heraplem's recent activity

  1. Comment on California Gov. Gavin Newsom commutes all 548 death sentences in ~society

    heraplem
    (edited )
    Link Parent
    Against. I intended my comment to be playful, but not sarcastic. I think it's a good thing these sentences were commuted; and, given Newsom's reputation for going where the political wind is...

    Against. I intended my comment to be playful, but not sarcastic. I think it's a good thing these sentences were commuted; and, given Newsom's reputation for going where the political wind is blowing, I think it's very possible that recent election results played a role in his decision here.

    14 votes
  2. Comment on California Gov. Gavin Newsom commutes all 548 death sentences in ~society

    heraplem
    Link
    Woke is back, baby!

    Woke is back, baby!

    5 votes
  3. Comment on Alphabet shares tumble in $500bn rout [as AI-mode search threatens advertising profits] in ~finance

    heraplem
    Link Parent
    I also don't understand why anyone would pay attention Google's AI overview answer. If I want an AI answer, I'll use a proper model, not the dinky one that Google uses for every search.

    I also don't understand why anyone would pay attention Google's AI overview answer. If I want an AI answer, I'll use a proper model, not the dinky one that Google uses for every search.

    6 votes
  4. Comment on Proton to ‘re-interview’ staff about AI to see who gets to keep their job in ~tech

    heraplem
    Link
    Email: I second the Fastmail recommendation. Coming from Gmail's bloated Web interface, Fastmail is a breath of fresh air. It looks and performs like "Web 1.0+", but it has every feature I could...
    • Email: I second the Fastmail recommendation. Coming from Gmail's bloated Web interface, Fastmail is a breath of fresh air. It looks and performs like "Web 1.0+", but it has every feature I could want from an email interface.
    • VPN: Mullvad.
    6 votes
  5. Comment on Decomp.dev in ~games

    heraplem
    (edited )
    Link Parent
    I've seen a few people suggest this, but it's hard to imagine that working when you could just feed the video to an agent and say "Reproduce this". Maybe not possible now, but I imagine it will be...

    My take is that the tech behind Stadia will have a comeback, no only for games but all proprietary software will be nothing more than streamed pixels into our screens with just the minimum logic for inputs.

    I've seen a few people suggest this, but it's hard to imagine that working when you could just feed the video to an agent and say "Reproduce this". Maybe not possible now, but I imagine it will be in a year or two.

    1 vote
  6. Comment on The state of AI video in ~tech

    heraplem
    Link
    Most people don't know that, at least in federal jury trials (and I believe that most state jurisdictions follow the same general rules here), you can't just introduce anything as evidence. You...

    How can we admit video evidence into a court of law, perhaps unless it's played directly off a recording device that's technologically incapable of having video uploaded to it?

    Most people don't know that, at least in federal jury trials (and I believe that most state jurisdictions follow the same general rules here), you can't just introduce anything as evidence. You need to lay a foundation. In particular, you need a witness who will testify that the evidence is indeed what it purports to be. This doesn't completely get rid of the problem, but it does mean that someone would have to risk perjury in order to get an AI-produced video introduced as evidence.

    3 votes
  7. Comment on The dock on Mac, from OS 10 to macOS 27 in ~comp

    heraplem
    Link Parent
    That Dock looks quite similar to the NeXTSTEP Dock, which is of course where the macOS dock comes from originally.

    That Dock looks quite similar to the NeXTSTEP Dock, which is of course where the macOS dock comes from originally.

    2 votes
  8. Comment on Solo developer rebuilds Adobe Creative Suite in Rust using Claude, releases it free to all in ~tech

    heraplem
    Link Parent
    I don't think that the devaluing of labor has ever, even once in all of history, ended well for those whose labor was devalued. I don't see how the correct prior here is anything other than "this...

    I don't think that the devaluing of labor has ever, even once in all of history, ended well for those whose labor was devalued. I don't see how the correct prior here is anything other than "this will not end well".

    16 votes
  9. Comment on The mathocalypse in ~science

    heraplem
    Link Parent
    Arguably yes, but it depends on how you use them. My understanding is that OpenAI told their agents to work out the proofs "by hand" first and then formalize the resulting proofs in Lean. I think...

    aren't these models a nearly perfect way to accidentally come up with proofs so contrived that they do stumble into proving a contradiction?

    Arguably yes, but it depends on how you use them. My understanding is that OpenAI told their agents to work out the proofs "by hand" first and then formalize the resulting proofs in Lean. I think that's much less likely to prove a contradiction than telling the agents to work out the proof in Lean and not stop until they prove the result (which they could achieve by proving a contradiction first).

    Also, maybe I should clarify what I meant by "it is possible for it to be wrong". In theory, i.e., if the logic-checker is written correctly, then it is actually impossible for it to be wrong, in the sense of "if a proof passes the logic checker, then it is a valid proof". Whenever someone finds a way to prove a contradiction, that's a bug, and it gets fixed. Eventually, it will probably get to a place where it has no such bugs.

    1 vote
  10. Comment on US Pentagon says the firing squad execution of Fort Hood shooter Nidal Malik Hasan will be livestreamed in ~society

    heraplem
    Link
    This is the first time one of the White House's performative cruelty stunts has broken through the media in a long time. They must be proud of this one.

    This is the first time one of the White House's performative cruelty stunts has broken through the media in a long time. They must be proud of this one.

