10 votes

It's not just a bunch of flowers - Why supporting Extinction Rebellion in a spirit of cooperation and friendship has, at times, been extraordinarily difficult

4 comments

  1. DanBC
    Link
    Extinction Rebellion is holding many protests in the UK. Their tactic seems to be "get yourself arrested". That's fine, civil disobedience has a long history. But ER have neglected to tell...

    Extinction Rebellion is holding many protests in the UK. Their tactic seems to be "get yourself arrested". That's fine, civil disobedience has a long history.

    But ER have neglected to tell protestors what their rights are when arrested by police, nor how being arrested (or charged) could affect their life in the future. https://greenandblackcross.org/statement-on-extinction-rebellion-xr-why-we-can-no-longer-work-with-xr-organiser/

    This article does a nice job of explaining some of the racism within ER. It links to an excellent Gal Dem article: http://gal-dem.com/extinction-rebellion-risk-trampling-climate-justice-movement/

    I support ER, but I wish they weren't so fucking clueless about some of this stuff.

    (I didn't know what group to put this in. Sorry.)

    4 votes
  2. [3]
    cfabbro
    Link
    Meta: The headline alone is pretty sparse and not very descriptive of the contents of this article, so I added the subheading to it as well. Please let me know what you think of the change.

    Meta: The headline alone is pretty sparse and not very descriptive of the contents of this article, so I added the subheading to it as well. Please let me know what you think of the change.

    4 votes
    1. [2]
      DanBC
      Link Parent
      I always welcome any changes. They help me understand what is good for Tildes, and I'm happy to change my style to fit what works here rather than continue to impose style choices I learned...

      I always welcome any changes. They help me understand what is good for Tildes, and I'm happy to change my style to fit what works here rather than continue to impose style choices I learned elsewhere. Especially when those choices are things I think are sub-optimal such as "use the original title".

      3 votes
      1. cfabbro
        (edited )
        Link Parent
        Yeah, one of my least favorite aspects of Hacker News is their rigid adherence to the "original title" rule, since context is often lost because of that, and clickbait is often left untouched. I...

        Yeah, one of my least favorite aspects of Hacker News is their rigid adherence to the "original title" rule, since context is often lost because of that, and clickbait is often left untouched. I much prefer how things are shaping up on Tildes where OPs and users with the "edit title" privilege can change the titles, they just have to try to make any changes as objective and informative as they can.

        2 votes