frequently touted The Dragon Prince as the best (off-brand) D&D cartoon I've ever seen. The characters are great and the world itself feels like a great spin on the classic Tolkienian fantasy...

      I've frequently touted The Dragon Prince as the best (off-brand) D&D cartoon I've ever seen. The characters are great and the world itself feels like a great spin on the classic Tolkienian fantasy world.

      For anyone looking to check it out for the first time though, fair warning: the animation in the first season is pretty choppy because it's done at a relatively low frame rate, but it improves dramatically with season 2.

      4 votes
  5. [4]
    CannibalisticApple
    Link
    If you have Netflix, I highly recommend "Kipo and the Age of the Wonderbeasts". It's complete and it's about a pretty colorful post-apocalyptic world where a lot of animals have mutated and...

    If you have Netflix, I highly recommend "Kipo and the Age of the Wonderbeasts". It's complete and it's about a pretty colorful post-apocalyptic world where a lot of animals have mutated and developed strong intelligence, and forced humans into hiding. It was a fun watch for me.

    If you want something aimed at more mature crowds and don't mind darker humor: Hazbin Hotel just released its first season on Amazon. It's about the princess of Hell opening a hotel to try to redeem sinners, and it's pretty dang fun. Biggest downside is it's only 8 episodes long, and no word on when season 2 will drop yet. There's also a spin-off series called Helluva Boss that's on YouTube, though personally not as big of a fan of the main protagonist in that one.
    Then there's Harley Quinn on MAX. I watched the first... Two, three seasons I think? That one was a LOT of fun. Very violent and lots of dark humor obviously, but each season so far had some overarching plot.

    15 votes
    1. GenuinelyCrooked
      Link Parent
      I came here to recommend Kipo! The soundtrack is amazing, and the themes and morals are really good without being heavy handed. I can't wait until my niblings are old enough to enjoy it.

      I came here to recommend Kipo! The soundtrack is amazing, and the themes and morals are really good without being heavy handed. I can't wait until my niblings are old enough to enjoy it.

      9 votes
    2. dr_frahnkunsteen
      Link Parent
      Kipo was my first thought as well when I saw what OP was looking for. I loved Hazbin Hotel and Helluva Boss, and I’m actually looking for more shows like that, that aren’t interested in courting...

      Kipo was my first thought as well when I saw what OP was looking for.

      I loved Hazbin Hotel and Helluva Boss, and I’m actually looking for more shows like that, that aren’t interested in courting both kids and adults, but a strictly for adults cartoon. I’ve been a fan of adult swim for years but kind of fell off after the Venture Bros. I really enjoyed Close Enough until it got Zazlov’d. Invincible is fantastic as well. What I enjoyed about Hazbin Hotel is that it has an almost Looney Tunes quality to it in the way the characters move and talk, and even the sound design, but it was also very fresh and new.

      5 votes
    3. Exellin
      Link Parent
      I do have netflix and Kipo sounds right up my alley! I'll also add Hazbin and Harley Quinn to the list, but probably won't get to Harly Quinn for a while as I don't have Max and I would want to...

      I do have netflix and Kipo sounds right up my alley!

      I'll also add Hazbin and Harley Quinn to the list, but probably won't get to Harly Quinn for a while as I don't have Max and I would want to finish Batman the animated series first so I at least have some background knowledge on Gotham City.

  6. [8]
    legogizmo
    Link
    I'm surprised Hilda (Netflix) hasn't been mentioned yet. And then there is the classic that is Batman the animated series (as well as the rest of the DCAU)

    I'm surprised Hilda (Netflix) hasn't been mentioned yet.

    And then there is the classic that is Batman the animated series (as well as the rest of the DCAU)

    15 votes
    1. [4]
      Jerutix
      Link Parent
      Hilda is such a good one! I’d also add 2017 DuckTales to the list. I haven’t watched Steven Universe, but Gravity Falls and Avatar round out my top 3 cartoons of all time with DuckTales.

      Hilda is such a good one!

      I’d also add 2017 DuckTales to the list. I haven’t watched Steven Universe, but Gravity Falls and Avatar round out my top 3 cartoons of all time with DuckTales.

      11 votes
      1. [3]
        Exellin
        Link Parent
        Alright I just looked up DuckTales and saw that David Tennant (my favourite doctor) is Scrooge McDuck and I'm sold! I know almost nothing about that universe, anything I should read or watch...

