34 votes

Adoption isn't happily ever after

This will probably make some people uncomfortable and even angry, but it needs to be said.

Adoption isn't happily ever after.

The media loves to portray it that way, especially for foster kids. Everyone loves the fairly tale story about the poor abused kids that get rescued by the selfless hero foster parents who then adopt them and everything is all good after that. I mean, the kids now have loving parents and a stable home. That's all they need right?

People love a happy ending. But fairy tales aren’t real and life isn’t that simple. Adoption is messy, and I don't mean the legal process, I mean the actual adoption itself. Adoptive parents aren't selfless heroes, they are regular flawed people just like everyone else, they just happened to choose to adopt.

These kids have been through bad things that are beyond the imagination of most people who don't have experience with the kids themselves. I hear it all the time. People say "They just need a good loving home". Loving and stable homes are great, but they don't make those bad things go away. Even if the adoptive parents were perfect (which they definitely aren't) these kids will be dealing with their trauma for the rest of their lives.

And for these kids trauma isn't simple like so many people assume it is. It isn't just bad dreams and sadness. It's rage. It’s frequent meltdowns over the smallest things. Sometimes it’s hurting pets, or even other kids. Sometimes it's trying to burn the house down. Other times it’s stealing from kids at school. Sometimes it’s grade schoolers finding ways to look at porn. Sometimes it’s trying to molest other kids. This doesn’t describe all kids from foster care. It’s not meant to scare you. It’s meant to show you that there’s more than what you see on the outside.

For these kids meltdowns have a completely different meaning than for most other kids. A meltdown isn't crying and getting angry for 10 or 15 minutes. It can be hours. Hours of true screaming. Hours of punching doors and walls. Or punching us. Or hurting themselves. Total non-compliance. It's a total inability for them to calm down at all. Sometimes we have to physically restrain them for safety reasons. Usually, they have to physically exhaust themselves before they finally begin to come down.

And it's not their fault.

And we parents aren't perfect either. Sometimes we scream back at them. Sometimes we escalate the meltdown even more. Sometimes we restrain when it's not necessary. Sometimes we just layer on consequence after consequence, not because it's helping, but because we are mad and caught in a power struggle.

We take them to doctor appointments. We adjust meds. We get to counseling every week. We literally pull them out of public school because they can't function there. We are usually exhausted. We are often hopeless. We fear they will never have a normal childhood. We fear that they won't have a good life as adults.

We can never replace their birth parents. They will always miss them, no matter how bad the abuse was. They will mourn what could have been. They will mourn what should have been.

They point that hurt and anger at their adoptive parents. They say they hate us. They say they will kill us.

We aren't a fairy tale family. We aren't some success story about the power of love.

We were the safest option in a bad situation.

We will always love them as our kids. We will always strive to be there for them, to support them, to give them what they need to have whatever healing is possible.

For them though this will never be as good as having birth parents that were safe and loving in the first place. This will never compare with what should have been.

8 comments

  1. [2]
    cfabbro
    (edited )
    Link
    Not much I feel I can say except that I have always genuinely appreciated your openness and honesty when it comes to sharing your experiences as a foster/adoptive parent (the good and bad) here on...

    Not much I feel I can say except that I have always genuinely appreciated your openness and honesty when it comes to sharing your experiences as a foster/adoptive parent (the good and bad) here on Tildes. And this topic is no different. So thanks for opening yourself up like this once again for us. ❤️

    p.s. You say you're not a hero, but you fucking are. ;) IMO being a hero doesn't mean you're perfect; It just means you stepped up and did what was needed, when it was needed most, when others wouldn't/couldn't... which is exactly what you have done for your kids.

    18 votes
    1. Grendel
      Link Parent
      Thanks, everyone here has been very kind and supportive through this whole process. I remember that I made a post or a comment back when my son first had to go to an inpatient psych facility and...

      Thanks, everyone here has been very kind and supportive through this whole process. I remember that I made a post or a comment back when my son first had to go to an inpatient psych facility and people really showed their support. It helped me through that tough time.

