20 votes

First few levels of F-Stop (Cancelled Portal prequel) leaked online

11 comments

  1. [8]
    CannibalisticApple
    Link
    According to this article from Kotaku, it's fully playable. Honestly from what little I see, it seems fun! It's also neat to see Aperture Science when it was actually functional. Looking it up,...

    According to this article from Kotaku, it's fully playable.

    Honestly from what little I see, it seems fun! It's also neat to see Aperture Science when it was actually functional. Looking it up, seems the playtesters just didn't like the lack of portals...? Fair enough, but this still could have been a good spin-off though!

    11 votes
    1. [5]
      Tsubasa
      Link Parent
      Viewfinder feels like a fully realised game with this mechanic, though it tends to lean more into copying objects (and entire landscapes) than just moving them around. It definitely would have...

      Viewfinder feels like a fully realised game with this mechanic, though it tends to lean more into copying objects (and entire landscapes) than just moving them around.

      It definitely would have been interesting to see Valve's take on it as a spin-off though. One of my favourite things about Portal 2 is how well they integrated the various extra puzzle elements with the base of the portal gun, and there could be a lot of creative room to mix them with the camera too.

      Going strictly by this footage, I can sort of understand why people would be turned off if they'd played the first game. It feels a bit like "what if the same game but we replace the whole core of the game with something that isn't obviously as dynamic and interesting".

      7 votes
      1. [4]
        kfwyre
        Link Parent
        I was also reminded of Superliminal with the object-placement focus.

        I was also reminded of Superliminal with the object-placement focus.

        6 votes
        1. [3]
          CannibalisticApple
          Link Parent
          Same. This actually pushed it up to the top of my list for the backlog burner!

          Same. This actually pushed it up to the top of my list for the backlog burner!

          3 votes
          1. [2]
            kfwyre
            Link Parent
            Ooh, nice! I thoroughly enjoyed it and hope that you do too!

            Ooh, nice! I thoroughly enjoyed it and hope that you do too!

            2 votes
            1. CannibalisticApple
              Link Parent
              I'm sure I will! It's been on my list for years now, it was one of the first bundles I bought on Fanatical after getting my Steam Deck. I was planning to finally play it this month (I need to free...

              I'm sure I will! It's been on my list for years now, it was one of the first bundles I bought on Fanatical after getting my Steam Deck. I was planning to finally play it this month (I need to free up space on my Steam Deck, it's only 64GB and even with the micro SD card, I think all the shaders have filled up the space), but this just pushed it to the front of the line~

              2 votes
    2. [2]
      teaearlgraycold
      Link Parent
      It just doesn't feel like it adds enough to the franchise to deserve a release. It would make more sense as a DLC or fan-made mod.

      It just doesn't feel like it adds enough to the franchise to deserve a release. It would make more sense as a DLC or fan-made mod.

      1 vote
      1. CannibalisticApple
        Link Parent
        Eh, I don't think we have enough info to make that claim. The leaked game is fairly short since it's basically a demo. At bare minimum, it would provide a lot of world-building information though...

        Eh, I don't think we have enough info to make that claim. The leaked game is fairly short since it's basically a demo. At bare minimum, it would provide a lot of world-building information though (seriously, seeing the lab when it was still a lab is fun).

        This clip makes me realize they could've had a whole series of Aperture Science games focusing on various unique mechanics. It's a good setting for exploring heavily mechanic-driven puzzle games like this.

        3 votes
  2. widedub
    Link
    Play testers famously did not like the camera mechanics and Valve gave it the axe. They took some inspiration from F-Stop and put it into Portal 2 but I can't help but wonder what we may have...

    Play testers famously did not like the camera mechanics and Valve gave it the axe. They took some inspiration from F-Stop and put it into Portal 2 but I can't help but wonder what we may have gotten if they had developed this to completion

    5 votes
  3. [2]
    gingerbeardman
    Link
    Apparently the leak has much more than this?

    Apparently the leak has much more than this?

    2 votes
    1. widedub
      Link Parent
      Seems like that's a the case! Sorry, I was excited and posted the first article I saw

      Seems like that's a the case! Sorry, I was excited and posted the first article I saw