        Alright I just looked up DuckTales and saw that David Tennant (my favourite doctor) is Scrooge McDuck and I'm sold!

        I know almost nothing about that universe, anything I should read or watch beforehand or can I go in blind?

        2 votes
        1. [2]
          legogizmo
          Link Parent
          You can go in blind. It is stand alone and you don't need to know any lore to appreciate it.

          You can go in blind. It is stand alone and you don't need to know any lore to appreciate it.

          3 votes
          1. Jerutix
            Link Parent
            Agreed. There are tons and tons of Easter eggs, but no knowledge is required to enjoy it. You just won't be as excited when characters from other Disney Afternoon 90s shows appear.

            Agreed. There are tons and tons of Easter eggs, but no knowledge is required to enjoy it. You just won't be as excited when characters from other Disney Afternoon 90s shows appear.

            2 votes
    2. [3]
      Exellin
      Link Parent
      Thank you for the Hilda recommendation I'll be sure to check it out especially after a few others also endorsing it! For Batman the animated series I'm not that into superhero media, but all I...

      Thank you for the Hilda recommendation I'll be sure to check it out especially after a few others also endorsing it!

      For Batman the animated series I'm not that into superhero media, but all I have really watched is most marvel films up to endgame along with a handful of spiderman, superman, and batman movies. I'm down to give it a shot! I found a recommended viewing list on reddit that cuts out the bad episodes, do you agree with this or I should just watch it all?

      2 votes
      1. legogizmo
        Link Parent
        That list looks pretty good. If you find yourself enjoying it, give the "bad" episodes a shot, because I can't think of any truly bad episodes just ones that aren't as great. But that post sums up...

        That list looks pretty good. If you find yourself enjoying it, give the "bad" episodes a shot, because I can't think of any truly bad episodes just ones that aren't as great.

        But that post sums up my feelings on the show, it laid the ground work for so much that followed.

        2 votes
      2. CannibalisticApple
        Link Parent
        I'd say watch them all, though that list is definitely a good starting point! If you're watching it on Max, I think it scrambled the episode order for some reason so that list will help. While...

        I'd say watch them all, though that list is definitely a good starting point! If you're watching it on Max, I think it scrambled the episode order for some reason so that list will help. While many of the episodes can be watched at any time, there are some that definitely follow a certain continuity. Pretty Poison and Two-Face are the big examples to come to mind.

        Side-note: I'm not hugely into superhero media either, but the DC Animated Universe feels like a golden standard to me. I've been saying for years that DC's films would have been better if they just adapted some of the DCAU stories. So hopefully that means you'll enjoy this more than the movies!

        1 vote
  7. [2]
    Nefara
    Link
    A lot of my picks have already been listed, so I'll pitch in Amphibia. It's another animated series that starts off pretty shallow and episodic, but it develops an overarching story that becomes...

    A lot of my picks have already been listed, so I'll pitch in Amphibia. It's another animated series that starts off pretty shallow and episodic, but it develops an overarching story that becomes increasingly complex with higher and higher stakes. It has some pretty dramatic character development over the series, where most of the main cast become unrecognizable by the end. I initially was pretty meh about it, but by the end I was binging it and glued to the screen. I don't want to say too much about it since the discovery is part of the fun, but stick with it and it really takes off.

    For the record, my other picks from the thread are: She Ra: Princesses of Power, Hilda, Owl House, Dragon Prince (not so much more recent seasons though) and Kipo.

    9 votes
    1. Exellin
      Link Parent
      You pitched Amphibia well and I'll be sure to check it out!

      You pitched Amphibia well and I'll be sure to check it out!

  8. [5]
    Foreigner
    Link
    I'll add a few more to the list of those already mentioned: Amphibia OK KO Mao Mao: Heroes of Pure Heart (cancelled?) Glitch Techs (cancelled?) Bee and Puppycat Centaur world Moon Girl and Devil...

    I'll add a few more to the list of those already mentioned:

    • Amphibia
    • OK KO
    • Mao Mao: Heroes of Pure Heart (cancelled?)
    • Glitch Techs (cancelled?)
    • Bee and Puppycat
    • Centaur world
    • Moon Girl and Devil Dinosaur
    • Dead End (cancelled)
    • Wander Over Yonder

    With more adult comedy:

    • Inside Job (cancelled)
    • Tuca and Bertie
    • Star Trek: Lower Decks
    • Tear along the dotted line/This world can't tear me down
    • Harley Quinn
    • Helluva Boss

    More humour focused and for "younger" audiences:

    • The Amazing World of Gumball
    • Kiff

    Not at all funny but beautiful:

    • Blue eye samurai
    • Castlevania
    • Cyberpunk Edgerunners

    I absolutely do echo recommendations to watch Pantheon and Scavengers Reign, they would have been on this last list if they weren't already mentioned.