      I'm really happy people have been open to hear what it's really like. It can make some people very uncomfortable, but then again the truth usually does.

      Thanks again for the support :)

      6 votes
  2. [2]
    tvl
    Link
    Thank you for sharing. I feel like show "The Queen's Gambit" did a great job of explaining how adoption doesn't "end" — it's a constant process over the course of your life. The adoptive parents...

    Thank you for sharing.

    I feel like show "The Queen's Gambit" did a great job of explaining how adoption doesn't "end" — it's a constant process over the course of your life. The adoptive parents in the show were by no means perfect. They were conflicted about the whole process throughout, and the child took half a lifetime to come to terms with what it meant for her and how her previous life effected her. For the parents, particularly the mother, the show did a good job of showing how it can be incredibly hard to form a true bond with a new person like that. I'd be curious to know your thoughts if you've seen the show.

    15 votes
    1. Grendel
      Link Parent
      Bonding is always tough, and the older the child is when they come to you the harder it usually is. Many people don't realize that things like changing diapers and feeding a baby has an impact on...

      Bonding is always tough, and the older the child is when they come to you the harder it usually is. Many people don't realize that things like changing diapers and feeding a baby has an impact on bonding. They feel your touch, they hear your voice. They identify you as the one who provides for their needs and that's how trust is established.

      There is special family counseling to help with bonding. Even people who specialize in Attachment Theory (which is an incredibly complex and fascinating sub-field).

      They have some neat ways of "making up for" some of those baby bonding activities. For example having the kids and parents finger paint each other's faces is a way to get some positive touch bonding. Our boys are 6 and 7 which is pretty far beyond the age that most kids are rocked to sleep however we have been rocking them to sleep almost every night since they came to us two years ago. It helps with bonding and it also helps them developmentally.

      Another aspect of this is that for most kids in care their developmental age is about half that of their physical age. Have a 16 year old? You can expect them to have the emotional capacity and needs of an 8 year old. This is something that the Queens Gambit didn't really show, but it would have made it hard for the plot to progress if they had so I get it. Kids can catch up on their developmental age, but you have to go back and fill those needs for it to happen. So if you have a 16 year old you have to do some of the things that parents would normally do for an 8 year old (at least emotionally).

      9 votes
  3. [4]
    mrbig
    Link
    I understand all you say and agree with, even though I have no experience myself. I applaud your dedication. I would just like to add that there are no guarantees when having a kid through the...

    I understand all you say and agree with, even though I have no experience myself. I applaud your dedication.

    I would just like to add that there are no guarantees when having a kid through the usual means either. Kids can come with all kinds of physical and mental issues which poses all kinds of challenges that can hardly be predicted or prevented, including but not limited to psychopathy and severe disabilities. "Regular" parents roll the genetics dice as well.

    6 votes
    1. [2]
      Tardigrade
      Link Parent
      It's not something most parents think about before hand either.

      It's not something most parents think about before hand either.

      6 votes
      1. Grendel
        Link Parent
        That's very true, and it will have a huge impact on the relationship of parents. I don't have numbers on it, but anecdotally I've seen people get divorced not long after adoption or fostering. I...

        That's very true, and it will have a huge impact on the relationship of parents. I don't have numbers on it, but anecdotally I've seen people get divorced not long after adoption or fostering. I would guess there are probably pretty similar numbers for those who have special needs kids naturally. Not only does it dramatically add stress, it also makes it harder to take time for self care. It's hard to find people who can/will watch kids with special needs. There's less time due to appointments, special therapies, and special schools.

        The increase in stress combined with the inability to relieve that stress can really tear people apart if they aren't very proactive about their relationship

        6 votes
    2. Grendel
      Link Parent
      Yeah that's absolutely true, and I know that people with neurotypical or physically typical kids have a hard time understanding that life looks different for parents of special needs kids,...

      Yeah that's absolutely true, and I know that people with neurotypical or physically typical kids have a hard time understanding that life looks different for parents of special needs kids, regardless of how they came to you. I think I really just want more awareness overall about the reality of kids with needs.

      5 votes