17 votes

Did you ever like a book on the second attempt because you liked something else that ties in with the book?

Not a native speaker, so I hope I phrased it correctly. Let me explain. It happened to me at least twice.


Some years ago, I picked up the "Metro 2033" book by Dmitry Glukhovsky. I read part of it until I read about the Stalker, who was a badass wearing a black coat. It was so cliche, I was unable to continue. I wrote off the book as trash.

Then, some time later I played the video game under the same title, which is an adaptation of the novel and I liked it a lot. It had that eerie atmosphere and a unique Eastern European feel to it, unlike games like Fallout. I decided to give the book another go, but this time I knew the lore and I had images from the game in my mind and everything changed. I really liked that book, it was a good mix of horror, action and sociopolitical commentary disguised as a postapo novel. It may not be great, but it's a very pleasant read. By now, I've read all three books and played all three video games (btw if you plan to play Metro Exodus I'd advise you to read "Metro 2035" first, as the game is a direct continuation of that story and both were written by the author) and I consider myself a fan of the series.


Another, more recent example is "Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone". I am not a Potterhead, I never read any HP books, I even despised them for the most part. By the time J.K. Rowling's stories were published in my country I was already 20 or so. I was familiar with Jordan, Tolkien, Sapkowski, Williams and many more authors writing fantasy. I was into the tolkienesque depiction of wizards, so something like Hogwart with robed men and children riding brooms and waving wands is both weird and strongly off-putting to me. Also, I considered myself already too old for what I saw as children's books.

I'm 42 now and those words of C.S. Lewis resonate with me ever so more:

When I was ten, I read fairy tales in secret and would have been ashamed if I had been found doing so. Now that I am fifty I read them openly. When I became a man I put away childish things, including the fear of childishness and the desire to be very grown up.

So I decided to give Harry Potter a chance. I first tried watching the first movie. I didn't like it much and dropped it somewhere in the middle. Then a couple moths ago I loaded a free sample of the first book from Kobo Store and it was... alright. I dropped it as well. I thought it was well written, but was definitely a kids book for which I was too old.

I started playing Hogwart's Legacy a week ago or so. I'm now positively hooked on that game, it's beautiful, it has characters I like, it has a good combat system and it's been my doorway to Hogwarts. So when I couldn't play, I was thinking about it and picked up that book which I dropped earlier. But this time I had a better understanding of the lore, had images of certain places in my mind and it clicked! I am still an old fart and it is still a kids book, but I have found new appreciation for it. I think it's well written on the literary level, it has a lot of situational and verbal humor (I think it has a distinct British flavor to it, like a very toned down version of Pratchett) -- I actually often chuckle when reading it. I bought the whole set (books 1-7) and maybe I'll even read them. Here's hoping that they mature with the readers, that's what I've been told. I'm sure that if I were 12 when reading them for the first time, I'd love them.


As you can see, in my case it's usually that good video games drive me to give another chance to some books that I initially didn't like and because of the great experience with video game adaptations, I start liking the source material. Do you have similar experiences?

(btw this is my first post on Tildes)

7 comments

  1. [4]
    DiggWasCool
    Link
    For me, this was basically any lengthier classic that was a mandatory reading in high school. Either never got through it when it was a requirement for school work, or just straight up didn't like...

    For me, this was basically any lengthier classic that was a mandatory reading in high school. Either never got through it when it was a requirement for school work, or just straight up didn't like it. For example, East of Eden, a John Steinbeck classic, was just too long and no way was i going to finish it as a 16 or 17 year old. Meanwhile I've now read it twice as an adult and loved it!

    5 votes
    1. chocobean
      Link Parent
      As a sort of "natural progression of growing older, and the freedom to choose" front, for me it is the Psalms. I naturally have little tolerance for non-strictly structured poetry and I thought...

      As a sort of "natural progression of growing older, and the freedom to choose" front, for me it is the Psalms. I naturally have little tolerance for non-strictly structured poetry and I thought the Psalms were just so repetitive, and mostly a guy whining and moaning about everything.