    Also for anyone who has young kids (or not) I will never stop plugging Bluey. It's my comfort show :)

    7 votes
    1. [4]
      Akir
      Link Parent
      I absolutely love Bee and Puppycat. I like how even though there is this great fantastical world and dark threatening characters it always keeps them in the background and prioritizes the...

      I absolutely love Bee and Puppycat. I like how even though there is this great fantastical world and dark threatening characters it always keeps them in the background and prioritizes the characters and their feelings. And the whole thing looks amazingly gorgeous visually. It’s a masterpiece of vibes.

      3 votes
      1. [3]
        Foreigner
        Link Parent
        Bee and Puppycat set the bar for me as far as "whimsical slice of life (but not exactly)" shows go. It really is great and I hope they continue it! Have you watched Summer Camp Island? It's more...

        Bee and Puppycat set the bar for me as far as "whimsical slice of life (but not exactly)" shows go. It really is great and I hope they continue it!

        Have you watched Summer Camp Island? It's more "childish" and the style is very different, but also hits the whimsical show spot for me. Not among my favourites, but it might be up your alley if you like B&PC.

        1 vote
        1. [2]
          Akir
          Link Parent
          I did watch the first episode or so, but I felt a bit alienated by the very young characters.

          I did watch the first episode or so, but I felt a bit alienated by the very young characters.

          1 vote
          1. Foreigner
            Link Parent
            Yeah that's fair, I did drop it at one point in the beginning but then went back to it as I ran out of other things to watch. It is intended for younger audiences after all.

            Yeah that's fair, I did drop it at one point in the beginning but then went back to it as I ran out of other things to watch. It is intended for younger audiences after all.

            2 votes
  9. [2]
    Grayscail
    Link
    Teen Titans had good overarching plots with each season having a big picture antagonist. And tons of character development for each of the team members. One of the best cartoons ever, in my...

    Teen Titans had good overarching plots with each season having a big picture antagonist. And tons of character development for each of the team members. One of the best cartoons ever, in my opinion. I think it would be a good fit for what you are looking for.

    6 votes
    1. zoroa
      Link Parent
      I'm assuming you mean the series from 2003 and not the reboot. I hadn't thought about that in forever, and now I'm awash in a wave a nostalgia for that show.

      I'm assuming you mean the series from 2003 and not the reboot.

      I hadn't thought about that in forever, and now I'm awash in a wave a nostalgia for that show.

      3 votes
  10. [3]
    meme
    Link
    She Ra reboot (quite childish but in a way I enjoyed) Owl House (you think it's episodic until the overarching plot sneaks up on you, like Gravity Falls) Adventures of Fiona and Cake (TV-14,...
    • She Ra reboot (quite childish but in a way I enjoyed)

    • Owl House (you think it's episodic until the overarching plot sneaks up on you, like Gravity Falls)

    • Adventures of Fiona and Cake (TV-14, exactly the kind of adult Adventure Time people dreamed of)

    6 votes
    1. [2]
      Blakdragon
      Link Parent
      Huge vote for Owl House! This thread is making me think I need to go check out She Ra!

      Owl House

      Huge vote for Owl House!

      This thread is making me think I need to go check out She Ra!

      7 votes
      1. Nefara
        Link Parent
        Do, it's wholesome and fun but doesn't lose its emotional resonance. It recognizes and acknowledges the dark but it doesn't ever fall into it. It's a bit like classic Star Trek in that it believes...

        Do, it's wholesome and fun but doesn't lose its emotional resonance. It recognizes and acknowledges the dark but it doesn't ever fall into it. It's a bit like classic Star Trek in that it believes in the best of everyone and people in general. Has some great story moments and I'd recommend it to anyone.

        5 votes
  11. Dr_Amazing
    Link
    I don't think I saw Gargoyles on here. That's like the grand daddy of continuity in kids shows

    I don't think I saw Gargoyles on here. That's like the grand daddy of continuity in kids shows

    6 votes
  12. babypuncher
    Link
    Star Trek Prodigy might fit the bill, if you're willing to expand to 3D animation. It gets off to a slow start but picks up after a few episodes.

