16 votes

If an album isn't streaming online, does it really exist?

23 comments

  1. [4]
    joplin
    Link
    I hit this with an old song recently. Couldn't find it on any service. Bought the entire CD for $3 (and probably $7 shipping or something whack like that) used on Amazon. There are a few movies...

    I hit this with an old song recently. Couldn't find it on any service. Bought the entire CD for $3 (and probably $7 shipping or something whack like that) used on Amazon. There are a few movies that seem to be unavailable for streaming as well. It's a bummer.

    8 votes
    1. [2]
      kayelcio
      Link Parent
      There's always discogs too

      There's always discogs too

      2 votes
      1. joplin
        Link Parent
        Oh yeah! I always forget about them. Thanks for the reminder.

        Oh yeah! I always forget about them. Thanks for the reminder.

        1 vote
    2. cfabbro
      Link Parent
      Similar to discogs, I have used MusicStack to buy old, out of print/hard to find music before too.

      Similar to discogs, I have used MusicStack to buy old, out of print/hard to find music before too.

      2 votes
  2. [15]
    jgb
    Link
    If you have no qualms about piracy (which, if you're in the habit of streaming, you probably shouldn't) and a little internet nous then it's not to hard to find almost all but the most obscure...

    If you have no qualms about piracy (which, if you're in the habit of streaming, you probably shouldn't) and a little internet nous then it's not to hard to find almost all but the most obscure stuff available for download somewhere, even without having an invite to the exclusive private trackers.

    7 votes
    1. [2]
      onyxleopard
      Link Parent
      Yeah, I’m really grateful for all the data hoarders out there who seed all kinds of content that would otherwise be inaccessible for no other reason than that rent-seekers aren’t aware of it, or...

      Yeah, I’m really grateful for all the data hoarders out there who seed all kinds of content that would otherwise be inaccessible for no other reason than that rent-seekers aren’t aware of it, or failed to negotiate the rights to resell it. I pay a few subscriptions for music and movies, but it’s nice to know if those streaming libraries are incomplete, I have alternatives (and they’re not even that much less convenient).

      7 votes
      1. wundumguy
        Link Parent
        I never had access to what.cd (or was it oink?) but I lamented its loss when I learned that they had nearly EVERYTHING on there. Unbuyable live show recordings, unreleased studio samples, etc

        I never had access to what.cd (or was it oink?) but I lamented its loss when I learned that they had nearly EVERYTHING on there. Unbuyable live show recordings, unreleased studio samples, etc

        3 votes
    2. [12]
      culturedleftfoot
      Link Parent
      Even that is a lot more difficult than it used to be. A good proportion of my favorite music (which is not that obscure, just not mainstream in the US/Europe) was originally released on vinyl and...

      Even that is a lot more difficult than it used to be. A good proportion of my favorite music (which is not that obscure, just not mainstream in the US/Europe) was originally released on vinyl and hasn't seen any digital release at all. It used to be that much of it was available on YouTube through people uploading their collections, but as channels collected copyright strikes a lot of historically significant stuff got taken down as collateral damage, and I know more than a few uploaders who just never bothered to invest their time into sharing their stash elsewhere. Their respective online scenes feel incomplete as they move on without them.

      7 votes
      1. [11]
        tomf
        Link Parent
        Do you have an example of the obscure stuff you're looking for? I like a good treasure hunt. :) I listen to a lot of 'exotica' and related genres.

        Do you have an example of the obscure stuff you're looking for? I like a good treasure hunt. :) I listen to a lot of 'exotica' and related genres.

        2 votes
        1. [10]
          culturedleftfoot
          Link Parent
          Do you mean genre-wise or the actual songs? Some of the genres I meant include zouk, highlife, reggae, big beat, calypso, and MPB. This is the first I've heard of exotica and I'm not sure how well...

          Do you mean genre-wise or the actual songs? Some of the genres I meant include zouk, highlife, reggae, big beat, calypso, and MPB. This is the first I've heard of exotica and I'm not sure how well you'll find that fits with those. For the songs, I don't have many great examples off the top of my head... some of it is specific edits/mixes of otherwise available music though. I have a list saved on my desktop PC but I haven't checked it in a couple years.

          I imagine a lot of pre-90s releases from smaller, indie music labels in more mainstream genres are at risk too - underground house, hip-hop, metal, jungle, etc. Even besides those, stuff like mixtapes are unlikely to ever be available on DSPs because they're gray market.

