23 votes

Harmony

Harmony does something to my brain than I can't explain but it's like a short cut to, well, I dunno, but something good.

I'd really like your suggestions for harmonies that create emotional response.

Sorry for dumping a huge number of links here. Here are two favourites:

Picforth, In Nomine a 5.

and

Cork Sacred Harp - "47b Idumea"

Here are some examples: (and now that I post them, I realise some of them aren't really harmony proper, so I'm not sure what I'm asking for)

Irish lilting in harmony

Beloe Zlato - "За тихой рекою" (beyond the calm river?), and a better but more noisy version Белое злато - "За тихой рекой" (Белое злато / Beloe Zlato / White Gold -- I don't know anything about this group and if I'm posting Russian propaganda please let me know because I don't want to be doing that)

Mamas and Papas - "California dreaming", "Here in my arms" (although Ella Fitzgerald's version is much much better), "Safe in my garden" (especially the bit around 1:50 building to 2:15)

Sacred Harp choirs. Sacred harp and "shaped singing" is how you teach people to sing if they can't read music. [https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shape_note](Wikipedia has a good explainer). They start with a verse of the soh, lah, ti, fah sounds so people know the tune and rhythm and then they launch into it. I'm not religious (in a quiet, polite, respecting other people's religions kind of way) but they turn out a great tune sometimes. Henderson, Texas - Sacred Harp 463: "Angel Band", Austin, Texas - Sacred Harp 463: "Angel Band", Unknown - scacred harp 463: "Angel band". Camp Doremi Europe 2015 - Sacred Harp 117 "Angel Band". I've dumped four of the same song so you get a feel for differences in pace, in size of congregation, and skill of singers. The acoustics of these rooms suck, and even skilled professional sound engineers are going to struggle to mic up these rooms and get good output, but I like the fact that every consumer grade mic and recording equipment is just OVERLOADED TO ALL HECK.

More sacred harp. Texas - Sacred Harp 505 "Cleansing Fountain". The lyrics are really something.

Irish sacred harp, and this is the one I really want to share because my word they mean it: Second Ireland Sacred Harp Convention - "47b Idumea" there's a woman really singing. I love love love this. There's also Cork Sacred Harp - "Come thou fount"

It's not just vocal harmony either. Lankum, NPR Tiny Desk Concert, "The Wild Rover" just builds and builds layer upon layer. (And "Bear Creek" does something similar, with more joy. The Mary Wallopers - "Frost is all over" have something going on underneath this romping joyful noise and I think it's the sneaky "Banish Misfortune", so here's a version of that Sorcha Ni Scolai - "Banish Misfortune" and it's all amazing but there's a tiny bit at 1:19-1:25 that gets right into my brain.

Sometimes it's just a big crowd. From a comment by @jgb I found this Welsh National Anthem just before Wales beat England. Here's a Welsh flash mob Cor Meibion Male Voice Choir - "Bread of Heaven"

And I think it's not just "harmony" proper that I'm thinking of. A bit of nice tune in the middle of near chaotic noise is nice. So, for an example, listen to all of this The Incredible String Band - "The Mad Hatter's Song" and stick with it, because at 3:40 they suddenly drop into this very short, but very sweet bit of nice tune. And that "I am the archer, the lover of laughter, and mine is the arrowed flight; I am the archer and my eyes yearn after the unsullied sight" is lovely.

I'm listening to a bunch of music from the 1500s, and especially In Nomine. The strings sliding all over the place is amazing to me. In Nomine À 5, "Seldome Sene" · Christopher Tye · Jordi Savall, In Nomine À 5, "Rachells Weepinge" · Christopher Tye · Jordi Savall, In Nomine IV A 6 (Strogers) · Hespèrion XX · Jordi Savall, Youtube have given this weird artwork Picforth, In Nomine a 5.

12 comments

  1. [2]
    toshi
    Link
    Sing! Day of song - Bobby McFerrin - Improvisation - A large crowd provides accompaniment for one of the finest vocal masters of popular music. Jacob Collier Harmonises The Audience [Toronto] -...