      I even tried to read C S Lewis's Reflection on the Psalms to work my way around it - much like @steel_for_humans trying to tie it into video games. Nope. Boring and whiny.

      Now that I am old enough to have lamentations, as well as appreciate the different parts of one's day and seasons, I find them very fitting to express sentiments I can't find words to express. I suppose I became that boring, weeping, whining mess of a person lol

      3 votes
    2. steel_for_humans
      Link Parent
      Oh yeah. I admit I didn't read most of the required material in high school, even though I was an avid reader since early childhood. I didn't like being forced to read with a deadline (being a...

      Oh yeah. I admit I didn't read most of the required material in high school, even though I was an avid reader since early childhood. I didn't like being forced to read with a deadline (being a slow reader doesn't help), I didn't enjoy the classroom discussions with forced "correct" interpretation (I am aware it's most likely my country's educational system specific thing). I also think many of those books are probably great reads, but maybe not at that stage of life. I want to revisit some of them now that I'm an adult with different experiences.

      3 votes
    3. Dr_Amazing
      Link Parent
      When I was in school, we had to read this book called Pit Pony. It's about a young boy who has to go work in a coal mine and befriends a horse. I was a big reader, but I hated that book. It was...

      When I was in school, we had to read this book called Pit Pony. It's about a young boy who has to go work in a coal mine and befriends a horse. I was a big reader, but I hated that book. It was boring and not a lot happens.

      Years later I'm a teacher and we're still using it. I read it again and it's actually not too bad. Not going to be my favorite book or anything, but there's definitely stuff I missed that I could appreciate more as an adult. Students actually surprised me a little by catching stuff I hadn't caught at their age.

      2 votes
  2. [2]
    chocobean
    (edited )
    Link
    Unrelated to your topical question: as a late comer to the Harry Potter franchise, do you have opinions about the author's more recent controversy? Perhaps to be polite, not your opinion on the...

    Unrelated to your topical question: as a late comer to the Harry Potter franchise, do you have opinions about the author's more recent controversy? Perhaps to be polite, not your opinion on the controversy itself, but rather, on "is it okay to like art created by troubled individuals"?

    On topic:

    I think it's great that tie ins allow folks to approach different medium/genre of art from different angles, if the first attempts are unsuccessful. I was talking to a dietitian and in their field they have "food laddering", in which you can chain foods that have few variables in taste/color/texture/temperature/brand/etc so someone who has an aversion to Z can take a long way towards it because they already eat A. Perhaps art association sometimes needs a less obvious path.

    I'm following your post with interest to see if I can find a laddered path towards other poetry, especially the epics.

    2 votes
    1. steel_for_humans
      Link Parent
      I don't. I am aware of the controversies but I tried not to read into it and instead read the books. I think the only good answer is "it depends". It depends on where the problem lies and how the...

      Unrelated to your topical question: as a late comer to the Harry Potter franchise, do you have opinions about the author's more recent controversy?

      I don't. I am aware of the controversies but I tried not to read into it and instead read the books.

      Perhaps to be polite, not your opinion on the controversy itself, but rather, on "is it okay to like art created by troubled individuals"?

      I think the only good answer is "it depends". It depends on where the problem lies and how the reader feels about said problem in particular. Or how strongly they feel about it. If you ask multiple people about the same topic, some will be upset, some will be indifferent and some will even agree with the views of the author.

      3 votes
  3. Cannonball
    Link
    I tried reading Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy but couldn't really wrap my head around the absurdity and word play the first time. It wasn't until I read a considerable amount of Terry...

    I tried reading Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy but couldn't really wrap my head around the absurdity and word play the first time. It wasn't until I read a considerable amount of Terry Pratchett's Discworld novels that it suddenly clicked and I was able to go back to Hitchhiker's and thoroughly enjoy it. It's now one of my favorite series. I guess Pratchett was a bit easier for me to digest and helped ease me into the wonderful nonsense

    1 vote