5 votes

Will Facebook’s oversight board actually hold the company accountable?

6 comments

  1. [3]
    bloup
    Link
    I personally don't think an "oversight board" should be allowed to be called an "oversight board" when it literally only exists at the discretion of the people it's supposedly overseeing, lmao....

    I personally don't think an "oversight board" should be allowed to be called an "oversight board" when it literally only exists at the discretion of the people it's supposedly overseeing, lmao. Ideally, such a thing should be comprised of individuals democratically chosen by the users and the employees and should have veto power over any decision made by shareholders.

    10 votes
    1. [2]
      stu2b50
      Link Parent
      I don't think that's actually legally possible given the corp charter.

      should have veto power over any decision made by shareholders.

      I don't think that's actually legally possible given the corp charter.

      2 votes
  2. skybrian
    Link
    Whenever you see someone advocating for "holding x accountable" you should try to figure out what the concrete action is supposed to be. Are they supposed to complain more or what?

    Whenever you see someone advocating for "holding x accountable" you should try to figure out what the concrete action is supposed to be. Are they supposed to complain more or what?

    3 votes
  3. [2]
    annadane
    Link
    No, of course not. Zuck will fight tooth and nail so he has everything his way (he also owns majority voting power)

    No, of course not. Zuck will fight tooth and nail so he has everything his way (he also owns majority voting power)

    2 votes
    1. stu2b50
      Link Parent
      Nah, he's the one pushing for it. In fact, for PR purposes, I think that there's going to be a major issue that Zuck ostensibly is pushing, and the oversight board successfully overturns him. What...

      Nah, he's the one pushing for it. In fact, for PR purposes, I think that there's going to be a major issue that Zuck ostensibly is pushing, and the oversight board successfully overturns him.

      What FB is really trying to do during the pandemic is convince everyone they're cool and privacy-focused now. Conceding some medium sized price point so the oversight board can gain ostensible credibility is easily worth it.

      8 votes