    Sing! Day of song - Bobby McFerrin - Improvisation - A large crowd provides accompaniment for one of the finest vocal masters of popular music.
    Jacob Collier Harmonises The Audience [Toronto] - Collier takes this idea further by harmonizing the crowd in 3 parts. Simple, but large scale and spontaneous.
    Jacob Collier - Moon River - 4725 part harmony /hyp
    Lizzy McAlpine: Tiny Desk Concert - The backing band here, Tiny Habits, has some of the tightest harmonies I've ever heard in popular music. Lots more available on Youtube etc.
    Choral - Solo accordion, but lush chords and amazing gravitas. The ultimate track of a superb album.
    Ryuichi Sakamoto - "andata" (from "async") - Another instrumental track, gravitas out the nose here.
    MICROTONAL TETRIS - Magical harmonies and modulations that you may not have experienced before.
    Vicentino: Madonna il poco dolce - Speaking of microtonal music, Vicentino's microtonal works may be of interest if you like Renaissance music.

    Try these on for size, I'm curious which ones align with your request.

    2 votes
    1. DanBC
      Link Parent
      The crowd work from McFerrin and Collier is amazing. I've seen that Jacob Collier video before but it's always impressive. I love NPR's tiny desk concerts but for some reason I keep dropping them...

      The crowd work from McFerrin and Collier is amazing. I've seen that Jacob Collier video before but it's always impressive.

      I love NPR's tiny desk concerts but for some reason I keep dropping them off my viewing. That's clearly a mistake, because Lizzy McAlpine and Tiny Habits are fantastic. I loved this.

      I hadn't heard of Ryuichi Sakamoto before at all, and I really enjoyed this piece - I like the slow builds and sweeps.

      Microtonal tetris was delightful and tickled my brain!!

      I loved the Vicentino - it's a bit of a challenge, but I'm up for that.

      Thank you so much for the suggestions!

  2. [3]
    ken_cleanairsystems
    Link
    Following on from toshi's post, here's a little variety of things: Thomas Tallis - Spem in Alium -- from the Renaissance period, a choral piece written for 40 voices. This is just a single...

    Following on from toshi's post, here's a little variety of things:

    I'd love to know if you like any of these!

    2 votes
    1. [2]
      DanBC
      Link Parent
      I love the Schumann, and I hadn't heard it before so thank you for that. The Rachmaninoff is beautiful - I'd love to hear more about singing and recording!! I know about Tallis and I'm slowly...

      I love the Schumann, and I hadn't heard it before so thank you for that.

      The Rachmaninoff is beautiful - I'd love to hear more about singing and recording!!

      I know about Tallis and I'm slowly slowly building more knowledge and exposure. The piece you linked is amazing though, thank you!

      I've now got lots to build on from your post.

      1 vote
      1. ken_cleanairsystems
        Link Parent
        I glad to hear that! If you want to hear more Russian early-modern sacred music, there are a number of arrangements of the "All-Night Vigil" that are worth listening to (IMO). The Rachmaninoff I...

        I glad to hear that!

        If you want to hear more Russian early-modern sacred music, there are a number of arrangements of the "All-Night Vigil" that are worth listening to (IMO). The Rachmaninoff I linked above is an excerpt from his setting, and Tchaikovsky has a famous one, too. Then there are settings by less famous composers like Kastalsky, Chesnokov, and Grechaninov. Out of those, I'm probably most familiar with Rachmaninoff's and Kastalsky's.

        1 vote
  3. [2]
    nosewings
    Link
    Some pop examples that come to mind just off the top of my head: Bon Iver's album 22, A Million is awash in vocal harmonies. "22 Over Soon" and "715 Creeks" are probably the most striking...

    Some pop examples that come to mind just off the top of my head:

    • Bon Iver's album 22, A Million is awash in vocal harmonies. "22 Over Soon" and "715 Creeks" are probably the most striking examples.
    • Of Montreal's Gronlandic Edit uses harmony excellently as a dramatic device.
    • Mother Falcon's cover of Radiohead's Lucky.
    2 votes
    1. DanBC
      Link Parent
      I've heard of Bon Iver but not listened to any of it. I really like it! There's a teeny tiny hint of Lali Puna - 6 0 3 but I can't quite put my finger on why it triggers that for me. (I think...

