8 votes

About content editing

I was just thinking about something that I've noticed being an issue in a few cases on reddit. If you accidentally post something that's wrong or misleading, you might decide to edit the comment/post to be more accurate, once something was pointed out to you.

But lets say that you posted some tidbit like "David Firth is demonetized from youtube.. god i hate youtubes recent trend", which was along the lines of the things I'm talking about. But then weren't fully up to date on the story anymore as Firth had been re-instated.

With the post getting 90% of its upvotes before the "e: he's reinstated now", it's rife for accidental victimless misinformation. And once you make the correction (let's not make it 100%), you cant really go pm'ing everyone because that's annoying, and not everyone that saw it commented on it.

I'm not actually sure how much of an issue anyone else thinks this is so I'd be glad to hear if you've got a perspective on it.

The best thing I can think of is to give a little notification to people who have interacted with the post (or viewed it in the last certain amount of time?) so that you can evaluate the comment again. This isn't ideal because you'll be clued into everyone's spelling corrections.

A friend suggested a edit "pull request" thing where anyone could propose an edit, and then empowered users could approve the changes. Perhaps, if this is actually an issue and not just an over-caution, this could be rolled into that. If an empowered user thinks that it's worth pinging everyone that interacted with that post directly (vote/tag/comment) once the edit is pushed.

2 comments

  1. ajar
    Link
    Sounds like an interesting idea to me! In order to avoid getting the spelling notifications, maybe the notification should only be sent when more than X characters have been modified, and only if...

    Sounds like an interesting idea to me! In order to avoid getting the spelling notifications, maybe the notification should only be sent when more than X characters have been modified, and only if the poster ticks a box or something (meaning they consider it to be worth checking).

    Also, it'd probably be good that all users could completely disable these types of notifications if they want to.

    6 votes
  2. crius
    Link
    The message popping up on my inbox if I've replied to it should be easy to implement as first prototype of the idea I think. Maybe it could trigger for everyone that posted on the topic once it...

    The message popping up on my inbox if I've replied to it should be easy to implement as first prototype of the idea I think.

    Maybe it could trigger for everyone that posted on the topic once it reach a certain threshold of votes as supposedly lots of people have seen it?

    1 vote