45 votes

Loneliness results from an isolating society, not individual failures to pursue connection

4 comments

  1. Kremor
    Link

    In a hyper-individualistic society where we’re constantly told to exercise personal responsibility, it’s not surprising that we are told to manage our emotions this way [contact a friend]. And for those who can’t self-manage, and for whom mental healthcare is either unaffordable or undesirable, there’s life coaching to pull us out of our rut.

    In the midst of what has been characterized as a “loneliness epidemic” in American society, even friendship is being commodified and outsourced to the market.

    The liberal media will instruct you to manage your emotions, and the life-coaching industry will sell you a product to help you manage your life, conservative media will focus on a different but familiar bogeyman [...] the decline of “the family.”

    When it comes to underlying structural factors that have caused changes in our “old-fashioned patterns,” the analysis stays relatively superficial [...] “wealth drives us toward solitude.” This makes loneliness seem a bit inevitable—an unfortunate side effect of human progress—and if something is seen as inevitable, how likely are you to propose major structural changes to address it?

    These problems are not individual-level problems. Changing them requires policy and political will. Simply put, we have to create an entirely different society which prioritizes human social life along with human and ecological well-being. Doing this requires ending the prioritization of private profit in our society.

    16 votes
  2. [2]
    TreeFiddyFiddy
    Link
    While the author makes some great and very valid points, their disparagement of both putting responsibility on individuals and "conservative" talking points is not well thought out. What all three...

    While the author makes some great and very valid points, their disparagement of both putting responsibility on individuals and "conservative" talking points is not well thought out. What all three camps have wrong when it comes to the loneliness epidemic is that the issue is certainly multifactorial. Loneliness emerges from societal structural issues, including degredation of family, as well as individual responsibility to get offline more and to be willing to reach out more. All sides are losing something when they don't aknowledge that it's not a one size fits all problem

    6 votes
    1. MimicSquid
      Link Parent
      Could you expand on the points you feel they handle poorly, and how your position differs? I'd like to hear your alternative take that comes from a conservative perspective if you're willing to...

      Could you expand on the points you feel they handle poorly, and how your position differs? I'd like to hear
      your alternative take that comes from a conservative perspective if you're willing to expand on your post.

      3 votes