      I've heard of Bon Iver but not listened to any of it. I really like it! There's a teeny tiny hint of Lali Puna - 6 0 3 but I can't quite put my finger on why it triggers that for me. (I think maybe gentle glitching?)

      I enjoyed Mother Falcon, they're a new band on my list now, thank you!

      1 vote
  4. [3]
    Akir
    Link
    Most of the music I listen to features harmony, and there are quite a few choral tracks in there too. Rather than list a bunch of them, I’ll recommend one The Beginning and the End. There is a...

    Most of the music I listen to features harmony, and there are quite a few choral tracks in there too. Rather than list a bunch of them, I’ll recommend one The Beginning and the End.

    There is a certain degree of imperfection to the song that I have a hard time articulating; it’s almost as if some of the notes are off timing or pitch. But that is precisely the thing that makes the song so powerful. It’s just so incredibly human. It’s quite literally the only choral recording I’ve ever heard that does this. As a side effect if you are listening to it alongside all of these others you will probably not quite get it. But when you are able to listen to it on its own terms it will move you.

    2 votes
    1. [2]
      DanBC
      Link Parent
      I like it! It reminds me a little bit of Les Mystere des Voix Bulgares. Here's an enthusiastic reaction video, and here's a playlist

      I like it! It reminds me a little bit of Les Mystere des Voix Bulgares.

      Here's an enthusiastic reaction video, and here's a playlist

      1 vote
      1. Akir
        Link Parent
        I don’t have any of their albums but I have heard of them before. I wouldn’t be surprised if this was them but I never found complete credits on this soundtrack. They also did the chorus on the...

        I don’t have any of their albums but I have heard of them before. I wouldn’t be surprised if this was them but I never found complete credits on this soundtrack.

        They also did the chorus on the soundtrack for Alone in the Dark - yes, the bad one, and one of my favorite games unironically. I swear at one time I had a different mix of the soundtrack that better showcased their voices, but I can’t find it. The official soundtrack release is something of an arrangement as there isn’t really discrete tracks in the game; the music is dynamic and reacts to what’s happening, something Olivier Derivier specializes in. In any case this is my personal favorite so far as I can find.

        1 vote
  5. granfdad
    Link
    There's one song that immediately comes to mind when I hear the phrase "harmonies that create emotional response", Veil of Oblivion by Erang. It's an incredibly simple track, 2 synths - only one...

    There's one song that immediately comes to mind when I hear the phrase "harmonies that create emotional response", Veil of Oblivion by Erang.

    It's an incredibly simple track, 2 synths - only one at a time - and some sound effects. It's basically carried by the way the sound design and story interacts with the harmony (which is perhaps not what you're asking for, but I think it still counts). The harmony is almost a lullaby, mostly warm and comforting, but there's an atmosphere of longing as the progression... progresses. That longing is basically forced into the limelight by the sound design, a muted bass robs you of any warmth that the harmony could provide, and the remaining airiness takes over. The tone of the harmony is completely different when using the synth it does compared to if it had been played with a violin or some deeper instrument. The track isn't only cold, (to me) it embodies the feeling of becoming cold (I don't mean this in a metaphorical sense, I literally mean temperature-wise).

    Then the two switch places. In the last minute of the song the second synth kicks in, basically the exact opposite of the first - bassy and muffled, the reverb further filling out the lows. It would be warm if it weren't for the harmony, which refuses to resolve, instead fading out without providing any relief. There's not a single moment of peace across the whole 4:05, despite it being almost within grasp.

    The album art and title (Another World, Another Time) also paint a pretty good picture of the tone of the track, along with the context for the rest of the album. The first track in the album has an accompanying poem:

    There are ages that left the memories of men
    
    
    Like a timeworn stone under the rain.
    
    
    And amongst them, one is lost forever: Far as the oldest stars, its light has gone out of our world…
    

    Veil of Oblivion so perfectly captures the apocalyptic yearning that I'm basically forced to stop and listen with all my focus anytime it comes on.

    This just turned into me rambling about one of my favorite songs, but it really was the immediate thing I thought of when I read your post, so I hope this has at least somewhat contributed to your curiosity :)

    1 vote