18 votes

Country music’s culture wars and the remaking of Nashville

4 comments

  1. [3]
    HEBV5
    (edited )
    Link
    Solid article and appreciate how holistically it approaches the weird politics around country music. I can't speak much for Nashville (I live in Chicago), but as someone that plays locally what...
    • Exemplary

    Solid article and appreciate how holistically it approaches the weird politics around country music. I can't speak much for Nashville (I live in Chicago), but as someone that plays locally what the article and industry call "Americana," I have to mirror the awkwardness in defining what music can "belong." Whenever I interact with somebody not in the scene, I find myself struggling (and probably failing) to explain what old-time is or that bluegrass only really came around in the 1950s. That "musical redlining" and the resulting segregation of demographics that continues to manifest in algorithms is particularly troubling--I'm a pretty progressive fan of the genre and had never heard of many artists mentioned in the article!

    Will be checking out Adeem the Artist and others found within, but some recommendations for others that are interested in the non-Nashville scene:

    • Nick Shoulders is a phenomenal yodeler from Arkansas that performs in New Orleans. Thoughtful lyrics that are openly political with the occasional bit of education, plus fun covers (like Blondie's "Heart of Glass").
    • Defunct Carolina Chocolate Drops is a supergroup of black artists wanting to reclaim and recenter black identity within old American-style music. Some solid arrangements and they've won a Grammy for their work. Highly recommend finding YouTube clips of their live performances.
    • Rhiannon Giddens (of the CCDs), has her own solo career that has taken off. She's decently popular/commercially viable and has been nominated for and won tons of awards, including multiple Grammies.
    • Dom Flemons, also of the Drops and styled as "The American Songster," is a great multi-instrumentalist with a greater focus on the cultural/historic preservation. He's worked with museums and the Library of Congress and I adore his album Black Cowboys, which got a Grammy nomination.
    • Sierra Ferrell dabbles in a several different genres and is often country/folk-adjacent, but is generally spectacular. Solid stage presence, with a striking, heavily-tattooed appearance. (Though this may be cheating; I think she may actually be based in Nashville.)

    There are many more nationwide and there are YouTube channels specifically to corral and promote these smaller artists. Gems on VHS and Western AF are personal favorites for discovering new folk folx.
    [Edit: formatting, grammar]

    9 votes
    1. cfabbro
      (edited )
      Link Parent
      I'll throw some of my recommendations in the pile too, in case people want more to listen to. I mostly listen to Indie/Singer-Songwriter/Contemporary Folk, Bluegrass/Newgrass, Southern Rock and...

      some recommendations for others that are interested in the non-Nashville scene

      I'll throw some of my recommendations in the pile too, in case people want more to listen to. I mostly listen to Indie/Singer-Songwriter/Contemporary Folk, Bluegrass/Newgrass, Southern Rock and Alt/Progressive Country... and I mostly listen to Live music too. So my recommendations will be mostly limited to those genres. But with that said, here are some of my favorites (from an old comment of mine):

      William Elliott Whitmore - Hell Or High Water (Live on KEXP)
      Nickel Creek: NPR Music Tiny Desk Concert
      The Civil Wars - You Are My Sunshine (Live) (that whole concert is amazing!)
      Watkins Family Hour: NPR Music Tiny Desk Concert (ft. Fiona Apple)
      Shawn James // American Hearts (A. A. Bondy) | Wolf Sanctuary
      Joseph: NPR Music Tiny Desk Concert
      The Marcus King Band - "Where I'm Headed" (Live at JITVHQ in Los Angeles, CA 2018
      Miley Cyrus - The Backyard Sessions - "Jolene"
      The Oh Hellos: NPR Music Tiny Desk Concert
      Kaia Kater: NPR Music Tiny Desk Concert
      Ed Sheeran - Masters of War (Bob Dylan Acoustic Cover)
      Joan Shelley: NPR Music Tiny Desk Concert
      Sufjan Stevens - For The Widows In Paradise, For The Fatherless In Ypsilanti
      Punch Brothers: NPR Music Tiny Desk Concert
      Brother Bird - Landslide | OurVinyl Sessions
      First Aid Kit - Tiger Mountain Peasant Song (Fleet Foxes Cover)
      And speaking of Fleet Foxes, their self-titled Album is absolutely fantastic, I highly recommend it!
      Johnny Cash - Hurt (Good Audio - HQ- High Quality)
      You can't go wrong with Johnny Cash either.
      Toledo - Knot | Sofar Boston
      Listener - Wooden Heart
      Jade Bird - "Uh Huh" | Black Box Sessions
      Ray Lamontagne - Crazy (Gnarls Barkley Cover)
      Haley Bonar: NPR Music Tiny Desk Concert
      Andy McKee - Guitar - Drifting - www.candyrat.com
      Shakey Graves - "Climb on the Cross" | Black Box Sessions
      The Secret Sisters: NPR Music Tiny Desk Concert

      And a few ones that I have submitted to Tildes too:
      Old Salt Union - Here & Off My Mind (Jam In The Van - Live at Huck Finn Jubilee)
      The Cleverly's cover Red Hot Chili Peppers "By the Way" (Jam In The Van - Live at Huck Finn Jubilee 2018)
      Basia Bulat - Heart of My Own (album)<-- Canadian Folk <3 Basia

      That should be enough to get you started hopefully. ;)

      I wholeheartedly second the recommendations of Gems on VHS and Western AF. Both great channels. Jam in the Van has a lot of great Americana, Southern Rock, Bluegrass, etc stuff too.

      4 votes
    2. monarda
      Link Parent
      Wow, Carolina Chocolate Drops are freaking amazing. Loving the rhythm in Snowden's jig. Thank you for a new band to explore!

      Wow, Carolina Chocolate Drops are freaking amazing. Loving the rhythm in Snowden's jig. Thank you for a new band to explore!

      2 votes