25 votes

I am officially a DM now!

This is a follow up to this discussion from the other day where I was getting ready to DM my first session of 5e. tl;dr from that is that I was chosen to be the DM by my group and we're playing through the Essentials Kit campaign, albeit with certain elements tweaked to give it more flavor.

Our first game was last night and I think I crushed it. Typical of our group we got a later start than intended, so we only made it through most of a single quest. But man it was so much fun. I was expecting the group to go routes I hadn't expected, but I really didn't account for them splitting the group...whoops.

Basically the first quest was to retrieve an elderly woman from a windmill. When they arrive, the windmill is under attack by a manticore. In my head the solutions were A) fight it there, B) distract it and save the woman, or C) go hunt with it for food.

The group ultimately chose all 3. One character started telling the Manticore riddles while another snuck around behind the windmill to try to get the woman out of the house. But conveniently the window was too small. It culminated in the Manticore going hunting with a Harengon alone, the rest of the group realizing what a bad idea that was and then shadowing them. And then ultimately the group jumped the Manticore and we had our first encounter. Thankfully I had nerfed the Manticore's health about 40%, so it was a pretty easy fight.

The weakest part was definitely the combat. I was never any good at that as a player, so me running it was a little rocky. But nobody died, everyone got to participate, and they defeated the Manticore at about the right speed to keep it interesting. The best was just the roleplaying. I got to play as 3 distinct characters (the starting zone guide character, the Manticore, and the old lady) and had a blast. The old lady's voice slowly slipped into a Terry Jones inspired cockney woman's voice, which is just so much fun to do.

Long story short, everything went really, really well. I know what did and didn't work, so I'll be adjusting accordingly for next session. Although very little didn't work. I was really pleased. And since we didn't even entirely finish the first quest (the turn-in part at least), I still have a quest/dungeon written up that I can use for next week.

6 comments

  1. [4]
    zelderan
    Link
    Dude yes!! Well done, I read your post the other day and it was remarkably similar to my experience (mediocre player, unsure of what to do exactly) and I'm so happy that you guys had a great time....

    Dude yes!! Well done, I read your post the other day and it was remarkably similar to my experience (mediocre player, unsure of what to do exactly) and I'm so happy that you guys had a great time. As I've DM'd more and more, I find it actually super rewarding and as fun as playing as a character. Setting up story bits and holding in your excitement when your players are super close to reaching a goal you've planned is incredibly enjoyable.

    Good shit!

    3 votes
    1. [3]
      hamstergeddon
      Link Parent
      Thanks! I'm a little bummed our plans it only to meet once a month because I am definitely ready to do that again.

      Thanks! I'm a little bummed our plans it only to meet once a month because I am definitely ready to do that again.

      3 votes
      1. zelderan
        Link Parent
        Honestly meeting once per month is probably good to start. Lets everyone prepare (to not miss a session) and keeps everyone fresh and not burnt out- especially you!

        Honestly meeting once per month is probably good to start. Lets everyone prepare (to not miss a session) and keeps everyone fresh and not burnt out- especially you!

        3 votes
      2. Apex
        Link Parent
        You can always start up a second group!

        You can always start up a second group!

        1 vote
  2. OstensibleUtensil
    Link
    Sounds like everyone had fun, which (for me at least) is the main goal when I'm running a game. Great job!

    Sounds like everyone had fun, which (for me at least) is the main goal when I'm running a game. Great job!

    3 votes
  3. Bohmbot
    Link
    Sounds like a memorable session. Glad you (and your players) had fun!

    Sounds like a memorable session. Glad you (and your players) had fun!

    1 vote