    Star Trek Prodigy might fit the bill, if you're willing to expand to 3D animation. It gets off to a slow start but picks up after a few episodes.

    5 votes
  13. [2]
    moocow1452
    (edited )
    Link
    A bit of a sidebar, but a lot of the cartoons mentioned are part of the Flapjack Family, in that a lot of the show runners worked on the Marvelous Misadventures of Flapjack....

    A bit of a sidebar, but a lot of the cartoons mentioned are part of the Flapjack Family, in that a lot of the show runners worked on the Marvelous Misadventures of Flapjack.

    https://www.reddit.com/gallery/188sq8k

    I can vouch for all the featured cartoons, if any catch your interest.

    5 votes
    1. moocow1452
      Link Parent
      Also, because I completely put it out of my head, Disney's X-Men '97 has been pretty good and is headed towards a 3 part season finale.

      Also, because I completely put it out of my head, Disney's X-Men '97 has been pretty good and is headed towards a 3 part season finale.

      1 vote
  14. [7]
    SloMoMonday
    Link
    Star vs Evil does calm down on the "random" humor as the plot ramps up and the character needs to grow up. Unfortunately, it's a case of "it gets good by season 3". A lot of my favorite western...

    Star vs Evil does calm down on the "random" humor as the plot ramps up and the character needs to grow up. Unfortunately, it's a case of "it gets good by season 3".

    A lot of my favorite western animations are already mentioned so some anime recommendations I give to everyone are:

    Spy x Family - A cold war, Mr/Mrs Smith story where the kid, dog and babysitter are all wrapped up in it.

    Violet Evergarden - Post WW2 drama about a child soldier finding herself by working as a typist. A little more anthology but you track the characters development over 5 years. Can be on the nose at times but it's beautifully animated and I ugly cried at times.

    A Place Further than the Universe - A grounded school adventure about kids wanting to go to Antarctica and figuring out how to do it.

    Frieren: Beyond Journey's End - Fairly new but quickly moving up my favorites list. the story begins at the end of a decade long debenture to kill the demon king. And we immediately skip 50+ years to where the heros die happy and peacefully, save for the immortal elf who figures out a little too late how important those relationships were. This comic sums it up best.

    5 votes
    1. [4]
      moocow1452
      Link Parent
      Even then, I don't really thinks it sticks the landing because it wanted to tackle deeper material than it really knew how to, and the ending is infamous among the fandom for not really landing as...

      Star vs Evil does calm down on the "random" humor as the plot ramps up and the character needs to grow up. Unfortunately, it's a case of "it gets good by season 3".

      Even then, I don't really thinks it sticks the landing because it wanted to tackle deeper material than it really knew how to, and the ending is infamous among the fandom for not really landing as intended.

      Second "A Place further than the Universe" and "Violet Evergarden" though.

      1 vote
      1. [3]
        arch
        Link Parent
        It is probably my favorite animated series, and I have watched nearly all of these that are recommended. To be fair, I am pretty sure I have untreated ADHD, so the short format and high energy...
        It is probably my favorite animated series, and I have watched nearly all of these that are recommended. To be fair, I am pretty sure I have untreated ADHD, so the short format and high energy really appeals to me. But story wise the allegory of bigotry and racism being tackled through the monsters, as well as the fact that there is no simple solution to their problems despite magic being a central device in the show are wonderful. The charter arc & growth with Ludo (Alan Tudyk is always a delight) and Buff Frog are some of the best I have ever seen. And the ending, while being absolutely devastating, is so emotionally cathartic that I couldn't think of a better way to do it. If you are not a viewer who empathizes with the characters as a form of emotional release, then I suppose it could fall flat, because like everything else in the show it is not a simple magical solution that solves everything, it has consequences and is bittersweet.
        Click to expand spoiler.

        Star chooses to give up herself and all of magic in order to save Marco (and both her worlds). She chooses to do it knowing she will never be with him again. Even with the happy twist at the end, you don't get over those emotions quickly, they stick with you.

        If someone really has trouble getting into the series, I would suggest watching Episode 1 then jumping to Episode 13 and continuing from there before flat out giving up. There is a lot of things in season 1 that could be considered filler, but later on become clear that there was a plan for most of the characters and their arcs from the beginning.

        1 vote
        1. [2]
          moocow1452
          Link Parent
          Okay, let's get into the weeds on children's entertainment. My major issue with the ending Two things that kind of annoy me about the magic decision. In universe, we have no idea of the...

