17 votes

Why turtle soup disappeared: An elite, rare delicacy intersected with the advent of industrial canning, leading to supply exhaustion and backlash in consumer sentiment

5 comments

  1. [3]
    JuDGe3690
    Link
    Phil Edwards, a video producer for Vox, always has interesting, well-produced topics. Here, he goes into some of the history of turtle soup (with a slight antarctic detour). Turtle soup used to be...

    Phil Edwards, a video producer for Vox, always has interesting, well-produced topics. Here, he goes into some of the history of turtle soup (with a slight antarctic detour). Turtle soup used to be on the menu at fancy restaurants everywhere in the 19th century, as well as canned in the early 20th century, but has now all but died out.

    Some interesting things I learned from this:

    • Mock turtle soup often used calf heads in place of turtle, and is the source of the cow-headed mock turtle in Alice in Wonderland.
    • In England, turtle soup originally used large green sea turtles, but as these became rare (because all the ones harvested were mature adults) Americans started substituting snapping turtles and later terrapins.
    • Some of the impetus for sea turtle protections were because of sea turtle canneries, in addition to concerns over plastic (like the soda/beer can rings).
    8 votes
    1. Merry
      Link Parent
      When I was a kid, my dad cooked a snapping turtle one time. All I remember is that the smell was God awful and is still seared in my brain 20+ years later. I have no idea if that is supposed to be...

      When I was a kid, my dad cooked a snapping turtle one time. All I remember is that the smell was God awful and is still seared in my brain 20+ years later. I have no idea if that is supposed to be the case when cooking turtles, but I never want to eat turtle again.

      6 votes
    2. TheD00d
      Link Parent
      Mock Turtle is actually a big staple in my city. Back when I ate meat, it was one of my favorites. Worthmores made the best "big box", but nothing could beat my families recipe. I can still find...

      Mock Turtle is actually a big staple in my city. Back when I ate meat, it was one of my favorites. Worthmores made the best "big box", but nothing could beat my families recipe. I can still find it in some of my local Kroger stores.

      2 votes
  2. GinandTonic
    Link
    I always found it interesting that so many older cookbooks had recipes for turtle soup and it seemed to be especially popular within New England.

    I always found it interesting that so many older cookbooks had recipes for turtle soup and it seemed to be especially popular within New England.

    2 votes
  3. KneeFingers
    Link
    I've loved Phil's work on Vox and it's great to see him expanding with his own channel! The turtle soup featured in this video looks different than the one I've had the opportunity to try. Their's...

    I've loved Phil's work on Vox and it's great to see him expanding with his own channel!

    The turtle soup featured in this video looks different than the one I've had the opportunity to try. Their's is more yellowey, while the version I had was a deep brown. As it is with lots of Creole/Cajun food, I guess it comes down to roux preference? The version I had was most likely based off Brennan's Turtle Soup which is another famous NOLA restaurant that specializes in the dish.

    One thing that this video didn't cover is the tradition to sometimes drizzle extra sherry on top of the soup before serving!

    1 vote