    8 votes
  11. Comment on OpenAI releases findings on 377 math problems, further roiling field in ~science

    heraplem
    Link Parent
    The next frontier there is going to be software both produced and verified by AI. It's probably not worth the time and money for frontier labs to train that capability right now, but there's no...

    The next frontier there is going to be software both produced and verified by AI. It's probably not worth the time and money for frontier labs to train that capability right now, but there's no reason why they can't get there eventually.

  12. Comment on OpenAI releases findings on 377 math problems, further roiling field in ~science

    heraplem
    Link Parent
    See, I think this just isn't thinking far enough ahead. Give it a few more years, and you don't need humans to have institutional knowledge about how the code works.

    institutional knowledge over how that code actually works

    See, I think this just isn't thinking far enough ahead. Give it a few more years, and you don't need humans to have institutional knowledge about how the code works.

    1 vote
  13. Comment on The mathocalypse in ~science

    heraplem
    Link Parent
    The logic test is a small and battle-hardened piece of software whose job it is to check proofs for logical correctness. It is possible for it to be wrong. People occasionally find ways to prove...

    Who is writing the logic test, then?

    The logic test is a small and battle-hardened piece of software whose job it is to check proofs for logical correctness.

    It is possible for it to be wrong. People occasionally find ways to prove contradictions. It doesn't happen very often, and the proofs are usually pretty contrived. You are not likely to just stumble into proving a contradiction.

    1 vote
  14. Comment on OpenAI releases findings on 377 math problems, further roiling field in ~science

    heraplem
    Link Parent
    I would argue that while "programming" or "software engineering" may still exist, "coding" basically is over as a thing that humans do. There are still exceptions, it will take time for the impact...

    I would argue that while "programming" or "software engineering" may still exist, "coding" basically is over as a thing that humans do. There are still exceptions, it will take time for the impact of coding assistants to be felt evenly, etc., but having humans bang out code simply isn't economical anymore for basically any purpose.

    "Software engineering" may still exist because we still need to produce software; and, furthermore, that does still want domain expertise. Someone with prior experience as a programmer is, at least for now, going to be better at getting their LLM to do the right thing. But for high-level math, the practical utility is unclear; and when it does have practical utility, it's usually not in merely knowing whether a given theorem is true or false.

    4 votes
  15. Comment on OpenAI hacked Australia's Medicare portal in ~tech

    heraplem
    Link Parent
    In the US at least, hacking into a government computer system is a federal crime regardless of whether any damage was done.

    In the US at least, hacking into a government computer system is a federal crime regardless of whether any damage was done.

    5 votes
  16. Comment on The doomsday cult inside OpenAI in ~tech

    heraplem
    Link Parent
    I think one of the things that makes people suspicious is the simple observation that, despite all their warnings, these people continue to build the thing that they are warning about. I...

    Yea, I find it rather off putting that there is large group of people who seem rather quick to conclude that the people closest to this technology don't know it the best or can't be trusted to give observations.

    I think one of the things that makes people suspicious is the simple observation that, despite all their warnings, these people continue to build the thing that they are warning about.

    I understand that they have their reasons (including, but not limited to, uh, money), but it's very hard to convince someone that you are sincere when your actions appear to contradict your words.

    12 votes
  17. Comment on Steam recently made a fundamental change to indie game discoverability in ~games

    heraplem
    Link
    In a world where it often feels like everything keeps getting darker, Valve is a shining beacon.

    In a world where it often feels like everything keeps getting darker, Valve is a shining beacon.

    17 votes
  18. Comment on A beginning for mathematics in ~science

    heraplem
    Link
    It's about as nice a vision as you could hope for, I suppose. In a way, it sort of proposes that mathematicians should become like chess players. I did not see an answer to where the funding will...

    It's about as nice a vision as you could hope for, I suppose.

    In a way, it sort of proposes that mathematicians should become like chess players.

    I did not see an answer to where the funding will come from, though.

    2 votes
  19. Comment on [Poem] Things Artificial Intelligence Can’t Do - Aaron Belz in ~books

    heraplem
    Link Parent
    Only speaking for myself here. A better analyst than me would spend a lot of time talking about the body of the poem itself, which has nothing to do with AI. Only the title frames the poem as...

    Only speaking for myself here.

    A better analyst than me would spend a lot of time talking about the body of the poem itself, which has nothing to do with AI. Only the title frames the poem as being "about" AI. But I am a poor analyst, so ...

    I take the poem to be a combination of sincerity and irony.

    It's sincere, because these are things that AI genuinely cannot do. They are genuinely human things.

    It's ironic, because they are mostly depressing things, things that you don't really want to do.

    In asking the question "What can't AI do?" the set of "good" answers seems to be shrinking daily. So all that is left are the "bad" answers.

    6 votes
  20. Comment on How accurate have Ed Zitron's AI skeptic predictions been? in ~tech

    heraplem
    (edited )
    Link Parent
    I agree. This is why I don't call myself "anti-ai" even though I completely loathe the technology (and I'm no poser—I've hated it since the mid-2010s). You can't authentically be "anti" something...

    I agree. This is why I don't call myself "anti-ai" even though I completely loathe the technology (and I'm no poser—I've hated it since the mid-2010s). You can't authentically be "anti" something that you can't meaningfully oppose.

    1 vote