          Okay, let's get into the weeds on children's entertainment.

          My major issue with the ending

          Two things that kind of annoy me about the magic decision. In universe, we have no idea of the implications of turning off magic across all of everything. Ponyhead and her family seemed to survive it well enough, but they made a point of having some of the counsel members of magic no longer be alive due to that decision. That's also a decision that Star made for every creature in existence without input, and if the show's message is that the monarchy shouldn't unilaterally make decisions to make their subjects lives worse in the name of their own values and pride, then it's a bit of a mixed message in the finale.

          Out of universe, it's kind of a "flip the table" solution to governance and revolution that so happens to work out, and the show frames it as entirely the right thing to do because magic is the tool of the oppressors and if you take it away the world is better off for it." Maybe that's true, but it needs to be better established and not brought up and an option at the end of the penultimate episode. Maybe it would have gone down better if this was something of last resort, or explicitly the Royal Magic was cut down as opposed to all magic across all creation, or it was the only way to stop the death spell, but as presented, the whole thing left a bad taste in my mouth.

          Not to take anything away from you, your feelings and how the characters were represented, this is how I feel and I thought it landed sour.

          1 vote
          1. arch
            Link Parent
            No hurt feelings or anything on my end, we simply seem to have different interpretations of what happened and what the meaning of it was. Star's struggles fit with my personal world view, and my...

            No hurt feelings or anything on my end, we simply seem to have different interpretations of what happened and what the meaning of it was. Star's struggles fit with my personal world view, and my own experiences when I was a teenager who was given too much responsibility and power. Despite trying my best things were continually misunderstood and went awry. I find it very relatable even as an adult with a kid of my own.

            I don't think the show's message is that monarchy shouldn't unilaterally make decisions. Star makes that decision at one point in the series, but she almost immediately sees that the Mewmans and Monsters go right back to fighting. The gap in power that she leaves is exploited and leads to war. There's also the ironic that her deciding to not rule the monarchy is making a decision that all of her subjects will have to live with. It is supposed to be messy, it is not supposed to have a clear answer or moral. For me it made the show better, and I completely understand how it may have made the show worse for others.

            1 vote
    2. [2]
      Exellin
      Link Parent
      Thank you for the anime recommendations! I'll check out A Place further than the Universe and Violet Evergarden due to the additional endorsement from /u/moocow1452.

      Thank you for the anime recommendations! I'll check out A Place further than the Universe and Violet Evergarden due to the additional endorsement from /u/moocow1452.

      1. chizcurl
        (edited )
        Link Parent
        I recently finished season 1 (25 episodes) of Frieren: Beyond Journey's End, and it's amazing! Like ATLA, the show is extremely character driven with incredible world building and some episodic...

        I recently finished season 1 (25 episodes) of Frieren: Beyond Journey's End, and it's amazing! Like ATLA, the show is extremely character driven with incredible world building and some episodic storytelling in the mix. It has it all: coziness, comedy, action, romance, adventure, existentialism, heartwarming moments, dark moments. I'm now watching commentaries to get my fix after the show is over. I can't recommend it enough!

        Edited to add another anime that was short and enjoyable and might be your vibe: Somali and the Forest Spirit. In short, a forest golem embarks on mission to reunite a lost child with her family. It's cute, funny, and also kinda dark.

        1 vote
  15. [4]
    threegnomes
    Link
    If you're willing to try anime Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood checks all those boxes.

    If you're willing to try anime Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood checks all those boxes.

    5 votes
    1. [3]
      Exellin
      Link Parent
      I have actually watched all of Fullmetal Alchemist that I enjoyed for the most part! However that was 5 years ago so I could see myself watching brotherhood eventually even though they are...

      I have actually watched all of Fullmetal Alchemist that I enjoyed for the most part! However that was 5 years ago so I could see myself watching brotherhood eventually even though they are somewhat similar.

      1 vote
      1. threegnomes
        Link Parent
        I've never seen all of the original Anime, but they split fairly early on in Brotherhood's runtime and after that it's an entirely different story.

        I've never seen all of the original Anime, but they split fairly early on in Brotherhood's runtime and after that it's an entirely different story.

        2 votes
      2. PotatoKat
        Link Parent
        The plot majorly diverges and they become practically different shows. Around FMA's episode ~30 is around brotherhood's 12 then the rest of the 50 episodes are completely different. It feels much...

