9 votes

Forget technocrats - let's get some realitycrats

3 comments

  1. [2]
    skybrian
    Link
    Ironically, it seems rather dogmatic? I see a lot of statements about what worked and what should be done that are unsupported. Our knowledge of reality comes from evidence, but you won't find it...

    Ironically, it seems rather dogmatic? I see a lot of statements about what worked and what should be done that are unsupported. Our knowledge of reality comes from evidence, but you won't find it here.

    13 votes
    1. fuzzy
      Link Parent
      It seems like all that matters these days is if something feels true.

      It seems like all that matters these days is if something feels true.

      11 votes
  2. Tum
    (edited )
    Link
    I disagree: opening up the Italian Rail System to private competition has been a success. The formula seems to be: the state owns and maintains the lines, but there is open competition between...

    Trains aren't well suited to competitive pressures.

    I disagree: opening up the Italian Rail System to private competition has been a success. The formula seems to be: the state owns and maintains the lines, but there is open competition between operators; who each have the same base cost, so innovate to drive down prices and improve customer experience. This has led to lower fairs and more frequent trains, all while the operators also turn a profit.

    The choice isn't simply public or private; it's a regulated market, where state ownership of the underlying infrastructure provides a level playing field for operators to compete on.

    5 votes