32 votes

Tokitae, the star of Miami Seaquarium, dies after half a century in captivity

8 comments

  1. [3]
    spit-evil-olive-tips
    Link
    archive link an excellent long read from 2015, from the alt-weekly here in Seattle: The fight to free Lolita: the story of a Puget Sound killer whale that's been held captive in Florida for 45...

    archive link

    In August 1970, Tokitae’s ordeal began in the calm waters of Penn Cove, Whidbey Island – a quiet island off the coast of Washington state. Men with long sticks and guns corralled a group of resident killer whales, separating mothers from their calves. At least a dozen of those whales died during the capture, and more than 50 were kept for captive display. Toki was probably only a few years old at the time of her capture. A few years later, killer whales were placed under the Endangered Species Act.

    an excellent long read from 2015, from the alt-weekly here in Seattle:

    The fight to free Lolita: the story of a Puget Sound killer whale that's been held captive in Florida for 45 years

    "They had aircraft, they had spotters, they had speedboats, they had bombs they were throwing in the water, they were lighting their own bombs with acetylene torches in their boats and throwing them as fast as they could to herd the whales into coves," says activist Howard Garrett in the documentary Blackfish, which briefly depicts the August 1970 capture but doesn't discuss any of the killer whales involved.

    Evidently aware of what was happening, the orcas changed direction when they saw Griffin and Goldsberry coming for them. "They knew what was going on, they knew their young ones would be taken from them," says Garrett, who is also a cofounder of the nonprofit Orca Network.

    ...

    Some 80 killer whales were entrapped in Penn Cove that day, more than at any orca capture before or since. There are only three pods of southern residents—named J, K, and L by scientists, each an extended family led by matriarchs—and all three pods were present in Penn Cove, according to Canadian biologist Dr. Michael Bigg's later assessment of photographs. That means the oldest living killer whale known to science, J2, aka Granny, who is believed to have turned 104 years old this year, was there.

    ...

    Crowe admitted later that he and two other men were ordered to cut the three dead calves open, "fill them with rocks, put anchors on their tail, and sink them." They carried out this task under cover of night. For months, the deaths of these calves went unknown. Then their bodies started washing ashore. Their carcasses were still stuffed with rocks and chains. At least one was still attached to a 75-pound anchor, according to the Everett Herald.

    orcas mourn their dead. from 2018: Killer whale lets her dead newborn go after carrying body for 17 days

    and these sick fucks killed several calves, mutilated them, and threw their bodies back into the water.

    Dr. Jesse White, a veterinarian who'd flown to Seattle to make a selection on Miami Seaquarium's behalf, described the 4-year-old calf as "so courageous and yet so gentle." He named her Tokitae, a Coast Salish greeting meaning "nice day, pretty colors."

    "I think he named her Tokitae to honor her Northwest roots," Howard Garrett of the Orca Network told me, "and that was specifically what they"—meaning Miami Seaquarium—"didn't want people to know about. Within two weeks, they renamed her."

    They renamed her, disgustingly, Lolita.

    One of the orcas captured with Lolita in Penn Cove died seven months later in Texas. Another went to France and died in 1973. The two who went to Japan died in 1974. The one who went to England had the dubious honor of swimming with Prince Charles before being transferred to San Diego and dying in 1986. By 1987, every single southern resident Griffin and Goldsberry had captured in Puget Sound was dead—except Lolita.

    18 votes
    1. Corsy
      Link Parent
      Absolute shit stains. I hope they're remembered as such and no more orcas are captured

      Absolute shit stains. I hope they're remembered as such and no more orcas are captured

      8 votes
    2. fandegw
      Link Parent
      Fucking hell. Just no words... It feels extremely inappropriate, but it's putting a new perspective on the equivalent scene in Avatar 2, where they seems to be more tame than them.

      Fucking hell. Just no words...

      It feels extremely inappropriate, but it's putting a new perspective on the equivalent scene in Avatar 2, where they seems to be more tame than them.

  2. BlueKittyMeow
    Link
    This is such a travesty. I had been following the announcement that she was going to be moved to the sea and this just... Shattered me. Personhood is not limited to humans - I hope we as a species...

    This is such a travesty. I had been following the announcement that she was going to be moved to the sea and this just... Shattered me. Personhood is not limited to humans - I hope we as a species work to think more generously about all the different people around us, humans and other animals.

    13 votes
  3. doingmybest
    Link
    This was excruciating to read. I pray we can just be done with this barbaric practice.

    This was excruciating to read. I pray we can just be done with this barbaric practice.

    6 votes
  4. MrAlex
    (edited )
    Link
    I'm glad our practices of keeping captive whales and dolphins seems to be on the wane. This may be a minority opinion, but seeing how Keiko only lived to be 27 and never reintegrated with other...

    I'm glad our practices of keeping captive whales and dolphins seems to be on the wane.
    This may be a minority opinion, but seeing how Keiko only lived to be 27 and never reintegrated with other orcas in the 5 years after his release, part of me feels better about her passing away in the environment she had been in for the last 40+ years, as opposed to the brief confusion and additional isolation of being put in a basically new environment with orcas that either can't, or wont interact.

    I know I'm making a few assumptions, but I feel it's similar to someone in their 80s being deported from a country they have lived in for decades, to one they left when they were 7.

    4 votes
  5. [2]
    mezze
    Link
    This got me thinking...if she was taken at age four, and spent the next 53 years without communicating with another orca, would she even be able to communicate effectively or at all with the other...

    Plans were in place for millions of dollars to fund her flight back to her home waters – to live out her days in a sea pen being fed salmon, in communication distance of her kin.

    This got me thinking...if she was taken at age four, and spent the next 53 years without communicating with another orca, would she even be able to communicate effectively or at all with the other orcas near the sea pen? Presumably, her vocalizations shifted closer to match the bottle-nose dolphins she performed with.

    3 votes
    1. CrazyProfessor02
      Link Parent
      I vaguely remember reading that orca pods have different accents or different language, to put it in human terms, so she would have a hard time communicating with those orca.

      I vaguely remember reading that orca pods have different accents or different language, to put it in human terms, so she would have a hard time communicating with those orca.

      2 votes