        The plot majorly diverges and they become practically different shows. Around FMA's episode ~30 is around brotherhood's 12 then the rest of the 50 episodes are completely different. It feels much more like ATLA in terms of being an adventure compared to the original show's more character drama focus (not to say there isn't character drama in broship)

        2 votes
  16. [3]
    oracle
    Link
    Close Enough

    Close Enough

    4 votes
    1. moocow1452
      Link Parent
      In that vein, Regular Show is the precursor show and is still available for streaming in it's entirety rather than being taken out back braids the barn for a quick buck.

      In that vein, Regular Show is the precursor show and is still available for streaming in it's entirety rather than being taken out back braids the barn for a quick buck.

      4 votes
    2. dr_frahnkunsteen
      Link Parent
      Where can you even watch this anymore, besides the high seas of course?

      Where can you even watch this anymore, besides the high seas of course?

      2 votes
  17. [2]
    vildravn
    Link
    I haven’t seen it mentioned, sorry if I missed it, but Final Space is a show I can wholeheartedly recommend. It has silly and serious moments, the latter seasons are a bit “lol random” at times...

    I haven’t seen it mentioned, sorry if I missed it, but Final Space is a show I can wholeheartedly recommend. It has silly and serious moments, the latter seasons are a bit “lol random” at times but it’s very well written in my opinion.

    3 votes
    1. Jerutix
      (edited )
      Link Parent
      Man I loved Final Space! Tragic it got cancelled and pulled off (HBO) Max. Looking forward to, one day, reading the series finale graphic novel. Final Space Ends

      Man I loved Final Space! Tragic it got cancelled and pulled off (HBO) Max. Looking forward to, one day, reading the series finale graphic novel. Final Space Ends

      4 votes
  18. Interesting
    Link
    If 3d animation is OK, I highly recommend Star Trek: Prodigy. Frankly, it was the most like the 90's Star Trek of any of the new Star Trek shows. It does an great job developing the crew, the...

    If 3d animation is OK, I highly recommend Star Trek: Prodigy. Frankly, it was the most like the 90's Star Trek of any of the new Star Trek shows. It does an great job developing the crew, the backgrounds are beautifully animated, and overall it's just fun to watch.

    2 votes
  19. [2]
    Moogles
    Link
    Venture Bros. For adult comedy. One Punch Man to get into anime comedy. Going off road here. South Park develops continuity leading into the Stick of Truth game, so season 17 episode 8 onwards I...

    Venture Bros. For adult comedy.

    One Punch Man to get into anime comedy.

    Going off road here. South Park develops continuity leading into the Stick of Truth game, so season 17 episode 8 onwards I think is when the show hits a new stride.

    Regular Show is a great companion to Adventure Time.

    1 vote
    1. CannibalisticApple
      Link Parent
      Since you mentioned One Punch Man, I'll also throw out Mob Psycho 100. It's by the same author, and has some of the most banging openings in anime.

      Since you mentioned One Punch Man, I'll also throw out Mob Psycho 100. It's by the same author, and has some of the most banging openings in anime.

      2 votes
  20. [11]
    rahmad
    Link
    A great mix of light and heady. Clone Wars Primal Carmen Sandiego She-Ra Dragon Prince Trollhunters (and it's spinoffs, but they aren't as good as the original. RIP that guy) Bluey (kind of a...

    A great mix of light and heady.

    Clone Wars

    Primal

    Carmen Sandiego

    She-Ra

    Dragon Prince

    Trollhunters (and it's spinoffs, but they aren't as good as the original. RIP that guy)

    Bluey (kind of a different vibe, but it has some very heady moments. There is kind of is an overarching plot, but it's not that obvious, it's more like a difficulty curve than a plot)

    1 vote
    1. [6]
      Akir
      Link Parent
      Bluey is kind of amazing. It’s meant for very young kids but it doesn’t talk down on them or patronize them, and the adult characters aren’t cardboard cutouts, and they take their plots fairly...

      Bluey is kind of amazing. It’s meant for very young kids but it doesn’t talk down on them or patronize them, and the adult characters aren’t cardboard cutouts, and they take their plots fairly serious. As a result it’s pretty enjoyable for all audiences. The show has won a ton of awards.

      2 votes
      1. Nefara
        Link Parent
        Bluey is wonderful, and as a parent of a toddler I feel seen by it. I'd describe it as a slice of life show about parenting that both kids and adults can enjoy. It's beautiful but not what I...

