5 votes

Ask Tilde: How would you improve the ErgoDox

The ErgoDox has been out for a few years now and spawned many, many new designs based off it. My question is how would you improve it? I've been trying to answer this question for a few weeks now and would like to know what the community thinks. What is important in a keyboard for you?

I've thrown my hat into the ring with Gergo which I think comes close. It uses SMD components, reducing the overall size and cost of the board, Removes the ProMicro for a TQFP Atmega32u4, moves the paddles in a tiny bit and removes the extra keys from the thumb cluster. It's meant to be used without a case (using rubbered standoffs to keep it off the desk/surface) and the back has some pretty designs. The hardest part for me to justify was loping off the number row, but seeing as many layouts use a modifier and the right hand pad as a ortho numpad I went with it. Worst case the default layout will have paddle + top row give numbers. In addition, for occasional mouse users, I designed a trackball that fits inside of a 1u key and can be mounted on the right hand side of the board (or a regular key if wanted). The idea being for small movements you have something other then QMKs mouse keys to work with. I've gone into a bit more detail on my blog on the design considerations

The main thing I tried to optimize with Gergo was cost. Ergo keyboards need not be expensive and I think the price point on this board drives it home. With a cheap set of caps off Amazon and some Cherry clones, this board can be put together for under 100$ shipping included. Compared to a ErgoDox EZ with a starting price of 250$ before keys or shipping, I think I've done a decent job.

As keyboards are highly personal devices, what do you look for in a keyboard?

3 comments

  1. [2]
    Grendel
    Link
    I am very interested in this! I've been wanting an Ergo Dox for a while but the cost has prevented me so far. How many keys are on the thumb clusters now? Do you have a picture of the finished...

    I am very interested in this! I've been wanting an Ergo Dox for a while but the cost has prevented me so far. How many keys are on the thumb clusters now? Do you have a picture of the finished product yet?

    1 vote
    1. germ
      Link Parent
      None of the finished product yet (as I still need to send the Gerbers off to fab), but a full BOM and everything is allready put together waiting on pulling the trigger. Right now I'm trying to...

      None of the finished product yet (as I still need to send the Gerbers off to fab), but a full BOM and everything is allready put together waiting on pulling the trigger. Right now I'm trying to figure out if there's anything missing from the overall design before firing off the first run. A preorder or two would really speed that along :)

      The thumb clusters now have 3 buttons, two 2u paddles and 1 1u on the outer paddle. The other 1u had to be sacrificed in order to bring the cluster in a bit sadly. There a cad renders on the site here.

      1 vote
  2. hook
    Link
    The thumb cluster. Dactyl and ManuForm seem an improvement in that sense.

    The thumb cluster. Dactyl and ManuForm seem an improvement in that sense.

    1 vote