7 votes

Using NLP to detect mental health crises

3 comments

  1. DanBC
    Link
    I work in patient safety and suicide prevention and people always mangle the statistics. This coincides with the WHO effort to reduce deaths by suicide, and that programme includes a lot of work...

    I work in patient safety and suicide prevention and people always mangle the statistics.

    Between 2000–2020, rates of suicide increased worldwide1

    This coincides with the WHO effort to reduce deaths by suicide, and that programme includes a lot of work to improve the data. Are more people dying by suicide, or are more countries counting deaths better? The article cites this WHO report: Suicide World Wide in 2019

    That document says this:

    As with previous revisions of WHO Global Health
    Estimates, the entire time series from the year
    2000 were revised, including for suicide. Because
    the estimates for the years 2000–2019 draw on
    new data and on the results of the GBD2019
    study, and because there have been substantial
    revisions to the methods used, these estimates
    are not comparable with previous estimates for
    2000–2016 or with earlier revisions published by
    WHO. Therefore, suicide estimates in this booklet
    supersede suicide estimates previously published
    by WHO, and differences between published
    revisions should not be interpreted as time trends.6
    Rather, to identify time trends in WHO Global
    Health Estimates, including suicide, one should
    look at the latest published revision of WHO Global
    Health Estimates (Figure 10).

    And in figure 10 it says this:

    In the 20 years between 2000 and 2019, the global age-standardized suicide rate decreased by 36%, with
    decreases ranging from 17% in the Eastern Mediterranean Region to 47% in the European Region and
    49% in the Western Pacific Region (Figure 10). The only increase in age-standardized suicide rates was
    in the Region of the Americas, reaching 17% in the same time-period. The global rate also decreased for
    age-group specific rates.

    With regard to the SDGs, a global acceleration of the decrease in the suicide mortality rate is needed to
    reach the global target of a one-third reduction by 2030 that countries have committed to

    I'm not sure how a WHO document saying "the global age-standardized suicide rate decreased by 36%" is compatible with the article's claim of "Between 2000–2020, rates of suicide increased worldwide".

    The tech looks interesting, but I'll note that previous attempts to create risk ratings for suicidality have been so bad the UK NICE (looks at evidence bases for medical interventions) lists it as a "Do not use". (I understand these are very different types of tool.)

    NICE - Self-Harm: assessment, management and preventing recurrence - 1.6 Risk assessment tools and scales

    8 votes
  2. sparksbet
    Link
    This is super cool. It's a relief to see NLP being used in this domain in a way that is helps competent human operators rather than replaces them, and from my quick look at the journal article it...

    This is super cool. It's a relief to see NLP being used in this domain in a way that is helps competent human operators rather than replaces them, and from my quick look at the journal article it seems like they put the amount of thought into how they defined and labelled their classes that it deserves given such a domain.

    4 votes