        Bluey is wonderful, and as a parent of a toddler I feel seen by it. I'd describe it as a slice of life show about parenting that both kids and adults can enjoy. It's beautiful but not what I thought of for OPs prompt of over-arching story and character development. However, anyone looking for wholesome, sweet and funny content should watch it anyway.

        3 votes
      2. [4]
        rahmad
        Link Parent
        I actually think it's meant for the adults, but trying to make it accessible enough for the kids to enjoy it...

        I actually think it's meant for the adults, but trying to make it accessible enough for the kids to enjoy it...

        2 votes
        1. [3]
          DrStone
          Link Parent
          From wiki, emphasis mine:

          From wiki, emphasis mine:

          In July 2017, the Australian Broadcasting Corporation (ABC) and the British Broadcasting Corporation (BBC) co-commissioned Bluey as an animated series for preschool children to be developed by Queensland production company Ludo Studio.

          [Joe] Brumm wanted to portray the importance of children participating in imaginative play […] Brumm had previously worked on children's programs in the United Kingdom as a freelance animator and decided to create Bluey as a replica of the program Peppa Pig for an Australian audience.

          1. [2]
            rahmad
            Link Parent
            Yes, I'm not saying it is 'a product made for adults,' What I'm saying is: The thing Bluey does is evoke an idyllic relationship between parent and child, where the parent is free, available and...

            Yes, I'm not saying it is 'a product made for adults,'

            What I'm saying is:

            The thing Bluey does is evoke an idyllic relationship between parent and child, where the parent is free, available and able to be a child's equal in play, and is able to rediscover that disentangled feeling of free play.

            This is something I think many parents aspire to, wish for, enjoy when they can, but... The Cat's in the Cradle.

            The kid characters are playing. It's cute, it's funny. It works as a piece of children's entertainment.

            But the primary force inside the show is acting on a desire inside the parents.

            Kids are attuned to play. They will learn to engage in imaginative play, and turn all actions into games, instinctually. It's part of the normal and fairly universal development process. They don't need a show to teach them that, and I don't think most kids can distinguish between the quality of play between Bluey and, let's say, Hot Wheels City Adventures.

            Bluey's success, in my opinion, is not because it is more strongly attractive to kids than other kids entertainment, but because it is more strongly attractive to parents, who see it scratching something deep for them.

            And then, they choose this over some other show, they are more likely to watch it with their kids, they advocate for it with other parents, and they make it 'award winning kids entertainment.'

            2 votes
            1. DrStone
              Link Parent
              I interpreted in response to As disagreeing with who the primary (who it’s intended for) and secondary audiences (who else can still enjoy or benefit from it) are, but it sounds like just a...

              I interpreted

              I actually think it's meant for the adults, but trying to make it accessible enough for the kids

              in response to

              It’s meant for very young kids […] As a result it’s pretty enjoyable for all audiences.

              As disagreeing with who the primary (who it’s intended for) and secondary audiences (who else can still enjoy or benefit from it) are, but it sounds like just a semantic issue and actually agreement in spirit.

    2. [4]
      Foreigner
      (edited )
      Link Parent
      I'm not sure I'd call Primal light, it is very violent and gory at times. It's still an interesting series, and made by Gendy Tartakovsky, the creator of Dexter's Laboratory, , Samurai Jack, and...

      I'm not sure I'd call Primal light, it is very violent and gory at times. It's still an interesting series, and made by Gendy Tartakovsky, the creator of Dexter's Laboratory, Powerpuff Girls, Samurai Jack, and more recently, Unicorn: Warriors Eternal. If you're a fan of those shows it's worth checking it out.

      1 vote
      1. [2]
        Akir
        Link Parent
        Gendy Tartakovsky did not create Powerpuff Girls (though to my memory he did direct a few episodes).

        Gendy Tartakovsky did not create Powerpuff Girls (though to my memory he did direct a few episodes).

        2 votes
        1. Foreigner
          Link Parent
          Oops you're right that was Craig McCracken! Fixed my comment.

          Oops you're right that was Craig McCracken! Fixed my comment.

          2 votes
      2. rahmad
        Link Parent
        You're right. I guess I meant 'having moments of levity' -- which it does, but yeah, it's downright grisly in terms of violence.

        You're right. I guess I meant 'having moments of levity' -- which it does, but yeah, it's downright grisly in terms of violence.

        1 vote