          2 votes
          1. [7]
            tomf
            Link Parent
            actual albums would be best for the hunt. I'm talking about piracy / trading groups, though. A lot of what you mentioned is sometimes lumped into exotica, but typically exotica is attributed to...

            actual albums would be best for the hunt. I'm talking about piracy / trading groups, though.

            A lot of what you mentioned is sometimes lumped into exotica, but typically exotica is attributed to Denny Martin and such.

            Anyway, I love trying to find hard to find things on the ol' internet. If you've got a list, I'll see what I can track down.

            1 vote
            1. [6]
              culturedleftfoot
              Link Parent
              It'd be singles rather than albums, though I would like to get Spragga Benz's unreleased Thug Nature Vol. 2 again. My desktop's in storage, so if I think up anything I'll let you know. Reminds me...

              It'd be singles rather than albums, though I would like to get Spragga Benz's unreleased Thug Nature Vol. 2 again. My desktop's in storage, so if I think up anything I'll let you know.

              A lot of what you mentioned is sometimes lumped into exotica

              Reminds me of 'world music'. If the descriptions I'm reading online are accurate, it might have been somewhat adjacent to those genres in its day but I'm skeptical that notion has much relevance now.

              1 vote
              1. tomf
                Link Parent
                So, while most sites don't have stuff like this -- Soulseek definitely does. It's not the best platform, but it's excellent for a last resort. Typical exotica is from the 50s - 60s -- at least the...

                So, while most sites don't have stuff like this -- Soulseek definitely does. It's not the best platform, but it's excellent for a last resort.

                Typical exotica is from the 50s - 60s -- at least the really good stuff. There are some great stations for this sort of thing, https://luxuriamusic.com being pretty much the best.

                1 vote
              2. [4]
                Parliament
                Link Parent
                Anything else from Spragga Benz? I see some stuff on my main tracker, and I know him from his work with Easy Star All-Stars.

                Anything else from Spragga Benz? I see some stuff on my main tracker, and I know him from his work with Easy Star All-Stars.

                1. [3]
                  culturedleftfoot
                  Link Parent
                  Do you mean recommendations or stuff I'm looking for?

                  Do you mean recommendations or stuff I'm looking for?

                  1. [2]
                    Parliament
                    Link Parent
                    Stuff you're looking for.

                    Stuff you're looking for.

                    1. culturedleftfoot
                      Link Parent
                      Nothing I can think of, but thanks for the offer!

                      Nothing I can think of, but thanks for the offer!

          2. [2]
            nobody
            Link Parent
            Maybe a dumb question but, did you try with Soulseek?

            Maybe a dumb question but, did you try with Soulseek?

            1. culturedleftfoot
              Link Parent
              Not in years; the list I mentioned is largely auto-search queries left over from there. I was last active around the time QT was introduced and it seemed like the community fractured. Before that,...

              Not in years; the list I mentioned is largely auto-search queries left over from there. I was last active around the time QT was introduced and it seemed like the community fractured. Before that, it was definitely easier to come across those gems, but even back then it seemed like some stuff had started disappearing.

              1 vote
  3. [3]
    JXM
    Link
    For anyone interested in hearing more about the issues with De La Soul's albums and getting them on streaming services, I highly recommend this recent episode of the podcast What Had Happened Was...

    For anyone interested in hearing more about the issues with De La Soul's albums and getting them on streaming services, I highly recommend this recent episode of the podcast What Had Happened Was where Prince Paul and Open Mike Eagle talk about Paul's work with the band.

    (It's also just a great podcast in general)

    4 votes
    1. [2]
      culturedleftfoot
      Link Parent
      Had no idea Prince Paul was doing a podcast, that's a definite must-listen. Thanks!

      Had no idea Prince Paul was doing a podcast, that's a definite must-listen. Thanks!

      1 vote
      1. JXM
        Link Parent
        It's still relatively new but if you know who Prince Paul is, I feel like you'll really love it.

        It's still relatively new but if you know who Prince Paul is, I feel like you'll really love it.

        1 vote
  4. Micycle_the_Bichael
    Link
    I regularly have issues with Tidal/Spotify not having songs I want to listen to on their services so to me it doesn't really matter if they're online or not because I'm pretty use to needing to...

    I regularly have issues with Tidal/Spotify not having songs I want to listen to on their services so to me it doesn't really matter if they're online or not because I'm pretty use to needing to buy the CD anyway. That said, Spotify and Bandcamp both have really upped the amount of music you can find on them so it seems to be less and less of an issue.

    1 vote