12
votes
Race report: 'UK not deliberately rigged against ethnic minorities'
Link information
This data is scraped automatically and may be incorrect.
- Title
- Race and racism 'less important in explaining social disparities' - report
- Published
- Mar 31 2021
- Word count
- 767 words
Here's the report. https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/974507/20210331_-_CRED_Report_-_FINAL_-_Web_Accessible.pdf
It is fucking infuriating.
Across any metric black people do worse in healthcare.
That's as patients - black women are 4 times more likely than white women to die in pregnancy or childbirth; black men are less likely to be in less intensive MH services but much more likely to be detained under the Mental Health Act, to be detained under the forensic sections of the act, to be on a community treatment order, or to be subjected to restraint and rapid tranquilisation. When we look at restraint we see an over representation of black men being restrained in a face down ("supine") position, or in a face up but on the floor ("prone") position and an under-representation in "guiding hand" restraint.
It's also as staff. There is an under-representation of black people in very senior leadership positions. When we look at healthcare professionals other than doctors we see a higher percentage of black staff at band 5 (entry level for a registered nurse) and lower percentage of black staff as we go up the bandings (ie, more senior positions).
When we look at complaints handling we see black staff are more likely to have a complaint made about them; are more likely to have this complaint upheld; are more likely to have complaint and concerns referred to a professional regulator; are more likely to undergo regulatory action; and are more likely to be suspended and erased from the register.
This often leads to mistakes and large payouts. See eg this man who was defending himself against a racist abuse: https://www.doughtystreet.co.uk/news/david-stephenson-secures-ps1m-payout-victim-racial-bias
The current UK government has lurched to the right. It's really worrying.
Luckily most NHS organisations will ignore this report, and instead focus on NHS WRES (NHS Workforce Race Equality Standard). https://www.england.nhs.uk/about/equality/equality-hub/equality-standard/
(Lots of edits, sorry).
If anyone can explain this without 1) using institutional racism (because this stupid report says that doesn't exist) and 2) without being massively racist I'd love to see it.
I mean, for fucks sake.
Here they're saying that Black people are more likely to be criminals and so they're more likely to be stopped and searched.
They've avoided the obvious explanation that disproportionate policing of certain populations will turn up more crime in that population, and lack of policing in other populations will ignore crime in that population.
Or, more simply -
Us: "the criminal justice system is institutionally racist"
Them: "these statistics, that we gathered from that system, shows it isn't".
Here's a comment from NHS Providers. https://twitter.com/NHSProviders/status/1377253543514681349
"Within the largest employer in the country – the #NHS – there is clear and unmistakable evidence that staff from ethnic minorities have worse experiences at work and face more barriers in progressing their careers than their white counterparts."
"While some progress has been made, to pretend that discrimination does not exist is damaging as is denying the link between structural racism and wider health inequalities."
A government-commissioned report has found that:
I'll update this comment with a link when the report is properly released
As is tradition, the Beeb have updated the headline. Is anyone able to edit it?
Race report: 'UK not deliberately rigged against ethnic minorities'
"deliberately" is doing a lot of work in that headline
Well, that seems different from there being 'no institutional racism'. Are they walking that claim back now?
Edit: I just did a quick Ctrl+F of institutionalized racism (s and z spellings), the entire sentence that the previous article headline was ostensibly quoting, and just the word institutionalis/zed. The only part I found which stated 'The Review found no evidence of systemic or institutional racism' seemed to be referring to the Timpson Report on education that was published in 2019.
The list of definitions at the end, and how they were used, is worth reading.