3 votes

Condiments and commercially made sauces: Which ones do you prefer?

I was making myself a chicken sandwich today, with thin strips of white meat chicken fried up with a soy sauce/honey/garlic combo that I like. I looked at my mayo jar and realized that I had become accustomed to using Blue Plate mayonnaise, to the point that I didn't even think about it anymore. You see, I used to be a Hellmann's snob, but they have priced themselves out of consideration, and for the last few years, I've switched to Blue Plate.

Here are a few condiments, salad dressings and other sauces that I use:

  • Mayo: Blue Plate
  • Mustard: Gulden's Spicy Brown
  • Salad dressing: Newman's Own Honey Mustard (I got SO tired of the ubiquitous ranch dressings)
  • Soy sauce: Kikkoman (No, I don't like La Choy)
  • Siracha: This one is still up in the air. I've tried half a dozen kinds, and tend to wander back to Huy Fong.
  • BBQ: Ray's No Sugar Added... I prefer the spicier version, and even it is a little too mild and sweet for my taste.
  • Ketchup: Anything. I use it so rarely, I don't have a favorite.

I don't have a great preference for a marinara sauce. The least expensive one I can tolerate is one sold under the HEB store brand, and its honestly not bad. HEB also sells a very good salsa, to the point I've abandoned Old El Paso entirely.

I'm sure there are plenty of great choices out there that I have never heard of, but a major consideration for me is price. Everything I use is on the less expensive side, or there simply isn't a good bargain brand available that let's me avoid the high priced products.

So, what else can I add to my good but not budget-busting list? Jamaican jerk sauce? And I've never had a curry sauce that I enjoy enough to repeat.

If you have favorites, please list them.

7 comments

  1. fxgn
    Link
    Not a sauce snob at all, I just buy store brand stuff. Tastes great.

    Not a sauce snob at all, I just buy store brand stuff. Tastes great.

    2 votes
  2. [3]
    CrypticCuriosity629
    (edited )
    Link
    So Huy Fong's Sriracha isn't the original recipe and they don't use the same chili peppers. Not sure if you're familiar with the drama there, but it's kind of interesting because I used to SWEAR...

    So Huy Fong's Sriracha isn't the original recipe and they don't use the same chili peppers. Not sure if you're familiar with the drama there, but it's kind of interesting because I used to SWEAR by them. At this point I think Huy Fong's Sriracha is a sleazy company and I'd never support them again after they screwed their original pepper farmer.

    Here's a decent article on it: How Sriracha's maker betrayed its 28-year pepper supplier

    Underwood Ranches Dragon Sriracha is the sriracha with the original farm, original peppers, and original recipe. So I swear by them now and it tastes exactly how Huy Fong's Sriracha tasted like before they screwed over Underwood Farms.

    2 votes
    1. [2]
      Kerry56
      Link Parent
      Underwood Ranches Dragon Sriracha seems to be discontinued. It's not available at my HEB store, Walmart or Amazon. That was with a quick search, I didn't look at more than the three sites.

      Underwood Ranches Dragon Sriracha seems to be discontinued. It's not available at my HEB store, Walmart or Amazon. That was with a quick search, I didn't look at more than the three sites.

      1. CrypticCuriosity629
        Link Parent
        Well shit. I bought several cases at Costco earlier this year. I had no idea. Welp, I'm glad I did.

        Well shit. I bought several cases at Costco earlier this year. I had no idea. Welp, I'm glad I did.

        1 vote
  3. stu2b50
    Link
    Mayo is one of the few sauces that crosses the boundary to where making it at home makes sense. As long as you have either a blender or a hand blender, the required ingredients is just vegetable...

    Mayo is one of the few sauces that crosses the boundary to where making it at home makes sense. As long as you have either a blender or a hand blender, the required ingredients is just vegetable oil and an egg and it takes half a second of blending.

    I don't have mayo often, but I make it myself when I do. Compared to store bought mayo, I add in a significant amount of raw garlic, lemon juice, and coarse ground black pepper as well as quite a bit of salt to give it more of a kick. Store mayo tends to just taste like, well, oil.

    1 vote
  4. [2]
    PraiseTheSoup
    Link
    BBQ sauce used to be my favorite. I would put it on everything: burgers, fries, chicken of all varieties, you name it. Recently though it has become nearly impossible to find a BBQ sauce that...

    BBQ sauce used to be my favorite. I would put it on everything: burgers, fries, chicken of all varieties, you name it. Recently though it has become nearly impossible to find a BBQ sauce that doesn't use HFCS. Even more recently I've noticed something that really disgusts me, and that is BBQ sauce labels that very loudly advertise "no added sugar!" and then you check the ingredients and that's because they just use an artificial sweeter like sucralose instead. While technically true I think this should be illegal.

    So mainly what I look for in a sauce is minimal ingredients and ingredients that are natural, and because of this I barely ever use BBQ sauce anymore. I'll make my own for sloppy joes or pulled pork or whatever.

    For ketchup I strictly use "Simply Heinz", even though I think the branding is awful, because it uses real cane sugar instead of HFCS.

    For mustard I have a (sort of) local favorite: Boetje's Stone Ground. After I had this stuff all the mustards in the store just suck in comparison.

    Other than that I don't have much sauce loyalty and I absolutely love trying new sauces.

    1 vote
    1. Kerry56
      Link Parent
      Yes, I agree on the added sugar label. I use Ray's No Added Sugar BBQ sauce because I have to be careful with processed sugar input. They use an artificial sweetener in it, and too much of it. As...

      Yes, I agree on the added sugar label. I use Ray's No Added Sugar BBQ sauce because I have to be careful with processed sugar input. They use an artificial sweetener in it, and too much of it. As I mentioned, it is slightly too sweet for me. I just haven't found a good alternative.