53 votes

Western Digital refused to answer our questions about its self-wiping SanDisk SSDs. Oh, and it’s also getting sued.

7 comments

  1. Wolf_359
    (edited )
    Link
    It sounds to me like they're reviewing what went wrong. But man, their PR person didn't do great with that response. And they're making a mistake by continuing to sell these right now. I have...

    It sounds to me like they're reviewing what went wrong. But man, their PR person didn't do great with that response. And they're making a mistake by continuing to sell these right now.

    I have noticed that companies who seem to escape these situations are the ones who communicate clearly and avoid corporate speak. They write a nice, detailed blog post apologizing, explaining the exact issue, and then explaining how and when they're going to make it right.

    If they don't know the details, they say very bluntly, "we don't know what the problem is yet, but we are looking into it and we will share everything we know once we find out. In the meantime, we have pulled this product and are coming up with a plan to make this right for our customers."

    They don't make excuses and, I'll stress this again, they avoid the vague, corporate speak. Everyone hates that shit.

    The Baldur's Gate 3 team recently did a great job explaining their screw up to the public, if you want an example of what I'm talking about.

    10 votes
  2. WiseassWolfOfYoitsu
    Link
    To make it worse, this isn't even the first catastrophic firmware bug SanDisk has had in the last few years. They had one with enterprise SAS SSDs a few years back where they'd self brick at...

    To make it worse, this isn't even the first catastrophic firmware bug SanDisk has had in the last few years. They had one with enterprise SAS SSDs a few years back where they'd self brick at around 40k hours - https://www.thestack.technology/ssd-death-bug-40000-hours-sandisk/

    6 votes
  3. [5]
    RustyRedRobot
    Link
    SanDisk is/was my "go to" for micro SDs. I'm assuming that they are still good, but I'll probably need to look to another brand now. Any suggestions as to the current champs in the micro SD and...

    SanDisk is/was my "go to" for micro SDs. I'm assuming that they are still good, but I'll probably need to look to another brand now.

    Any suggestions as to the current champs in the micro SD and SSD worlds?

    4 votes
    1. [2]
      blueshiftlabs
      Link Parent
      Samsung would be your best bet IMO.

      Samsung would be your best bet IMO.

      12 votes
      1. vuzzar
        Link Parent
        I have been using Samsung SSDs for over 10 years now (starting with the 840 Pro). They've never let me down - or anyone I know for that matter. Paying a slight premium is definitely worth it for...

        I have been using Samsung SSDs for over 10 years now (starting with the 840 Pro). They've never let me down - or anyone I know for that matter. Paying a slight premium is definitely worth it for the reliability.

        7 votes
    2. Nihilego
      Link Parent
      I like Kingston and PNY myself.

      I like Kingston and PNY myself.

      1 vote
    3. moistfeet
      Link Parent
      Sk Hynix is a pretty good option too, but I don’t know if they make flash drives. I work in a datacenter, and we use their products a lot, along with Samsung and micron.

      Sk Hynix is a pretty good option too, but I don’t know if they make flash drives. I work in a datacenter, and we use their products a lot, along with Samsung and micron.

      1 vote